Locunity — where decisions happen.
Sky Park Pickleball Debate Heads to Commission as Council Takes No Action

Sky Park Pickleball Debate Heads to Commission as Council Takes No Action

City Council • Scotts ValleyNovember 19, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Scotts Valley’s noisiest civic fight is over four courts at Sky Park, where neighbors and players are split over noise, parking and speeding. On Nov. 18, 2026, the City Council heard nearly an hour of staff findings, police data and public comment but took no vote. The issue now goes to the Parks and Recreation Commission on Dec. 8. In a quieter 5-0 vote, the council created a new analyst position to bring business licensing back in-house.


  • Sky Park pickleball goes to the Parks and Rec Commission Dec. 8, with a post-pilot survey open through Nov. 30
  • An 8 p.m. closing time drew the most support from both neighbors and players in a city survey
  • Police logged about 75 traffic-enforcement visits but issued only three citations at Sky Park
  • Council members floated respite days, sound barriers and grants but ruled out nothing and decided nothing
  • Resolution 2107 passes 5-0, adding an analyst who will take over business licensing from an outside vendor

Sky Park Courts: Noise, Traffic and No Easy Exit

Why it matters: Sky Park has what Recreation Division Manager Allison Pfefferkorn described as the county’s only lighted public courts. Neighbors say the noise and traffic now intrude on daily life. Whatever the commission recommends will decide who gets relief and who loses court time.

The basics: Sky Park has four court areas: two tennis courts, one shared court and one pickleball-only court with permanent nets. According to Pfefferkorn, pickleball took off around 2014 and Court 4 became permanent in 2018. Complaints began in 2023. A council subcommittee then produced a Rec.us reservation system in 2024, boulders in the medians, signs and shorter hours of 9:30 a.m. to 8:30 p.m. A neighbor filed a formal complaint in January 2026.

Where things stand: The city surveyed both neighbors and players. “An 8:00 PM closing time received the most support from both groups,” said Recreation Division Manager Allison Pfefferkorn. Both groups named parking as a problem. Neighbors also reported speeding, drivers running stop signs and blocked driveways.

A pilot program ran from Aug. 17 to Nov. 13. It closed the courts at 8 p.m. and added police patrols. Staff listed several limits on what the city can do:

  • No other city land is available for courts.
  • Sound studies and noise barriers are expensive.
  • “The Sky Park courts are the only public courts in the county that have lights,” Pfefferkorn said.

Options on the table include:

  • Scheduling changes and access controls
  • More parking through the Sky Park master plan
  • A sound study and acoustic barriers
  • Lessons from a pilot program in Campbell

Enforcement by the numbers: Between June and October, “we were out there specifically for traffic enforcement over 75 times, approximately 75 times, with 2 parking citations and 1 stop sign violation that was cited,” said the Police Chief. Officers also made more than 70 after-hours checks. “We had no documented violations,” the chief said.

The other side: Public comment broke along clear lines.

Players and their supporters:
- Carol Hagan praised drop-in play for its social and health benefits.
- Mark Dettel, President, Santa Cruz Pickleball Club, called the courts an asset for seniors and young people. He backed adding lighted courts elsewhere in the county.
- Andrew Lenz, a city pickleball instructor, said the sport keeps growing. He argued the fix is more courts away from Sky Park, possibly near the high school after its remodel.
- Nina Eklhoff, a mobile home park resident who also plays, supported sound barriers.

Neighbors and critics:
- Tracy Waldheim, who lives on a cul-de-sac near the park, described worse traffic and drivers running stop signs. She welcomed speed bumps and said the reservation system does not work.
- Another commenter said the noise exceeds 100 decibels. She argued that home life should come first and suggested players use a private club.
- Mary Jan Murphy asked for noise and traffic studies. She said only about 30-some percent of surveyed players live in Scotts Valley and warned that more parking could make things worse. She also said a past presentation acknowledged a violation. Pfefferkorn disagreed: “There was nothing in that presentation saying we were in violation of the courts and the houses there.”
- Chris Hoffman, who does not play, said the courts have no parking and a proven noise problem. He urged moving them as part of the Town Center plan.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Mayor Donna Lind said the council could not take action, so members offered ideas instead.

