Locunity — where decisions happen.
Oakland Committee Advances Consultant for $200M-a-Year Waste Deals

Oakland Committee Advances Consultant for $200M-a-Year Waste Deals

Public Works and Transportation Committee • OaklandNovember 17, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Oakland is getting ready to renegotiate the biggest agreements it signs: garbage, recycling and organics franchises worth about $200 million a year, with the first expiring June 30, 2030. On Nov. 17, 2026, the Public Works and Transportation Committee advanced a $1.11M consultant contract to guide those talks. Members also used the item to question a roughly $35 million-a-year franchise fee that voters never approved, and they cleared a $15.24M rail safety contract, a $35.9M housing grant fix and a reshuffled fleet repair deal, all headed to the City Council on Dec. 1, 2026.


  • $1.11M HF&H consulting deal advances ahead of 2030 waste franchise expirations. The roll call was garbled, so the exact tally is unclear.
  • $15.24M Embarcadero West rail safety contract goes to O.C. Jones & Sons on a 4-0 vote. State grants cover the work, including change orders.
  • Houston cuts Ford dealer's award in half and shifts $700,000 to local body shops (4-0).
  • Name-change fix unlocks $35.9M state housing award for 285 12th Street (4-0).

Waste Talks: Oakland Hires an Equalizer

Why it matters: The three 2015 franchise agreements set what Oakland households and businesses pay for trash, recycling and organics service. The city renegotiates them only once every 10 to 20 years.

"These three agreements reflect the largest agreements the city enters into on behalf of the community, with an annual revenue of around $200 million," said Rebecca Parnes, Recycling Program Manager, Oakland Public Works.

Where things stand: Staff recommended an agreement with HF&H Consultants worth up to $1,114,868, with $200,000 coming from Fund 1710. The team includes R3 Consulting Group and Environmental Justice Solutions. Three contracts are in play:

  • Waste Management's mixed materials and organics contract expires June 30, 2030.
  • California Waste Solutions' recycling contract runs to 2035.
  • Waste Management's disposal contract also runs to 2035.

Parnes argued the city is outmatched without outside help. "The city goes into negotiations once every 10 to 20 years, whereas solid waste companies negotiate with jurisdictions across the state all the time," she said. Staff said the scope also includes outreach to councilmembers and to other haulers, with the goal of drawing more bidders.

Councilmember Zac Unger, the committee chair, tried to keep the debate narrow: "This item is specifically about potentially engaging a consultant."

The other side: Members wanted to revisit the last round of negotiations before paying for a new one. Councilmember Ken Houston asked who negotiated last time and raised illegal dumping and the order of the talks. Staff said HF&H was not the city's prior consultant. Councilmember Charlene Wang asked how the city would avoid repeating past mistakes.

Councilmember Noel Gallo went after the franchise fee, which is about $35 million to $36 million a year. "We're one of the rare, rare cities that collects a franchise fee that the voters never approved," he said.

Parnes said the fee appears in the adopted budget. "Every city across the state of California that I'm familiar with charges franchise fees through their solid waste rates," she said.

Public commenter Asada Olabala said she hoped the consultant would help reduce illegal dumping. She urged the city to stop collecting unpaid Waste Management bills and placing liens on property after 2030.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Houston moved the item and Unger seconded. It was declared approved and sent to Council on consent. Gallo and Houston were recorded as ayes, but the clerk's tally was garbled and Wang's vote could not be heard, so the official count is unconfirmed. The incumbent haulers, Waste Management and California Waste Solutions, now face a city with dedicated negotiating help. Ratepayers have the most at stake in how the franchise fee is handled.

What's next: Council takes up the contract Dec. 1, 2026. Gallo's earlier request for staff briefings on the waste contracts, the franchise fee and Civic Corps will go through the Rules Committee.


Embarcadero West: Rail Safety on State Money

Why it matters: Jack London's rail corridor is one of Oakland's most dangerous stretches for people walking, biking and driving. "On average, about 65 trains use this corridor daily, with reported incidents occurring approximately once every 5 days on average," said Audrey Harris, Supervising Transportation Planner, Oakland Department of Transportation.

Where things stand: The $15,240,586.98 contract goes to O.C. Jones & Sons. Its bid was about 35% below the engineer's estimate, and it was one of five bids. Phase 1 covers a one-mile corridor and includes:

  • Modernized rail crossings at Market and Oak streets.
  • A new signal with rail preemption, which gives approaching trains priority.
  • An upgraded route for overweight trucks that moves them off 7th Street.
  • Protected bike lanes and wayfinding signs.

Construction is expected from spring 2027 to 2029. Houston asked who pays if costs rise. Change orders are capped at 25%, or about $3.8M. "That funding would come from 100% state grant funding through the California Transportation Agency," Harris said.

