Locunity — where decisions happen.
Verona Zoning Board Rejects Event-Space Owner's Appeal in 5-2 Vote

Verona Zoning Board Rejects Event-Space Owner's Appeal in 5-2 Vote

Board of Adjustment • VeronaOctober 14, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Verona's Board of Adjustment ruled 5-2 that a Bloomfield Avenue event business operating for five years under a 2021 approval is not a permitted on-site caterer. The vote upheld the zoning official's determination and leaves the owner two options: seek a variance or change how she operates. The board also approved a contested patio variance on Linden Avenue and cleared the way for a stalled Floyd Road home to resume construction.


  • Board denies 340 Bloomfield Avenue appeal, 5-2, backing the zoning official on event-space use
  • Owner of Esteemed Events and Planning may now seek a variance after five years in business
  • Linden Avenue patio variance approved 5-2 at 18.9% rear-yard coverage, where 15% is allowed
  • Floyd Road plan changes ruled not material, 5-0, easing a stop-work order and a loan deadline

Event Space vs. Caterer: Board Sides With Zoning Official

The basics: This was an appeal, not a variance request. The question was whether the zoning official read the code correctly, and the owner carried the burden of proof.

"It is basically a determination of whether the board believes that the zoning officer's determination is accurate and correct," said Board Attorney Greg Messara.

Why it matters: "Event space" is a defined use, but it is not permitted in the extended Town Center zone. A small business that believed it was legal now operates without a clear legal footing. The ruling also shows the limits of approvals issued by a former zoning official.

Where things stand: The owner of Esteemed Events and Planning, Ms. Bynes, said former zoning official Mr. DiCarlo approved her application and that she has operated only as she described it. "I applied five years ago for it," she said.

Her attorneys, Shehina Ansari and Jason Simon, argued that the code defines an on-site caterer by whether it serves food, not whether it prepares food. They said every event includes food. They also argued that the town's later definition of "event space" cannot undo a valid earlier approval, a grandfathering claim. "It says nothing about preparing the food," Ansari said. Two clients testified that Bynes served food at their one-off events.

Zoning Official Kathleen Miesch said the 2021 letter described an event venue that "generally fits" a caterer on site. She said the business offers no set menu and does not require food. "From a zoning point of view, event spaces are not allowed in any zone," Miesch said.

Messara advised members not to weigh detrimental reliance, meaning the owner's investment based on the earlier approval. On the current definitions, he said: "event space is not permitted, she's absolutely correct."

The other side: Members were divided. One member who voted against denial said: "because there's no definition of event space, I could see that this falls into onsite catering." Members on the other side pointed to the application's own wording, "event space, meeting room," and to the word "generally" in the 2021 letter.

Another member was sympathetic to the business but still concluded the operation fits no approved use: "I don't think it's fair to the business to compare to the definition that we created for event spaces after they initially applied."

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The motion to deny the appeal passed. The chair first announced 4-2, then corrected the count after a late vote from Mr. Raff.

The owner loses the protection she believed the 2021 letter gave her. Other Town Center businesses that rely on older approvals now have a stricter reading of the use definitions to consider.

What's next: McGinley said the owner can apply for a variance. Miesch said one of two cases expected in November is a use variance, but she did not say which property it involves.


Linden Avenue Patio Clears on Split Vote

The basics: Application 2026-22 sought relief from the 15% rear-yard coverage limit at 66 Linden Avenue. "The 15% is required, and we're asking for 18.9%," said architect Julianne Cecere.

Why it matters: The only relief needed came from an existing detached garage on a long, narrow, sloping lot. Older garages like this one can push routine backyard projects into the variance process.

Where things stand: Cecere argued both hardship and benefit. Under New Jersey zoning, a C-1 variance rests on the property's physical conditions, and a C-2 variance rests on whether the benefits outweigh the detriments. "We cannot move the detached garage," she said.

The patio would extend about 3 feet past the house with a knee wall, which Cecere said improves safety. Roof leaders would be redirected onto grass to improve drainage. She said neighbors' additions extend farther back than the patio would.

The owner reported no flooding in five years and said neighbors on both sides support the project. A new fence, which needs no variance, will enclose the yard for a dog and a 3-year-old.

The other side: One member said the 3- to 4-foot wall could look like "a bunker in the back, not a patio from the street." Other members saw minimal impact.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The variance was approved subject to the board engineer's memo.

  • For (5): Mr. Raff, Ries, Cuartas, Ryan and Weston
  • Against (2): Tully and McGinley
  • Not called: Mr. Conrad Parisi

The homeowners get their patio and drainage upgrades. Neighbors gain redirected runoff.

What's next: A resolution will be drafted for the board's next meeting.


Floyd Road Family Gets Back to Building

Why it matters: A stop-work order at 756 Floyd Road put a family's loan at risk. The loan requires completion by December.

Where things stand: The board granted eight variances in March and memorialized them in an April resolution. The applicants later added a fourth bedroom, which they said their lender required, and replaced a deck with a patio. The revised plans also include two new rear dormers. A stop-work order followed.

Applicant Mr. Doherty said the family relied on its architect, who advised that the changes were not material. He said the order has displaced his two children. "The stop work order issued on our home last month has created really a hardship for us and has had great negative impact on our family," he said.

Attorney Jonathan Golden of Clark Golden Attorneys at Law said only the dormer change is new and that the other changes reduced existing variances. "There are no new variances sought with this change," he said.

The other side: McGinley framed the test as whether the changes would have influenced members' original votes on the eight variances. He also flagged a precedent concern: "It's not typical for plans to be changed after we approve them."

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: On counsel's advice, the board took two separate votes.

  • Materiality: The board voted 5-0 that the changes are not material. Parisi, Tully, Ries, Ryan and Weston voted yes.
  • Resolution: The same five members voted 5-0 to adopt Resolution 2026-20 with stipulations.
  • Recused: Cuartas
  • Not eligible: Two members

The family can continue construction without filing a new application.


Minor Items

  • 5 Ballston Drive: Resolution 2026-25 cleared by voice vote, formalizing a deck and fence built without approvals that the board reduced in September. Only three members who heard the case were eligible to vote, and no tally was stated.
  • Minutes: The board approved its Sept. 10, 2026, minutes by voice vote with one abstention.

Looking ahead: Miesch said two cases are expected in November, including a use variance. The board's audio-visual equipment will also be upgraded.

Verona Zoning Board Rejects Event-Space Owner's Appeal in 5-2 Vote | Board of Adjustment | Locunity