  • Councilmember Krista Jett said, “I would feel not right about doing an outright ban.” She proposed “the potential for respite days of having 3 to 4 days of pickleball play allowed,” which would give neighbors predictable quiet days.
  • Councilmember Derek Timm asked whether other agencies plan lighted courts. Pfefferkorn replied that “the county has said that they have no plans of putting lights on any of their courts.” Timm also noted the park’s speed sign does not record data. He said that “once the project’s completed at the high school, I do think there’s some opportunities there with the courts.”
  • Vice Mayor Steve Clark spoke most bluntly to players about driving and parking: “This is on you to solve in your community, and if you can’t, you will give us no choice but to have to solve it.” He suggested sound barriers, grants, public-private or multi-agency facilities and a decoy patrol car.
  • Mayor Lind suggested players help pay for fixes: “I bet if we did a fundraising opportunity in our community, there’s enough pickleball players throughout the county that would probably contribute.”

The council’s message was mixed. Members showed little appetite for a ban but warned players to change their behavior. Neighbors gained no immediate relief. Players kept their courts for now, but they may soon be asked to raise money for barriers or new courts.

What’s next: The post-pilot survey closes Nov. 30. The Parks and Recreation Commission will review the results Dec. 8.


New Analyst Brings Business Licensing Back In-House

Why it matters: Business licensing will move from an outside vendor back to City Hall. The city is also adding staff before a permanent city manager arrives.

Where things stand: Interim City Manager Stephanie Hill presented the proposal, which the Economic Development Committee recommended. The council would create one full-time position in the confidential analyst series. City administration once had two full-time positions, but both were moved to other departments, leaving little support. Licensing is now handled by a third-party vendor, which Mayor Lind identified as HDL.

The analyst would spend about 25% of the job on business licenses. The rest would go to special projects, grants, coordination between departments and support for the incoming city manager.

The numbers:
- Full annual cost, including benefits: up to about $175,000
- Cost this year, for roughly seven months: about $105,000
- Personnel savings expected this year: about $185,000

Hill said the city’s budget forecast already planned for one new position in 2027-28 and another in 2028-29. This vote moves one of them forward.

The case for it: Council members cited complaints from businesses about the vendor, the potential to win more grants and the need to attract a strong city manager. “I remember when we handled business licenses in-house, and it was so nice that a business could call and contact a live person in Scotts Valley,” said Mayor Donna Lind. “Anything that helps our business community, I want to support,” said Vice Mayor Steve Clark. No one spoke against it.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Councilmember Derek Timm moved to adopt the resolution, and Councilmember Greg Wimp seconded. It passed by roll call (For: 5 — Lind, Clark, Jett, Wimp, Timm; Against: 0; Absent: 0).

Local businesses gain a local contact for licensing, while HDL loses that work. The incoming city manager inherits added staff capacity. Because this year’s cost is covered by existing salary savings, there is no new hit to the general fund in the current year.


  • Metro wins $28.97M: Mayor Lind said Metro received its full request for a South County bus maintenance facility in Watsonville. The grant includes a four-year bike share pilot.
  • Highway 1 ramp closures delayed: Vice Mayor Clark said the Regional Transportation Commission postponed the closures until after the holidays. It also approved Measure D five-year spending plans, including longer hours and weekend service for Lift Line, a paratransit service.
  • Town Center talks continue: Councilmember Jett said exclusive negotiations with developer Swenson are ongoing. “This project falls under the requirements of the Surplus Lands Act, which includes a requirement for 300 housing units on that site,” she said.
  • Storm response and Lockwood Lane: Hill said free sand is available at the Glenwood parking lot (bring your own bags and shovels). She added that new traffic cameras are not used for enforcement. Resident Wendy Crockett asked the city attorney to warn homeowners whose driveways and culverts cause flooding on Lockwood Lane. She also asked for permanent warning signs: “If that isn’t known liability, I don’t know what is.”
  • Bethany 125 concerns: Chris Hoffman said the housing project sits on an unreliable power grid near a PG&E shutoff area and asked the city to involve state housing officials. Mayor Lind replied that the plans will not come to the council because the project is state-mandated, though city staff can help.

Looking ahead: The Sky Park survey closes Nov. 30, and the Parks and Recreation Commission takes up the results Dec. 8. A more final Town Center design from Swenson is expected later this year.