

Sonoma Supervisors Approve $36M Fall Budget Plan as HR 1 Cuts Bite
Board of Supervisors • Sonoma CountyNovember 17, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
The Sonoma County Board of Supervisors spent the bulk of its Nov. 17, 2026, meeting on money and land. It approved roughly $36 million in one-time spending as federal HR 1 changes strip food and health benefits from residents and property tax growth slows. With Board Chair Rebecca Hermosillo absent, the four remaining supervisors also funded design of a permanent Asti bridge and put the brakes on a contested open space easement change at Adobe Creek in Petaluma.
- Fall budget approved 4-0: about $36M in one-time spending, mostly for infrastructure
- HR 1 fallout: 333 residents have lost CalFresh, and about 22,819 could lose Medi-Cal
- $4M for Asti bridge design after River Road residents rally behind a permanent crossing
- Adobe Creek easement continued after about 14 speakers, most of them opposed
- Russian River watershed coordination plan approved 4-0 with a recurring staff forum
- Housing Element zoning changes received three yes votes; no result was announced
Budget Bets on Infrastructure as Federal Cuts Land
Why it matters: The county has a cushion today, but staff warned the numbers tighten soon. Federal HR 1 changes are removing residents from CalFresh and Medi-Cal while property tax growth flattens.
Where things stand: Staff reported a $36.1M general fund year-end balance, with $30.4M available. The assessment roll grew 3.73%, but staff expects property tax revenue to come in at budget, not above it. Slight deficits are projected starting in fiscal year 2027-28.
County Executive David Guhin framed the item as unfinished business from the spring: “we deferred a lot of decisions and a lot of discussions and said we’d come back in November.”
HR 1 by the numbers: So far, 333 people have lost CalFresh benefits and 2,392 more are at risk. Staff estimated about 22,819 residents could lose Medi-Cal because of work requirements. The county has filled 33 of 38 added eligibility positions. Staff noted one-time state funds of $6M for Medi-Cal and $1.8M for CalFresh and recommended holding indigent healthcare reserves in place.
What got funded: Recommendations covered road repair, jail modernization, support for the Sonoma County Fair, an integrated justice system and sheriff training funds. They also included a $1.5M grant program to offset federal cuts. Supervisors favored keeping that program broad.
“I think that the ability to be nimble and to respond to urgent needs in real time will be critical going forward,” said Supervisor Lynda Hopkins, District 5.
Guerneville substation: Hopkins raised public safety concerns in Guerneville and the condition of the sheriff’s substation. The substation also houses the only 24/7 veterans shelter in unincorporated West County. “At times at that substation prior to 2016, we would have 4 deputy sheriffs on staff on duty at a time, and now it’s been reduced to 2,” said Sheriff Eddie Ingram. The building is more than 100 years old. Staff said five or six sites have been examined, and $500,000 is earmarked to begin design.
Animal Services: Animal control officers Cristiano Martinez, Anthony Valentino and Michaela Brunson thanked the board for expediting two time-limited officer positions. Brunson said 10 officers now cover three more cities. Ryan Williams of SEIU 1021 backed the positions. Staff said the positions are time-limited pending decisions on long-term animal services.
The other side: A public commenter who identified as an HIV advocate warned that SNAP and ADAP changes create a coverage gap for people with life-threatening illnesses. Hopkins pressed staff on keeping federally qualified health center care available to undocumented and trans residents. She also asked about airport staffing after a lapse. Public Infrastructure staff replied that “the board approved a second position to the airport to cover that shift.”
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The board received the report and amended the final budget, which required a 4/5 vote. It also changed department allocation lists. For: 4 (Coursey, Gore, Hopkins, Rabbitt), Against: 0, Absent: 1 (Hermosillo). Infrastructure, public safety and eligibility staff gain in the near term. Residents losing benefits depend on the reserves and grant program the county kept in place.
River Road Residents Win Asti Bridge Design Money
Why it matters: A permanent bridge would end the annual installation of a seasonal crossing near Cloverdale. Residents said it would also give them a safer evacuation route.
Where things stand: The budget package includes $4M to design a permanent Asti bridge. Supervisor James Gore, District 4, explained that a planned assessment district could not legally fund design separately. He said $3M has already been spent on environmental work. The design money is meant to make the project eligible for grants and set up a financing district vote.
The community push: Neighbors showed up in force. Cloverdale resident Preston Addison cited fisheries protection, shorter commutes and safety. River Road resident Eric Terreri cited a survey showing 90% support, with 82% saying they would vote in favor. He also described a fire chief’s offer of a volunteer station. Sam Wetton described fire evacuations across a one-lane bridge. A commenter named Jeffrey pledged grant work with the AVCL group to offset county costs.
“I hope this is precedent-setting because we have a number of seasonal temporary bridges in the Lower Russian River,” said Hopkins.
What’s next: Design proceeds, with residents moving toward a special district vote and grant applications.
