Locunity — where decisions happen.
CityBus Overhaul Heads to Dec. 1 Vote as Council Names Permanent Manager

CityBus Overhaul Heads to Dec. 1 Vote as Council Names Permanent Manager

City Council • Santa RosaNovember 17, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Santa Rosa's bus riders got a detailed look Nov. 17, 2026, at proposed service changes. Route 1 would return to 15-minute service, while Route 16 would end and Routes 9 and 18 would lose service. The City Council took no action at the public hearing. Staff will bring the plan back Dec. 1. The same night, the council made interim City Manager Jason Nutt permanent and heard fleet mechanics accuse management of stalling labor talks.


  • CityBus service overhaul aired: Route 1 returns to 15 minutes, Route 16 ends, and Route 18 loses weekends. Council action is set for Dec. 1.
  • Jason Nutt named permanent city manager on a 6-0 closed-session vote, with Councilmember Victoria Fleming absent.
  • Fleet mechanics press council to give a new negotiator bargaining authority after four postponements.
  • Consent calendar passes 6-0, including the Madera Avenue vacation over a neighbor's objection and the homeless emergency extension.

CityBus Trades Coverage for Reliability

The basics: The Short-Range Transit Plan reshapes CityBus routes. Staff coordinated the plan with Sonoma County Transit under the countywide MASCOTS plan. "Interlining" means one bus continues from one route directly onto another, here Route 1 into Routes 2/2B.

Why it matters: Staff cited declining on-time performance, full buses on Mendocino Avenue and a tight transit fund. The package improves Route 1 and connections to SMART, the regional rail line. Some riders would lose service, with changes planned for February 2027.

"The number one goal of this effort is to address growing service reliability issues in the city bus system," said Rachel, CityBus staff presenter.

Where things stand: About 450 surveys and two outreach phases shaped the proposal. The main changes:

  • Route 1 returns to 15-minute service.
  • Route 9 becomes bidirectional and serves North Dutton.
  • Route 10 is realigned.
  • Route 15 gets grant-funded 30-minute service.
  • Route 16 ends. The Oakmont Village Association is shifting riders to GoGo Grandparent.
  • Route 18 loses weekend service.

The Route 9 trade-off is the sharpest. "It would reduce frequency from every 30 minutes to 60 minutes," said Transit Planner Matt Wilcox.

Staff said ridership drove the cuts. Route 16 averages "about 1 rider per hour for '25-'26," said Yuri Koslin, transit planner and paratransit program manager. Rachel called Route 18 "by far our lowest ridership fixed route."

The other side: Councilmember Caroline Bañuelos questioned the Route 9 cut. "There's too much people who are waiting too long already at 30 minutes," she said. Rachel replied that riders surveyed favored hourly bidirectional service by "about a 65-35% split."

Councilmember Dianna MacDonald asked about Oakmont: "Have we reached out to the county to see if there's any way they could add a couple more stops?" Staff said, "We haven't discussed with them adding stops, but we can certainly reach out to them and report back when we come back to council."

Public speakers broadly supported the plan but raised specific concerns:

  • Ken Rossi, public commenter, asked to keep weekday Route 18 service on Hoen Avenue. He also asked to restore an audible arrival announcement for blind riders.
  • Jimmy, public commenter, backed the Route 9 North Dutton extension. He suggested tying Route 18 to fairgrounds events.
  • Sophie Apples, a Santa Rosa High School student, worried about the Santa Rosa Junior College stop. "Those buses often get extremely overcrowded after school," she said.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No vote was taken. Mendocino Avenue and SMART riders stand to gain. Oakmont's Route 16 riders, Route 9 riders and weekend Route 18 riders would absorb the cuts. Councilmember Eddie Alvarez accepted losing the texting arrival option: "I would much rather have more service than the texting option." Bañuelos called Route 1's 15-minute service "excellent."

What's next: Staff returns Dec. 1 for council action. The staff report and presentation are posted.


Fleet Mechanics Push to Restart Talks

Why it matters: Unit 13 mechanics, represented by Operating Engineers Local 3, maintain the city's vehicle fleet. The union says delays risk losing specialized workers who keep police, fire, bus and public works vehicles running.

