Locunity — where decisions happen.
Saratoga Council Approves 69-Unit Quito Road Project, Citing State Law

Saratoga Council Approves 69-Unit Quito Road Project, Citing State Law

City Council • SaratogaNovember 18, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Saratoga's City Council on Nov. 18, 2026, approved a 69-unit housing project on Quito Road over sustained objections about traffic and wildfire evacuation. Every councilmember said state law left no lawful basis to deny it. The unanimous voice vote overturned a Planning Commission denial and pushed the city toward writing the objective safety standards it did not have when the application arrived. The outgoing council also rejected a historic-home tax break 4-1 and left Mountain Winery annexation to its successors.


  • 69-unit Quito Road project approved by unanimous voice vote after members said state housing law blocked denial
  • 14 public commenters pressed traffic, evacuation, tree-loss and flooding concerns on the Quito corridor
  • The city attorney said no objective safety standard existed at application, and council asked staff to develop standards for future projects
  • Mills Act tax break for a 1936 Glenuna Drive home rejected 4-1
  • Mountain Winery annexation decision deferred to the incoming council
  • South Bay Musical Theater tapped to manage the Civic Theater for about $32,813 a year

State Law Carries Quito Road Homes Past Objections

The basics: The project at 14076 Quito Road would place 55 townhomes and 14 affordable accessory dwelling units in 12 three-story buildings on a 3.85-acre site split into 14 lots. It includes 110 enclosed and 15 visitor parking spaces and would remove 67 of 109 protected trees. It is a builder's remedy project, which bars denial based on the general plan or zoning. AB 130 exempts it from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), so no traffic analysis was required.

Why it matters: The council reversed its own Planning Commission's denial. The roughly 106-minute hearing, the longest of the night, showed how the Housing Accountability Act (HAA), builder's remedy and AB 130 now constrain local discretion over density, design and traffic.

Where things stand: The applicant offered $200,000 toward a future signal at Quito Road and Marshall Lane and $30,000 to extend sidewalks and bike lanes. Applicant attorney Tara Sullivan of Holland and Knight cited peak-hour trip increases of roughly 3%. "The HAA expressly forbids the city from disapproving this project absent written findings supported by the preponderance of the evidence," said Sullivan.

The other side: Residents framed evacuation as a life-safety issue. "Under cumulative development scenario, complete evacuation would increase to 6 hours and 15 minutes, a 25% increase," said Dory Albert, Neighborhood Watch lead, citing the city's evacuation study. Erica Cervantes described a same-day rain closure of Pollard Road. Kim Morgenthaler, a retired deputy sheriff, said Quito Road cannot absorb the project and emergency response would suffer. Brenda Flanagan asked for stop signs instead of a signal. John Busk said he supports housing in general but asked for a cumulative analysis. Earlier, public commenter Somnag had asked council to order an evacuation study addendum covering cumulative development and neighboring cities. Staff later told Councilmember Yan Zhao that the 2026 study included builder's remedy projects and nearby county development.

The legal wall: The city attorney said no objective health and safety standard existed when the application was filed in March 2024. He said any standard must be specific, quantifiable and reasonable. "No standard we develop now, or even if we developed a standard a year ago, we couldn't apply it to this project," said the City Attorney. Asked by Zhao, he added, "We don't have standards that determine what is safe or what is not safe."

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Councilmember Belal Aftab moved to uphold the appeal. The motion passed on a voice vote the mayor declared unanimous; no individual tally was announced. "Frankly speaking, when it comes to things like builder's remedy projects, our hands are quite tied," said Aftab. "Because the law ties our hands, I have no choice but to support the project as has been presented," said Vice Mayor Tina Walia. "I am just flabbergasted by the amount of local control that we no longer have," said Mayor Chuck Page. The developer secures its entitlement and 14 affordable units enter the pipeline. Quito corridor residents absorb the traffic risk they warned about.

What's next: Zhao asked staff to bring objective standards to the next council. The city attorney noted a safety element update is coming next year.