Adobe Creek Easement Stalls Under Neighbor Fire
Why it matters: The proposal would loosen a county-held open space easement on a 115-acre former golf course at 1901 Frates Road in Petaluma. The land is restricted to golf course or open space in perpetuity. The amendment would allow subdivision into four parcels and could open a path to a 36-acre annexation application.
The basics: The request (ZPE26-0058) would amend easement sections 2, 3, 4, 5 and 8. It would add uses such as a commercial horse facility and sports and entertainment assembly, plus a 1,200-square-foot caretaker unit. Josh Miranda, Supervising Planner, Permit Sonoma, said the amendment “limits all future development on the property to a maximum of 35 feet in height and no more than 15% lot coverage for the property.”
Where things stand: Staff sought no decision, citing new public comments. Scott Orr, Director, Permit Sonoma, said “there has been an extreme amount of misinformation included in those public comments as well.” He added: “The easement cannot force an annexation. It cannot change the zoning code.”
The opposition: Neighbors raised concerns about environmental review, proximity to the airport, notice and trust.
- Jim Cota, a retired federal environmental attorney, said the changes can’t be defended without an initial study.
- Adobe Creek resident David Donenfield said 85 residents oppose the amendment.
- Former HOA treasurer Sue Gertz cited illegible public notices.
- Brian Oh, Petaluma’s community and economic development director, urged a joint county-city-community planning process.
- Petaluma Councilmember Janice Cater Thompson, speaking personally, asked the board to wait for Airport Commission input.
- Susan Kirks urged the county to buy the land as permanent open space.
The other side: Applicant Richard Coombs said there is no project or deal. He argued the current restrictive language blocks any use of the empty property and asked for a continuance to Dec. 15. Polo player Carl Haas proposed golf plus polo fields and stables away from the airport approach.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Supervisors were skeptical. “I don’t believe it is consistent with the board’s intent,” said Vice Chair Chris Coursey, Supervisor, District 3, referring to the 1990 board.
“I do think we have a project,” said Supervisor David Rabbitt, District 2.
Hopkins said “any kind of a modification should have a public benefit and a public good associated with that.”
No vote was taken. The board continued the item to a date uncertain and directed staff to work with the applicant on a full permitting pathway. That outcome gives neighbors and Petaluma a project-level review before any easement change.
Russian River Coordination Gets a Standing Forum
Why it matters: Supervisors said fragmented county and regional efforts are limiting river health.
Where things stand: An ad hoc committee of Gore and Hopkins, formed Jan. 26, gathered input from county departments and regional partners. Todd Hunstorfer, clean water analyst and ombudsperson in the County Executive’s Office, presented two recommendations. The first is a recurring county staff meeting and a watershed program directory. The second is funding support for an inclusive, watershed-wide conference, which had been postponed. The item also contemplated $75,000 for the Headwaters 2 Ocean conference.
Coursey asked staff to clarify “bimonthly.” Staff said it means every other month. Supervisors stressed tribal partnership and water management. Rabbitt said he wanted to “challenge future boards to continue the work to coordinate how we look at these big projects, especially water.”
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Gore moved the recommendations and Hopkins seconded. For: 4 (Coursey, Gore, Hopkins, Rabbitt), Against: 0, Absent: 1 (Hermosillo). There was no public comment.
Housing Element Rules Get Three Votes
Where things stand: Eric Gage, the project planner for Housing Element implementation, presented amendments to the county’s housing rules. The proposed changes would:
- Raise by-right cottage units from three to four
- Increase R-1 lot coverage from 40% to 50%
- Cap cottages at 1,200 square feet and 18 feet in height
- Layer local density bonuses on top of the state bonus without raising maximum density
- Allow up to 30 units per acre in the affordable housing combining district
- Update the 2003 reasonable accommodations ordinance
Why it matters: The changes aim to make affordable ownership and rental projects more workable under state density bonus law. They would nearly finish the county’s required Housing Element programs.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No one spoke during public comment. The roll call recorded three yes votes from Coursey, Hopkins and Rabbitt. Gore was not present, and Hermosillo was absent. No result was announced from the dais.
Minor Items
- Workers’ comp settlement: A $250,000 settlement with Alicia Reeves nets $160,437 after $89,563 in prior advances. Approved 4-0-1 in closed session.
- Consent calendar passed 4-0: Includes a $1.24M interim housing logistics contract and a $500,000 resilience grant program agreement. A public commenter praised the F.S. Global contract.
- Technical corrections adopted 4-0: Fixes a parcel mapping error, lot line conditions and zoning code text. No policy change.
- Gold Resolutions: Recognized Family Court Awareness Month, Compassion Without Borders’ 25 years and World AIDS Day (Dec. 1, 2026).
- General public comment: Bob Anderson urged cultural fire practices. Michelle McDonald sought interim wastewater solutions for Monte Rio and Villa Grande.
Looking Ahead
The Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District policy revisions (item 47) and a Sonoma Valley sewer trunk main property negotiation (item 5A) were continued to later dates. The Adobe Creek easement will return on a date not yet set. Permit Sonoma staff said they are exploring alternatives to the standing Acts and Determinations item, which informs the board of land use decisions within the 10-day appeal window.