The other side: Wang asked whether bike lanes would conflict with freight traffic: "Has there been engagement done with the port and rail stakeholders to ensure that there's not going to be a conflict of interest here?" Staff cited coordination with the Port of Oakland, Union Pacific and the California Public Utilities Commission.

Wang also raised concerns from a nearby dialysis center. "There is very much a need for kind of an ADA-accessible loading zone," she said. Staff said the separate 2nd Street Transportation Hub project handles loading and curb ramps.

Public commenter Kevin Daly, a cyclist and rail commuter, welcomed the project. He said the bike-lane separation is not continuous and asked for physical traffic calming such as speed humps. Olabala asked how many phases the project will have, what it will cost in total and how each element is priced.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Wang moved and Gallo seconded. Vote: For: 4 (Gallo, Houston, Wang, Unger), Against: 0, Absent: 0. Freight operators, Jack London residents and cyclists all benefit, and local money is not at risk. Houston made a pitch for his district: "Next time this money comes around, can we trickle a little bit of this down to D7?"

What's next: Council considers the contract on consent Dec. 1, 2026.


Fleet Repairs: Houston Pushes Work to Local Shops

Why it matters: Council had already pushed staff to open city vehicle repair work to Oakland businesses. This vote reshaped the remaining $4.2M of a contract worth roughly $7M.

The basics: Rather than award one large contract, the city is splitting the work among several shops. "We will take that $7 million pie and break it up into different pieces with the goal of engaging more Oakland-based small businesses," said Richard Battersby, Assistant Director, Bureau of Maintenance and Internal Services, Oakland Public Works.

Where things stand: In July, the city made partial awards to Quality ($1.05M) and Moeller Brothers ($1.75M). Staff returned with four more recommended awards:

  • Ron DePrat Ford: $1.4M.
  • Turbo Auto Body: $700,000.
  • Experience Auto Body: $350,000.
  • Falcon Collision Repair: $1.75M, for heavy vehicles.

Outreach reached 23 light-duty shops, 15 of them in Oakland, and 19 heavy-duty shops, seven of them in Oakland.

Houston moved to shrink the Ford award. "I'd like to make a motion where instead of 40%, we turn 20%, which it'll be 80% local participation," he said. Staff said the change was workable. Battersby noted the city still needs a Ford dealer for some work: "We have to send stuff to the Ford to calibrate all of the fancy safety devices."

The other side: Wang and Gallo wanted assurances that quality would hold. "I want to make sure that I get your professional recommendation," Gallo said before seconding. Olabala asked about the cost of towing city vehicles to vendors in Dixon and Concord. She also argued that the city gives preference to local businesses but not to residents.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The amended motion cuts Ford's award to $700,000 and splits the other $700,000 equally among the remaining local businesses. Vote: For: 4 (Gallo, Houston, Wang, Unger), Against: 0, Absent: 0. Oakland body shops gain city work, and the Ford dealership keeps a smaller share tied to safety-system calibration.

What's next: Council considers the contracts on consent Dec. 1, 2026.


Housing Grant: Paperwork Fix Unlocks $35.9M

Where things stand: The state's Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities program awarded $35,873,066 for the 285 12th Street project. The award includes a loan of about $20.4M and about $14M for three city street projects: the 7th Street Connection, MLK Complete Streets and Broadway Transit. The original resolution named the wrong payee. The amendment substitutes 285 Development, LP, which is affiliated with EBALDC, for 285 12th Street, LP.

"It's just the name change, nothing about the loan terms, the projects, nothing about the terms of the agreement change," said Emily Ellers, a staff presenter with the Oakland Department of Transportation.

Why it matters: The state will not release the money until the resolution names the correct recipient. The site will have 65 homes, or 168 when counted with the related Liberation Park project on 73rd Avenue.

The other side: Olabala criticized members for asking few questions about a housing item of this size. She asked where the housing is, who can live there and who the developer is.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Wang moved and Gallo seconded. Vote: For: 4 (Gallo, Houston, Wang, Unger), Against: 0, Absent: 0. The item goes to Council on consent Dec. 1, 2026.


  • Pending list: Approved without changes, 4-0. Olabala asked when a 373-page parks assessment that flags ADA compliance problems will reach the committee.
  • OakDOT director: Daly urged members to set priorities for the vacant director post: traffic safety, ADA access and paving. He praised acting director Megan Weir.
  • Surveillance tech: Public commenter Blair Beekman said San Diego ended its license plate reader (ALPR), Flock and smart streetlight programs, and that Oakland's review process should learn from it.

Looking ahead: All four action items go to the City Council on consent Dec. 1, 2026. Under Oakland's new charter, the Council will also confirm or reject the mayor's nominee for transportation director.