Locunity — where decisions happen.
Wildcat Flow Trail Critics, Youth Riders Press Board Before Draft EIR

Wildcat Flow Trail Critics, Youth Riders Press Board Before Draft EIR

Board of Directors • East Bay Regional Park DistrictNovember 17, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

The fight over a proposed mountain bike flow trail in Wildcat Canyon Regional Park took up nearly an hour of the East Bay Regional Park District board's Nov. 17, 2026, meeting. About 15 speakers urged directors to shape a draft environmental impact report before its release, and the board did not respond. Directors also previewed a 2027 budget that balances now but shows gaps from 2028, extended a youth workforce pilot and raised their own meeting pay on a split vote.


  • Wildcat flow trail debate dominates public comment as critics question the science, costs and outreach, while youth riders push for approval
  • 2027 budget balanced, but shortfalls projected of $2.8M in 2028, rising to about $12M by 2031
  • Civicorps and Urban Tilth workforce contracts extended on two 6-0 votes
  • Vacancy rate falls to 6.05%, while AFSCME presses for data on why women leave
  • Directors adopt a 5% per diem increase, 5-1, with Director Dennis Waespi opposed

Wildcat Flow Trail Fight Fills Public Comment

Why it matters: A draft environmental impact report (EIR) is expected soon for the Wildcat bike trail. An EIR is the detailed environmental study California requires for projects with potentially significant impacts. Speakers asked the board to direct new studies, surveys, tribal consultation and cost disclosure before the report is released.

Where things stand: Opponents built a layered case against the project. John Taylor, a UC Berkeley biology professor, said the biological assessment used a narrow study area and left out Fish and Wildlife report text on tar plant seed dispersal. “Corrupt science begins with conclusions and then picks facts to fit them,” said Taylor.

RJ Dyer, a public commenter, contrasted Wildcat with the Briones pilot, which legalized existing trails. He cited 94 incidents, 363 staff hours and 30 citations at Briones. “Wildcat is the opposite case. A new machine-built one-way downhill trail with berms and jumps laid on open grassland mapped as critical habitat for 2 listed species,” said Dyer. He asked that the EIR compare the two.

Other critics raised more specific concerns:

  • Stuart Bell cited Pleasanton Ridge monitoring that showed native grassland declining after trail construction.
  • Leslie Goldstein noted that the district's own grant documents describe trails as sediment sources. “There is no sediment study of San Pablo Ridge,” she said.
  • Bara Sapir described tracked changes in the biological assessment. She asked that the EIR's biology chapter be written without edits from project staff.
  • Norma Wallace, an Ohlone and Miwok descendant, asked the board to confirm that tribal consultation is complete.
  • Marilyn Langlois of Friends of Wildcat Canyon Park reported a volunteer survey of 934 park users. About 9 in 10 had never heard of the project, and about 1 in 10 supported it after hearing a description.
  • Debbie Bayer asked what the trail has cost so far. She cited a $261,000 Ascent Environmental contract and a $300,000 to $400,000 construction estimate.

Janet Flint, also of Friends of Wildcat Canyon Park, read from her notes of a meeting with Director Elizabeth Echols (Ward 1). According to the notes, Echols said she does not support the project as proposed. Flint acknowledged the notes might contain errors.

The other side: Parents and coaches of high school mountain bike teams said a local flow trail would give young riders, including those who can't drive, a safe place to ride and learn stewardship. Berna Bowie, a youth coach, called it a safe space for nervous young riders. Setsuko Wakaio, a Berkeley High School Mountain Bike Club volunteer coach, said it would divert riders from crowded hiking trails. “But there is one thing our team can't provide: a better trail for our kids to ride close to home,” said Jenny Fowler, President of the El Cerrito High School Mountain Biking Board.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No action was taken. Most opponents framed their requests as direct questions to the board, and none were answered. The split pits neighborhood and conservation advocates, led by Friends of Wildcat Canyon Park, against youth cycling families in El Cerrito and Berkeley.

What's next: The draft EIR's release will open formal public comment. Watch whether it includes Briones comparisons, a sediment baseline and full cost figures.


Budget Balanced for 2027, Gaps Loom From 2028

Why it matters: The district's general fund balances next year, but recurring costs outpace revenue starting in 2028.

Where things stand: Staff project about $294M in all-funds revenue, “an increase of $9.4 million or 3.3% over 2026,” said Jonah, the district's Chief Financial Officer. Appropriations total $354M. The CFO said the year-over-year decline comes mostly from paused capital appropriations and reduced transfers.

The general fund balance would grow by about $500,000 and sit about $12.8M above the district's 32% reserve policy. The budget adds 5.25 net new positions. Capital fund balances total $115.9M, and staff plan to close dormant projects.

“The projected shortfall then in 2028 is $2.8 million, with it going out to 2031 going as high as $12 million,” the CFO said. Those projections exclude roughly $11M in annual investment income.

