Locunity — where decisions happen.
95-Unit Northfield Avenue Project Draws Recusal Bid, Hearing Carried to Dec. 2

95-Unit Northfield Avenue Project Draws Recusal Bid, Hearing Carried to Dec. 2

Planning Board • West OrangeNovember 5, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

A 95-unit mixed-use proposal at 525 Northfield Avenue took up most of the West Orange Planning Board's November meeting. An objector's attorney tried to remove the mayor and the board chair from the case over affordable housing talks, and neighbors pressed the owner on slopes, stormwater, trees and lighting. The board's attorney rejected the conflict claim, and after more than three hours of testimony the hearing was carried to Dec. 2, 2026. Earlier, the board quickly advanced a senior-care district at the Daughters of Israel site, part of the township's strategy to show it is meeting its affordable housing obligations.


  • 525 Northfield Avenue hearing carried to Dec. 2 after a recusal fight, cross-examination and neighbor testimony
  • Board attorney rejects conflict claim against the mayor and chair tied to a 60-unit fair-share figure
  • Owner offers more and taller plantings and removal of parking stackers after public questioning
  • Senior-care district at Daughters of Israel site found consistent with the master plan and sent to the council

Northfield Avenue: Recusal Fight, Slope Worries

The basics: A "builder's remedy" is a court-ordered path that can let developers override local zoning when a town lacks a certified affordable housing plan. A "fair-share" plan sets out how a town will meet its affordable housing obligation.

Why it matters: The dispute shows how builder's remedy leverage, and a 60-unit figure tied to the township's fair-share plan, are shaping the review of a 95-unit building. The building is nearly 60% larger than that figure.

Where things stand: Attorney James Turtletaub, representing an objector, alleged a conflict of interest. He pointed to emails about a 60-unit plan for the site and to language about waiving a builder's remedy, and asked the mayor and Board Chair Robert Bagoff to recuse themselves.

Board Attorney Diana P. McGovern said Bagoff attended no such meetings. She also said the application carries no density limit.

"So there is no conflict here. There is absolutely no conflict," said McGovern.

The hearing then turned to the project itself. The applicant is 525 Northfield Avenue LLC, represented by attorney Marsha Moore. Thomas Ricci, the applicant's planner, was cross-examined on setbacks and parapet height. Owner Pedro Gomes answered public questions about trees, deer, parking stackers, how visible the fence would be, a smoke-free policy and construction timing. In response, Gomes offered more and taller plantings and agreed to remove the stackers.

Richard Gajdek, a witness for the objector, described slope erosion and stormwater flooding and showed photos.

The other side: Neighbors focused on how the building would affect the homes around it:

  • Sacha Eaton, a Lenox Terrace resident, said homes at the top of the slope can see the site in winter and that lights shine into them.
  • Beverly Riley warned that deer eat arborvitae, a common screening shrub. She also flagged a blind spot the fence would create at Sheridan Avenue.
  • Richard Mensah asked that the building be scaled back toward 60 units and raised concerns about property values.
  • Not every speaker was opposed. Laz, a Watson Avenue resident, supported the ground-floor restaurant space and the cleanup of the vacant site.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The board took no vote. The hearing was carried without any new notice to neighbors.

  • Neighbors on the slope face more hearings over height, stormwater and screening.
  • The developer has made concessions on landscaping and parking but has not cut the unit count.
  • The board must weigh the variance requests while the township tries to protect itself from builder's remedy lawsuits.

What's next: The hearing resumes Dec. 2, 2026. A special meeting is possible.


Senior-Care District Clears Planning Board

Why it matters: The site is a designated piece of the township's fourth-round housing element, the part of its master plan covering affordable housing. That plan is aimed at winning court certification of compliance and immunity from builder's remedy lawsuits.

Where things stand: Board planner Lindsay Messiah reviewed Ordinance 2999-26. It creates a continuing care retirement community (CCRC) district, a zone for senior housing that offers several levels of care on one campus.

The district applies only to Block 171, Lot 12, where the Daughters of Israel nursing home sits. The ordinance includes affordable senior units.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Bagoff moved to recommend that the council adopt the ordinance as consistent with the 2019 Master Plan and the fourth-round housing element. The motion passed on a roll-call vote; individual tallies were not available.

  • Daughters of Israel gains zoning tailored to its campus.
  • Seniors needing affordable units move a step closer to new options.
  • The township advances a compliance piece of its housing strategy.

What's next: The board attorney will prepare a report for Bagoff's signature. The ordinance then returns to the town council for adoption.


Minor Items

  • Fire stations: Renovations to Fire Stations 1 and 3 (PB26-06) were found consistent with the master plan.
  • Crestmont Country Club (PB26-03): The application will be re-noticed and carried to Dec. 2, 2026.
  • 27 Fairway Drive (PB26-02): The hearing was adjourned to Dec. 2, 2026.
  • Housekeeping: The board adopted the Sept. 2, 2026, minutes, the July 22 executive-session minutes and the 2027 SPRAB meeting dates.

Looking Ahead

Dec. 2, 2026, is shaping up as a crowded night. The 525 Northfield Avenue hearing, Crestmont Country Club and 27 Fairway Drive are all set to return. Residents near Northfield Avenue should plan to attend, since no further notice will be mailed.

95-Unit Northfield Avenue Project Draws Recusal Bid, Hearing Carried to Dec. 2 | Planning Board | Locunity