Council Says No to Historic Home Tax Break

The basics: A Mills Act agreement lowers a historic property's tax bill in exchange for preservation and maintenance commitments. This one covered a 1936 Spanish Eclectic home at 19490 Glenuna Drive.

Why it matters: The vote signals the council will use its discretion over the program and scrutinize maintenance-heavy 10-year plans.

Where things stand: Staff estimated the city's share of the tax reduction at about $2,100 and said the plan met the policy's 6.25% threshold. Owner Narayan Subbarao committed to preservation and reaffirmed his openness to walking tours. The city attorney said the council has broad discretion.

The other side: "Neither Saratoga nor Santa Clara County residents, taxpayers, should be subsidizing the maintenance of market-rate homes in Saratoga," said public commenter Bill Dalton, who also disputed staff's estimate.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: "Mills Act agreements should provide a clear and meaningful public benefit that justifies the property tax reduction," said Zhao, who moved not to adopt the resolution. "I can't justify it. So I do not support," said Councilmember Kookie Fitzsimmons. Walia and Page struggled to find a reason to vote yes, and Aftab was supportive. The motion not to adopt passed 4-1 (For: 4, including Zhao, with Fitzsimmons, Walia and Page having stated they would not support the agreement; Against: 1, Aftab; Absent: 0). The owner will not receive the tax reduction.


Mountain Winery Annexation Goes to the Next Council

Why it matters: Annexation could bring tax revenue and some control over county-approved projects, but it carries cost, service and political risk.

Where things stand: The acting community development director recounted the city's terminated 2019-2020 annexation attempt. The director also outlined the Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO) process, which involves the city's sphere of influence and urban service area. That process would require a plan for services, a fiscal impact report and a vacant land inventory.

The other side: Speakers mostly opposed reviving annexation. "My request is simple: stop this insanity," said Antoinette Romeo, a retired county planner, who cited prior opposition, cost and about $82,000 in tax value. Glenda Ani cited Pierce Road traffic, cost and safety. Glenn supported due diligence but urged no added zoning rights or infrastructure burden. Dalton asked what rights the city has over a county project's access to Pierce Road.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The council gave no direction and took no vote. "I am open to bringing this back for when the new council starts," said Fitzsimmons. Page urged the next council to weigh benefits and impacts.

What's next: Any restart, along with its LAFCO and cost decisions, rests with the incoming council.


Civic Theater Management Heads to Longtime Tenant

Where things stand: South Bay Musical Theater (SBMT), which has used the Saratoga Civic Theater for roughly 60 years, would take over management and operations. Staff said the theater's specialized equipment factored into the choice. SBMT proposed an annual fee of $30,000 plus 18% of rental receipts from groups other than SBMT, or about $32,813 a year. SBMT projected about $15,000 in added annual revenue. Michael Hirsch of SBMT described plans for scheduling, youth classes and tiered access. No one spoke during public comment.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Zhao moved and Walia seconded authorizing the city manager's office to proceed with the transition. The motion passed on a voice vote declared unanimous. The arrangement aims to free staff time and add rental revenue while the city keeps ownership and control.

What's next: The final agreement returns to council for approval.


  • Wildfire funding: Assemblymember Mark Berman presented $1.75M from the 2026-2027 state budget for vegetation management along evacuation routes.
  • Village vitality: Staff reported $1.3M in citywide sales tax, including 12 of the top 25 producers located in the village, and said restaurants could be permitted by right.
  • Sewer rates: Zhao relayed proposed West Valley Sanitation increases of 12%, 12%, 12%, 12% and 11% starting in 2027-28; the district has not yet decided.
  • Regional boards: The SVRIA board approved a $13M Motorola console purchase, and Page reported Silicon Valley Clean Energy passed a data center pricing policy.
  • Storm prep: The city announced a free sandbag station alongside upcoming holiday events.

Looking ahead: The council next meets Dec. 2, its final session before the new council is seated. Objective safety standards and Mountain Winery annexation both await the incoming members.