

Woodfin Eyes $175,000 Manager, April Start as Search Kicks Off
Town Council • WoodfinNovember 20, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Woodfin's Town Council spent a Nov. 20, 2026, special meeting defining the town's next chief administrator: experienced, collaborative and willing to push back on Buncombe County. Consultants from the Piedmont Triad Regional Council used a live survey workshop to gather council priorities. They then laid out a tentative schedule that would post the job Dec. 8 and could seat a new manager by April 1.
- Manager search timeline set: posting Dec. 8 to Jan. 11, interviews in February
- $175,000 called "market" for the job, with no council objection
- Greenway delays frame the job: council wants a manager who will press the county
- No residency mandate: council favors North Carolina experience and ICMA ties
- Pitch to candidates: clean audits and no property tax increase for two years
A Spring Hire, If the Calendar Holds
The basics: The council has hired the Piedmont Triad Regional Council, a regional government consortium, to run its town manager search. The manager is the town's top appointed official and runs daily operations for the elected council.
Why it matters: The schedule and criteria set at this workshop determine when Woodfin gets a permanent chief administrator and who applies.
Where things stand: Consultant Matt Reese of the Piedmont Triad Regional Council said his team will build a community and position profile from the council's survey answers and photos. The posting will run through the consultants' portal, which links to major search engines. The town will also share it on social media and email lists.
"So the application period will be 12/8 to January 11th, and that's that first open window," said Reese.
After the window closes, the consultants would deliver a report by Jan. 18 and identify finalists around the 27th. Interviews would follow in the first and second weeks of February. Reese said a start date could be March 22, but April 1 is more likely. The job stays open past the first-review date, so later applicants can still be considered.
Vetting the field: Reese described a reference process the firm uses with every search. "Part of the process that we've always used that I'm assuming you all are going to want us to use is what I refer to as a soft background check," he said in response to a question from Councilmember Philip Cohen. The check includes 360-degree calls to people the firm knows, which Reese said is harder for candidates outside North Carolina.
Interviews will draw on a battery of 18 to 25 questions split among council members. Reese advised members not to ask the questions they care about most. Councilmember Johanna Young asked about personality assessments such as the Big 5. Reese said the firm has no emotional-intelligence tool in this scope and recommended using such tools for development, not screening. He named an outside firm in Charlotte that offers assessments at a cost in the high single-digit thousands.
The unanimity bar: Reese said the council should hire only on a unanimous vote. If the council splits, "it's my recommendation we keep working through that process," he said.
Confidentiality: Mayor Jim McAllister said applicant names must stay protected and suggested closed sessions or off-site interviews. "That has to remain more than 100% confidential," he said.
What's next: Council members were asked to send their out-of-town dates to staff so interviews can be scheduled. The mayor also asked members to review his edits to the job description before the posting goes live.
Paying for Competence: The $175,000 Question
Why it matters: Salary determines whether Woodfin can draw seasoned candidates, and the council signaled it would rather pay up for one strong manager than add staff.
Where things stand: Reese floated $175,000 and $160,000. No council member objected, and Reese called $175,000 the market rate.
Sherry, the Town Manager, said the current manager's salary sits slightly below the median in the League of Municipalities survey for towns of 5,000 to 10,000 residents. She said $175,000 could be justified for a very experienced hire and $140,000 might be fair for someone with less experience. Salaries in the survey range from about $90,000 to $240,000. "It would not be unreasonable to go above or below that number a little bit based on experience," she said. She will send the survey to the council.
McAllister cited the reported pay package for Asheville's new city manager as a regional benchmark.
The assistant trade-off: Councilmember Maxwell "Chip" Parton III framed the choice directly. "I would be inclined to pay more for a competent town manager than less for a less competent town manager and an assistant," he said. Reese said whether a town needs an assistant manager depends on the organization.
