Community Rallies to Protect El Granada's Open Space as Board Juggles Ambitious Plans

The Granada Community Services District's Sept. 17 meeting laid bare the tension at the heart of this small Coastside community's future: big ambitions for parks, a recreation center and land preservation — and a limited tax base that can't fund them all at once. Five residents turned out to plead for action on the Burnham Strip before state housing laws open the door to private development, while a nonprofit offered a surprise lifeline for a stalled community building.

• Residents urge GCSD to pursue Burnham Strip and post office lot parcels before developers move in under state housing mandates
• Senior Coastsiders offers to fund construction of paused community building in exchange for shared use
• Recology presents 4.41% garbage rate increase as diesel tops $9 per gallon — final year of current contract
• Park permitting clears a major hurdle, avoiding federal jurisdiction; design-build RFQ for recreation center nearly ready
• Board approves retroactive lot-use deal after county contractor sets up on GCSD land without permission
• Sewer authority locks in force main contract pricing and braces for record El Niño storm risks

---

Save the Strip: El Granada Fights to Keep Its Open-Space Gateway

Five community members delivered impassioned testimony urging the GCSD board to take concrete steps toward acquiring parcels on the Burnham Strip and the former post office lot before private developers exploit state housing laws to build on them. The discussion — the longest of the evening — exposed deep community anxiety about El Granada's identity and the board's constrained finances.

The basics: Staff presented a parcel map identifying GCSD, Harbor District and privately owned lots on the Burnham Strip and near the post office. One private Burnham Strip parcel is listed at $699,000. The post office lot, owned by the Harbor District, was listed as surplus in 2022 with no bids received and appraised at $880,000 for commercial use. Two additional Harbor District parcels are being maintained but have not been declared surplus; the Harbor District has tentative plans for Deer Creek daylighting on one of them.

Why it matters: Community members warned that state laws authored by State Senator Scott Wiener increasingly enable by-right residential development on parcels like these, potentially eliminating El Granada's last open-space buffers. Multiple speakers cited the community's long history of fighting to preserve the Burnham Strip's character.

Where things stand: Public commenter Lenny set the tone, urging the board to open formal negotiations with the Harbor District: "Let's not let this go. Let's not let this slip through. The community is going to lose out again if we don't. So I'm just urging you to initiate some kind of formal talks with the Harbor District at least and explore acquiring that post office lot and try to negotiate with them at least for time."

Janet Briner concurred and asked GCSD to pursue a standstill agreement, first right of refusal, option, donation or swap with the Harbor District. Dan warned about state housing laws and urged the board to start setting aside funds. Brigitte read a detailed statement on the history of the El Granada Gateway zoning, created to preserve the Burnham Strip's visual and open-space character, and cited the Harbor District's prior attempts to use the land for beach parking.

The other side: Kevin of Coastline Allies supported preservation but pushed back on the adversarial tone toward the Harbor District: "I think that the more that we put down the Harbor District and call them the bad guys in this scenario, it doesn't create a win or an open door for us necessarily. I hope that we can address that as neighbors, as community members and as friends."

Assistant General Manager Hope Batmore explained the legal process: "When a public agency owns property and decides they don't need it or want it, they are required to go through a process where they list that surplus property. They have to send out notices to housing development groups and other parks and recreation agencies."

Board Director Nancy Marsh provided the most detailed financial analysis, cautioning that the planned $2–3 million recreation center renovation could consume 100% of the district's regular property tax allocation for 20 to 30 years. She prioritized acquiring parcels contiguous to the existing park over the post office lot and floated creative alternatives: "I love the food truck lots in Hawaii and in Portland up north. It could be something that they lease to two or three food trucks which gives dining opportunities to the community."

Decisions: No acquisition action was taken. Board President Barbara Dye framed the outcome carefully: "I am not at this point proposing or even supporting the notion that we'll start thinking about making offers on these lots. But I want us to pay attention." The board agreed to keep the issue on future agendas and maintain dialogue with the Harbor District without making offers at this time.

What's next: Staff will continue monitoring the parcels. The board signaled it will revisit land priorities as financial constraints from the recreation center project become clearer.

---

A Surprise Lifeline for the Stalled Community Building

Sandy Winter, Executive Director of Senior Coastsiders, made an unexpected proposal during public comment that could revive a paused GCSD capital project at no cost to the district.

Why it matters: The 49-year-old nonprofit, which provides home-delivered meals, transportation and care management from Montara to Pescadero, is searching for a satellite site north of Half Moon Bay as its service population grows — one in four Coastside residents is now 65 or older.

Where things stand: Winter proposed that Senior Coastsiders fund construction of the planned community building near the former Picasso preschool site in exchange for daytime use: "We're prepared to bring real resources to this project, potentially funding construction of the building in exchange for use of the space. And in the spirit of true partnership, we would collaborate with GCSD to offer the building for community programs on evenings and weekends."

The organization plans a major fundraising campaign for its 50th anniversary in 2027. The board expressed strong interest but could not discuss the proposal during public comment under Brown Act rules.

What's next: Director Marsh added the proposal as a future agenda item, and staff was directed to research it.

---

Recology Rate Hike: Last Round Before Big Contract Negotiation

Ryan Gordon of Recology presented a 4.41% index-based rate increase for 2027, the final adjustment under the current five-year contract.

Why it matters: Next year's contract negotiation will set garbage, recycling and green waste rates for the rest of the decade, making this year's numbers the baseline.

