Locunity — where decisions happen.
Zoning Board Spares Vose Avenue Buyers Survey Cost, Balks at MGM Extension

Zoning Board Spares Vose Avenue Buyers Survey Cost, Balks at MGM Extension

Zoning Board of Adjustment • South OrangeNovember 4, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

South Orange's Zoning Board of Adjustment spent the largest share of its Nov. 4 meeting on a practical question: should new homeowners who inherited unpermitted backyard structures pay for a professional survey before their case is heard? The board said no and deemed the 331 Vose Avenue application complete by voice vote. Members also flagged stormwater risks at a proposed six-bedroom home on Irving Avenue and signaled they are unlikely to extend MGM Realty's 2022 approval after learning the building is being rented without residential approval.


  • Case #1073 deemed complete: Vose Avenue owners avoid a surveyor requirement; a chicken coop health sign-off is flagged
  • 114 Irving Avenue conditionally complete: stormwater is the chair's top concern ahead of the Dec. 1 hearing
  • MGM Realty extension stalls: the planner says the legal use is office, with no residential certificate of occupancy
  • Kingsland Terrace resolution adopted on a 4-0 roll call

Vose Avenue Buyers Get a Pass on Surveyor Costs

The basics: A completeness review decides whether an application has enough information to go to a public hearing. It is not a ruling on the merits. Case #1073 asks for variances to legalize existing rear-yard improvements at 331 Vose Avenue, owned by Baldeo Singh and Swarupa Singh.

Why it matters: The board chose not to add a possible multi-thousand-dollar surveyor cost for new owners who inherited the violations. That choice sets a practical tone for how retroactive "legalize what's there" cases move forward.

Where things stand: The structures were built without permits, and the buyers purchased the property knowing they would need a variance, according to Board Planner/Zoning Officer Greer Patras. The setback issues involve accessory structures. Lot coverage complies.

The measurements came from calculations Topology prepared using a scaled survey rather than a fresh field survey. Patras defended the approach: "It's not ideal, but it's not inappropriate or unnecessary," she said.

A member asked about a request in the application to waive public hearing notice. Staff said notice cannot be waived and described the request as a drafting oddity.

The chicken coop question: Members asked whether the coop on the property had health approval and when it was obtained. Patras proposed tying approval to a condition "that they get a valid health inspection sign-off." Under that condition, the owners would need the health office's sign-off or would have to remove the coop.

The other side: Board Member Devyani Guha pushed for precision. "I think it would be good for them to get real measurements," she said, though she indicated she would defer to the majority. Another member joined Board Chair Paul Breene in opposing the extra cost. "I would prefer not unless others feel strongly the other way," Breene said.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The board deemed the application complete by voice vote; no tally was stated. The Singhs avoid an added survey expense, and the board will rely on staff-reviewed figures when it weighs the setback requests. Neighbors will get their say at the hearing.

What's next: The hearing is set for a later meeting. The chicken coop's health status must be confirmed.


Irving Avenue Home Faces Stormwater Scrutiny

Why it matters: A&J Properties NJ LLC wants to build a new six-bedroom, single-family home at 114 Irving Avenue. The chair wants assurance that the house will not push more runoff onto the neighboring lot.

Where things stand: Adam Lazaros, an attorney with Prime Tuvel and Maselli representing the applicant, said the only variance requested is for lot width. Board Attorney Patrick Dwyer addressed a threshold question: "The lots did not merge, so it did not require a subdivision," he said.

Breene raised drainage toward the adjacent lot. He suggested the applicant's engineers consider a drainage ditch with piping to the basin. "I would want that to be addressed in full at a hearing," he said. Lazaros said a drainage basin was added in the second submission and that updated calculations will be provided.

Patras noted that engineer Bowman's technical review is unusually extensive because the lot has never been excavated.

The historic angle: The site falls within the Historic Preservation Commission's jurisdiction. The commission's review is advisory and non-binding, but the board made completeness conditional on that review.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The board deemed the case conditionally complete by voice vote; no tally was stated. It then opened the hearing with no testimony and carried it to Dec. 1. Opening the hearing preserves the applicant's public notice, so no new notice is required. A neighbor from across the street tried to ask questions. Breene said the public can ask questions and make statements at the December hearing.

What's next: The hearing resumes Dec. 1. The applicant must submit updated drainage calculations before then, and nearby residents should come prepared to weigh in on runoff.


MGM Realty's Extension Request Hits a Wall

Why it matters: Without completing resolution compliance, MGM Realty's 2022 approval for 468 Irvington Avenue cannot support a building permit. The applicant could be forced to start over under changed rules.

Where things stand: James McGowan of the Durkin Firm, counsel for MGM Realty, asked for more time to do roof and second-floor work. "So we are here today to seek an extension, a further extension through July 30th of 2027," he said. He told the board the tenants leave in May 2027.

That disclosure drew pushback. Patras said the building has no residential certificate of occupancy and the owner has not submitted a rental registration. She said the legal use is office. She also told McGowan, "you can't start construction until you finish resolution compliance." McGowan said he would confirm the details in writing.

The other side: Board members were blunt. "I think the board is hard put to grant an extension," Breene said. Guha went further: "I feel really uncomfortable keeping on giving extensions based on stuff that I'm not even aware of."

Dwyer described the stakes for the owner. If MGM loses the approval and returns, "they would have to present an entirely new application to conform with the change in the ordinance," he said.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The board took no action. That leaves the property owner under pressure to formalize the building's use and finish compliance paperwork. Current tenants are living in a building whose legal use, according to staff, is office.

What's next: Breene wants the matter addressed at the December meeting. Patras urged the applicant to submit for resolution compliance before then.


Minor Items

  • Case #1076 resolution adopted: The resolution for 250 Kingsland Terrace (Jason Steinberg) passed. For: 4 (Joseph Gabriel, William MacIntosh, Vice Chair Jacob Levine, Breene), Against: 0. Guha did not vote because she voted no on the case.
  • Why the variance shrank: The resolution records that "the driveway was narrowed and therefore the impervious variance was unnecessary," Breene said. Professionals must still review the plans for compliance.
  • October minutes adopted: The board approved the minutes by voice vote after a member's recorded vote was corrected from yes to no.
  • Two cases not taken up: Case #1075 (62 Massel Terrace) and Case #1077 (21 Cottage Street) were on the agenda but were not heard.

Looking Ahead

The board meets next on Tuesday, Dec. 1, 2026, at 7 p.m. The agenda is set to include the Irving Avenue hearing, and the chair wants MGM Realty's request addressed at that meeting.