Where things stand: Stephen Anderson, spokesperson for Unit 13, said management has postponed reopener talks four times. A reopener is a contract clause that allows bargaining on set terms mid-contract. Anderson said management is waiting for a new council member to be seated. He said the next session is set for Jan. 26, 2027, 10 months after the reopener.

"City management is failing to meet and confer in good faith under our signed contract, using repeated delays to avoid substantive negotiations," Anderson said. He added: "Please bring our new negotiator into closed session immediately, grant bargaining authority, and direct staff to finish our overdue equity adjustments."

Mark Beauchamp, public employee business agent for Operating Engineers Local 3, called the unit a hard-to-compare "unicorn." He asked the council to authorize negotiator Mark Wilson to bargain. "We're losing members to PG&E," he said.

The other side: No council or staff response was offered. The claims are the speakers' allegations.

What's next: Any direction would come through closed session. Labor talks are now an early test for the permanent city manager.


Nutt Gets the Job Permanently

Where things stand: After closed session, Mayor Mark Stapp reported the decision. "We have officially appointed to the permanent position of city manager Mr. Jason Nutt," he said. The vote was 6 in favor with Fleming absent. Individual votes were not stated.

Before the vote, Dwayne DeWitt, a Roseland resident and public commenter, pressed for a long-term hire, citing pension costs and turnover. "You need somebody who's not close to retirement, somebody that's got a full 10 years in the game here," he said.

Downtown property talks: The council also met in closed session on negotiations over city-owned downtown property involving Museum on the Square, LLC. Vice Mayor Jeff Okrepkie recused himself, citing "the possibility of a potential conflict." DeWitt alleged that a prior sale promised housing that was never built despite a $1.5M discount. He said the city should not pay to reacquire the property. "I do not believe you should trust this developer," he said. No action was reported.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Permanent leadership arrives as the city plans Measure L spending and handles labor negotiations.


Consent Calendar Passes Over Objections

Where things stand: No items were pulled for discussion. Okrepkie moved the package and MacDonald seconded. It passed For: 6 (Stapp, MacDonald, Okrepkie, Bañuelos, Alvarez, Rogers), Against: 0, Absent: 1 (Fleming).

The other side: David Millerick, public commenter, objected to vacating part of the Madera Avenue right-of-way. "I oppose the vacation of Madera Avenue," he said. He said neighbors have used the roughly 50,000-square-foot area for about a decade. He also said it provides fire protection access and that no public notice was given because the land is exempt surplus. He said he would submit documents.

DeWitt urged the council to use the homeless emergency to lobby county supervisors to open fairgrounds and veterans building space before storms. He said "there are 80 veterans on the waitlist" for VASH vouchers, a federal program that provides housing vouchers for homeless veterans.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Adjacent property owners receive the Madera Avenue land. The homeless emergency declaration stays in force heading into storm season.


Minor Items

  • Housing funds: Nutt announced an additional $820,000 in disaster recovery funds for Laurel at Perennial Park Phase 3. The money raises the city's total award to $39,289,772, with formal acceptance due in the new year.
  • Board seats: Appointments to four bodies passed 6-0, including Paul Schwartz to the Bicycle and Pedestrian Advisory Board and Scott Conrad to the mosquito district. The Personnel Board pick was continued to Dec. 1 after one of two applicants interviewed.
  • Mental health response: Buckelew Programs gets $889,901 more for InResponse, extending the program through January 2028 at up to $4.35M total.
  • Fleet purchases: Council approved three trucks for $192,410 and two equipment trailers for $129,400.
  • Roseland roads: DeWitt asked for an accounting of $6M in county annexation road funding, citing Trowbridge, Hewitt and Link Lane.

Looking Ahead

Dec. 1 brings the CityBus vote and the Personnel Board appointment. In his report, Stapp also flagged Measure L budget projections and a possible bond for neighborhood streets.

CityBus Overhaul Heads to Dec. 1 Vote as Council Names Permanent Manager | City Council | Locunity