Where things stand: The increase is driven by disposal costs, vehicle maintenance and diesel fuel that has crossed $9 per gallon. "Diesel has now gone over $9 per gallon. So on average each one of our collection vehicles is spending about $500 a day on gas," Gordon said. He noted Recology is an employee-owned company, and labor costs reflect collectively bargained driver increases.

Board members and the public praised El Granada's low rates, which staff attributed to residents' strong recycling and sorting habits. Kevin of Coastline Allies asked about assistance for seniors on fixed incomes. Gordon recommended downsizing to the smallest available container: "A 20-gallon can is the smallest can we offer. So that would probably be my first recommendation, especially if they have a can that they're bringing out and it's only half full."

The item was informational and required no vote.

---

Park Permitting Clears Federal Hurdle; Recreation Center RFQ Nearly Ready

GCSD's flagship community park and 480 building renovation project hit several milestones.

Why it matters: Avoiding federal permitting jurisdiction significantly shortens the regulatory timeline for the park, while the financial advisor selection and design-build RFQ move the recreation center toward construction.

Where things stand: The project team determined that regulatory permitting can proceed under a statewide general order rather than federal jurisdiction, because the site's drainage is considered small enough to qualify. Staff is preparing responses to agency comments on the Coastal Development application.

For the 480 building, a Request for Qualifications is nearly finalized. The design-build scope was expanded to include sidewalks, the parking lot, patio and connecting elements — not just the building itself. General Manager Chuck Duffy reported the district selected Ridgeland as its financial advisor after scoring five proposals: "We've decided to go with Ridgeland and they also had the best pricing. So it was a very smooth process."

Director Matt Allen was appointed as the board's representative for the skate element design work (approved by voice vote, 5-0). Public commenter Michelle Dragony raised the possibility of using a lease-leaseback construction method, which Legal Counsel Bill Parkin noted is a complex alternative.

Director Marsh cautioned that the $2–3 million cost estimate for the 480 renovation remains unvetted and that long-term financing could consume the district's entire regular property tax allocation for decades — a constraint that loomed over the evening's land acquisition discussion as well.

---

County Contractor Moves Onto GCSD Land Without Asking

In a special meeting preceding the regular session, the board addressed an unusual property trespass: VSS International, a contractor for a San Mateo County Public Works road resurfacing project in Miramar and Montara, began staging gravel and aggregate on GCSD's dirt lot the previous Friday without authorization.

Where things stand: The contractor apparently believed the lot belonged to the county based on vague prior conversations and had used the lot years ago. Assistant General Manager Hope Batmore explained: "They neglected to get permission or to reach out to the district about using the lot. VSS had used the lot years ago, and in their minds that meant that it was fine. And they were sort of under the impression that it belonged to the county, not to the district."

After a Monday meeting with the county Director of Public Works, VSS's on-site manager and the county project manager, staff negotiated conditions: the lot must remain partially accessible, the skate ramp must stay open, and VSS must consolidate materials over the weekend. A standard temporary use agreement was set at $1,000 plus $200 per day for overruns, retroactive to Friday.

President Dye emphasized accountability: "It's the responsibility of the contractor to find a yard. It's not the responsibility of the county to tell them where they can have it."

General Manager Duffy said the district plans to send preemptive ownership notices to Caltrans and the county ahead of a 2027 resurfacing project: "We're going to send out an email to Caltrans and the county, saying, yes, someone indeed does own that lot. It's us. You can't use it like that. And be preemptive."

Decisions: The board approved the retroactive use agreement 4-0-1. Director Allen abstained because he arrived late and missed the discussion.

---

Sewer Authority Locks In Prices, Braces for Record Storm Season

Director Marsh reported on two recent Sewer Authority Mid-Coastside board meetings covering infrastructure and emergency preparedness.

Why it matters: The force main project protects Coastside sewage capacity, while a severe El Niño forecast raises unprecedented flooding risks at the treatment plant.

SAM approved a budget adjustment enabling the McGuire and Hester force main contract to be signed, and pipe was ordered at July pricing as costs continue to rise. Subsidiary support contracts for construction management, environmental monitoring, soil testing and outreach were also approved. A closed session addressed cybersecurity for both business and SCADA operations.

Staff presented a detailed Super El Niño preparedness review. Marsh warned that Kelvin waves could compound the threat: "6 to 12 inches of additional ocean level plus king tides in January could be an unprecedented and major event."

She also noted that all GCSD service calls to SAM's collections crew turned out to be lateral or cleanout issues, not mainline problems.

---

Minor Items

• Eucalyptus fuel reduction completed: Kevin of Coastline Allies reported that Parks and Rec finished clearing a 50-foot defensible space margin behind El Granada Boulevard. The organization is advancing a county-supported home hardening grant program and investigating new fire retardant technology. A proposed process would give negligent property owners 60 days to remove hazardous vegetation or face county removal with a lien. Kevin noted many residents on the eastern side of El Granada Boulevard have lost their homeowners insurance due to wildfire risk.
• New classes and events: Staff launched Drawing Level 2 and Friday Hatha/Vinyasa yoga classes with growing enrollment. The Great Shakeout drill with CERT is Sept. 26 at the 480 building. GCSD is again a silver-level sponsor of the El Granada PTO fund run on Oct. 2. Quarterly recycling day is Oct. 10. The El Granada Winter Festival is planned for Dec. 19 at the 480 building, moved indoors due to forecast severe El Niño conditions.
• Consent agenda approved 5-0 without discussion.
• Sewer permit applications rising as the county lifts its building moratorium, signaling resumed development activity on the Coastside.