Qualifications: Survey results showed a strong lean toward candidates with North Carolina public administration experience. On membership in the International City/County Management Association (ICMA), the profession's main trade group, Reese noted its ethics code includes a two-year commitment to a post. He disclosed he is a member and has some bias.
Members discussed a typical manager tenure of two to three years. Reese said five to seven years is closer to average and advised the council to rely on employment agreements to secure stability.
On residency, Young said she would prefer that the manager live in town but valued proximity. Parton agreed that proximity matters. McAllister said the council is not "pounding the table" on a residency rule.
The council also ranked seven dimensions of manager work. Classic administration came first. Budget administration ranked lower because members said current staff are competent. Reese recommended against using personality screening as a gate.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No vote on pay was taken. The council's tolerance for a figure near $175,000, and its openness to nonresidents, widens the pool beyond town limits. It also puts Woodfin in direct competition with larger neighbors for experienced managers.
The County Test: Greenway Delays Shape the Job
Why it matters: Council members repeatedly cast the Buncombe County relationship as the defining challenge for the next manager, with the long-delayed Greenway as Exhibit A.
Where things stand: Cohen explained the arrangement. "The agreement with Buncombe County is that Buncombe County is the agent for building the Greenway," he said. Ownership passes to Woodfin once construction is complete. Young said the project began more than 12 years ago.
McAllister said the county keeps pushing construction out. He named the next manager's task as "motivating the county staff to move our greenways way up the list."
Young wants a fighter. The manager "needs to be a person who is not afraid to put their elbows out," she said. She also pointed to a structural squeeze on the town's tax base: "So we have almost 2 miles of our 9 miles are part of government use. So we don't get the taxes."
The other side: Councilmember Ken Kahn, who sits on the Greenway committee, pushed back on the mayor's account. "Money is in the bank, and I will politely disagree with the characterization," he said. He added that the county is moving as fast as it can.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Members described Woodfin as the area's "redheaded stepchild." They said the manager needs diplomacy and tact but also a willingness to stand up for the town. Cohen added that the county may approach Woodfin late about land opportunities, so the town should be more proactive.
The disagreement between McAllister and Kahn was civil but real. It shows the council is not of one mind on whether the county is a slow partner or a stalled one. Candidates will need to read that split.
Selling Woodfin: Clean Books and No Tax Hikes
Why it matters: These talking points will anchor how the consultants market Woodfin to applicants, and they show what the council considers its record.
Where things stand: Cohen pitched the town as fiscally steady, "with a balanced budget, lives within its means, and for the last 2 years has not raised its property taxes." He noted that neighboring jurisdictions raised theirs. Kahn added that "we've had 4 and probably 5 consecutive years of clean audits."
Sherry offered a reminder of how recent that turnaround is. She said the town was on a watch list the year before the clean audits began, and she described code updates that followed lawsuits. Cohen credited a sea change in staff and governance.
Public safety: Cohen and McAllister praised the police chief's community engagement, grant work and career ladder. They said the department is at or near full staffing.
Who lives here: Parton raised affordability and the generational families rooted in town. Young said Woodfin's demographics span $3 million homes and residents who have little.
What candidates must know: McAllister flagged limits on the town's reach. "The town does not control the water system," he said. Woodfin also has no town-run fire department, a distinction he said candidates need to understand.
Minor Items
- Agenda trimmed: The council limited the session to the manager-search contract. Councilmember Ken Kahn moved to approve the agenda; no result was announced.
- Next-day session canceled: On a motion by Parton, seconded by Young, the council passed an amendment by voice vote to cancel the following day's session and reschedule it for a later date, possibly January. The tally was not stated.
- No action on contract: Despite the agenda topic, no vote on the Piedmont Triad Regional Council contract was recorded.
- Adjournment: The council adjourned by voice vote at 1:19 p.m.
Looking Ahead
The posting is slated to open Dec. 8, with interviews in early February. Residents who want a say should watch for the job description the mayor has asked colleagues to review, and for the rescheduled council session.