

San Rafael Extends Canal Tenant Protections, Adds Citywide Right to Return
City Council • San RafaelNovember 16, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
San Rafael renters facing storm-driven repairs won a stopgap. On Nov. 16, 2026, the City Council voted 4-0 for an urgency ordinance that keeps Canal anti-displacement rules alive and adds a citywide right to return through April 30, 2027. More than 30 commenters used the hearing to push for something bigger: permanent rent and fee protections.
- Urgency ordinance passes 4-0, extending Canal protections set to lapse Dec. 31 and adding a citywide right to return
- Tenant coalition presses for rent control, a ban on hidden utility charges and citywide just cause ahead of a draft due in early 2027
- El Niño emergency renewed 4-0, with about $490,000 of a $500,000 reserve authorization already spent
- Garbage rates rise about 6.3%, and a refuse vehicle impact fee returns at one-third of its prior level
- Anderson Drive encampment clearing proceeds despite calls to wait for 21 tiny homes due in January
Stopgap Shields Renters Through Storm Season
Why it matters: The 2024 Canal protections, known as Ordinance 2034, were tied to an expiring Opportunity Zone and would have ended Dec. 31, in the middle of storm season. Tenants citywide now gain a right to return, but relocation help remains limited to the Canal.
The basics: "Substantial rehabilitation" evictions let landlords remove tenants for major health and safety repairs. