Locunity — where decisions happen.
Ridgeway Flag-Lot Fight Carried to December After Marathon Hearing

Ridgeway Flag-Lot Fight Carried to December After Marathon Hearing

Planning Board • West OrangeOctober 22, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

A bid to carve two flag lots from one oversized Ridgeway parcel drew close to three hours of testimony and cross-examination before the West Orange Planning Board. Members heard objections on fire access, flooding and house size, then carried the hearing to Dec. 2 without a vote. Earlier, the board approved two one-year approval extensions and a legal services agreement.


  • 15 Ridgeway LLC subdivision carried to Dec. 2 after engineer and architect testimony
  • Fire access dominates: 14-foot, single-file driveway with no turnaround draws scrutiny
  • Applicant offers sprinklers in both homes to address emergency access concerns
  • Stormwater waiver requested as neighbors raise flooding fears
  • Chairman proposes barring basement living space in two 6,000-plus-square-foot homes

Ridgeway Subdivision Restarts, Then Stalls

The basics: A flag lot sits behind other properties and reaches the street through a narrow strip, or "stem." C variances are relief from dimensional rules such as setbacks and lot width. They are not relief from what can be built.

Where things stand: 15 Ridgeway LLC (PB26-01) wants to split Block 158, Lot 28.01 in the R4 zone into Lots 28.03 and 28.04. The parcel is a 53,804-square-foot flag lot reached by a shared access easement. The hearing started over from scratch after an earlier notice problem and a change of attorneys.

"The applicant is requesting limited C variance relief with respect to lot width, lot frontage, and rear yard setback for one of the 2 proposed lots," said Tyler Zerbel, attorney for the applicant with Spiro Harrison and Nelson. He argued the use itself is permitted.

William Scott, the applicant's engineer, said 11 interior trees would be removed. He said the rear-yard setback problem arose after the property's rear line was reinterpreted.

The other side: Frederick Zelly, attorney for objector Luke Russo of 7 Ridgeway Court, argued the variances stem from the applicant's own building choices. He cited the township's 2010 master plan: "This report recommends that flag lots not be permitted except in extraordinary hardship cases."

Under questioning from Andrew Ellman, a Ridgeway Court neighbor who argued incorrect original plans created the variances, Scott conceded the point. "It's likely that we would have less variances," said Scott.

Why it matters: The proposal would add a third flag lot sharing one 14-foot driveway. That makes it a test case for how far the board will bend a master plan that discourages the configuration.

What's next: The board's planner, who questioned house orientation and tree permits, still has to testify. Board deliberation will follow.


One Narrow Driveway, Three Homes, No Turnaround

Where things stand: Zelly's questioning established the shared stem as a roughly 400-foot, 14-foot-wide, single-file driveway with no turnaround. Fire engines would have to stack and back out onto Ridgeway. Zelly cited an Oct. 20 memo from the fire chief.

Zerbel pointed to language in the same memo saying similar access limitations are not uncommon in West Orange. When a board member asked whether engineering improvements could help, Scott said the driveway's single-row function cannot change.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The applicant moved to blunt the objection. "My client would be willing to put in fire suppression systems in both of the homes," said Zerbel.

Sprinklers would protect the new houses. They would not change how trucks get in and out, which is the core of the neighbors' complaint.

Why it matters: Emergency access is a central basis for the objections. It is likely to shape any conditions the board attaches if it approves the project.


Stormwater Waiver Tests Neighbors' Flooding Fears

Where things stand: Scott described a plan with pervious pavement and an infiltration and retention basin. The plan also removes a second detention system. The applicant agreed to leaf screens and additional soil tests.

Scott said on-site soils cannot store half of the projected 2-year storm. "I would ask that the board consider a waiver for full compliance with the management of the retention storm," said Scott.

The applicant's case is that any system improves on today's conditions, because the site has no stormwater controls. Board questions covered steep slopes and a retaining wall, tree replacement, filing of an operations and maintenance manual, and dewatering during construction.

The other side: Public commenter Devlin Miles raised flooding and drainage concerns for neighbors. Kevin Malanga, a public commenter, pressed on impervious coverage, parking, tree identification and steep slopes. Ellman questioned the basin's setbacks.

Why it matters: Neighbors downhill bear the risk if the system underperforms. A waiver would let the project fall short of the township's full retention standard.


Big Houses, Basement Offices Draw Board Scrutiny

Where things stand: Theodora Boyadjis, the applicant's architect, testified to footprints of 4,081 and 4,959 square feet. Both homes would exceed 6,000 square feet of floor area: one with six bedrooms, one with four.

Boyadjis defended the layout against the setback rules. "I don't believe the setback could be met with having a functional first floor," said Boyadjis. She said a compliant design would produce a skinny house.

The board's planner asked her to review the ordinance's definition of a half story, which bears on how the attic levels are counted.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Board questions about basement offices centered on whether they could later become bedrooms. The chairman signaled a fix. "I'm going to recommend the condition to the board that the basement office space in both units can only be used as office space or storage," said the Planning Board Chairman.

Neighbors argue the homes exceed neighborhood scale. A basement-use condition would cap occupancy but not the size of the buildings.


Neighbors Challenge Work Already Underway

Where things stand: Five residents joined Zelly in challenging the application. Lawrence Cohen, a public commenter, asked whether the applicant jumped the gun by starting construction before the hearing. He also asked about multigenerational housing and recreation space.

Zelly examined Scott on the timing of demolition. Greg Williams, a resident of 5 Ridgeway, disputed the engineer's description of the garage walls.

Why it matters: The questions put a pointed issue before the board. Members must decide whether to grant variances for a project where work is already in progress, and whether initial plan errors should count against the applicant.

What's next: The hearing resumes Dec. 2 at 7 p.m. via Zoom. No new public notice will be issued, so residents tracking the case should mark the date now.


Minor Items

  • Extensions granted: The board approved one-year extensions of time by roll call for PB 22-13, West Crestmont Realty LLC, and PB 23-11, Tompkins Realty LLC. Exact expiration dates will be written into the resolutions.
  • Legal counsel: The board approved by roll call an agreement for planning board legal services with Diana Powell McGovern, Esq., of Gassione Pamacco, PC. Vice Chairman Guarino seconded each motion.

Looking Ahead

The board's next regular meeting is Nov. 4. The 15 Ridgeway LLC hearing, including the planner's testimony and board deliberation, returns Dec. 2 at 7 p.m. via Zoom.