Directors praised the presentation. “I was thinking doom and gloom, and you guys put it all out here, and I'm very confident that we're in really good shape,” said Director Dennis Waespi (Ward 3), the board's treasurer. Director Colin Coffey (Ward 7) was more cautious: “I would like to have an idea of how reliable will it be to find some money in fund balances without going into our reserves.”

The other side: Amelia Marshall of the Regional Parks Association said the budget under-invests in natural and cultural resources relative to administration. She recommended elevating Stewardship to a division led by an assistant general manager and hiring a historic preservation officer. “The way an agency actually spends public money is the true reflection of its values,” she said. Jim Hansen, Conservation Chair of the California Native Plant Society East Bay, cited declining rare wildflower populations and asked for a larger natural resources team.

Earlier, volunteer Maggie Clark had urged the board to keep supporting the Park Wildlife Volunteer Program, which has logged over 52,000 volunteer hours. “I'm not aware of any programs such as that being cut,” the CFO said, adding that he would look into it.

What's next: No action was taken. Board President Olivia Sanwong (Ward 5) said the board will vote at its next meeting on Dec. 1, 2026. The CFO cited Dec. 11 for final adoption.


Workforce Pathways Pilot Gets Another Year

Why it matters: The program is the district's bet on building a hiring pipeline from youth conservation crews.

Where things stand: “The Workforce Pathways Program was developed in 2025 to address the Park District's new workforce equity goal,” said Claire Griffing, Management Analyst in the General Manager's Office. The district received five proposals through its request for proposals. Civicorps reported nearly 13,500 hours of work, more than 100 corps members and 40 job placements. Urban Tilth runs a watershed crew in the Richmond area.

An unidentified director asked how the program differs from earlier contracts. General Manager Max Korten called it a more intentional pilot built with labor partners. He said the key measure of success is hiring: “we hired 3 people in this last year coming out of Civic Corps.”

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Directors approved the extensions separately.

  • Civicorps: moved by Director Luana Espana (Ward 4) and seconded by Director John Mercurio (Ward 6). For: 6, Against: 0, Absent: 1 (Deschambault).
  • Urban Tilth ($65,000): moved by Director Echols and seconded by Director Coffey. For: 6, Against: 0, Absent: 1.

The one-year terms give staff time to gather more data before a multi-year procurement.


Vacancy Rate Falls; Union Presses for Exit Data

Why it matters: State law (AB 2561) requires an annual vacancy report. The district's largest union used the hearing to press on retention.

Where things stand: “The district has a vacancy rate of 6.05%. Last year at this time, it was 7.8%,” said Jessica Romeo, Assistant General Manager of Human Resources. The time from requisition to an eligible hiring list fell from 140 days to 85.

The other side: Meadow Darcy, Chief Steward of AFSCME Local 2428, said 52% of voluntary resignations were women, though women make up 38% of the workforce. “There's no information about why people resign,” she said, and she called for exit-interview data and retention goals. Chris, an AFSCME union representative, questioned the district's reliance on recurring contracts: “Why do we not have an archaeologist?”

That push for in-house cultural resources staff echoed the Regional Parks Association's call for a historic preservation officer during the budget item.

Romeo clarified how the district collects exit feedback: “It is not a postcard, by the way. It is a survey. It is an email survey.”

What's next: Board President Sanwong floated creating a personnel committee, or folding those duties into an existing committee, during the 2027 review of board guidelines.


Directors Raise Own Per Diem 5% on Split Vote

District counsel noted that the resolution left the percentage blank and recommended the full 5% allowed. Director Mercurio, who made the motion, said the rate was frozen at $100 in 1980 and would be $457 today if it had kept pace with Bay Area inflation. The increase brings the per diem to about $144 per meeting. No one spoke at the public hearing.

Decision: Moved by Mercurio and seconded by Espana. For: 5, Against: 1 (Waespi), Absent: 1 (Deschambault).


Minor Items

  • Trout stocking: Directors approved a five-year, $2.5M contract with Mount Lassen Trout Farms ($500,000 a year at $5.50 per pound) to stock six district lakes. It was the only bidder. Vote: 6-0.
  • Pest control: Pestech won a three-year on-call contract of up to $900,000 covering more than 120 structures. Annual use averages about $170,000. Vote: 6-0.
  • Danville land donation: The board accepted a free 1.109-acre Shiloh parcel next to Burrell Agricultural Park and appropriated $97,000 for fencing, gates and cleanup. Vote: 6-0.
  • Tilden steam trains: Ellen Thompson, owner of the Redwood Valley Railway Company, said the company has sought a contract renewal for eight years and the trains may have to leave Tilden. The district did not respond.
  • Fuels and storms: Korten said fire-fuels work is in “the most critical season right now.” He also noted a Tiger Dam project at Crown Beach with the City of Alameda.

Looking Ahead

The board is set to vote on the 2027 budget at its Dec. 1, 2026, meeting; the CFO cited Dec. 11 for final adoption. The Wildcat trail draft EIR is expected soon.

Wildcat Flow Trail Critics, Youth Riders Press Board Before Draft EIR | Board of Directors | Locunity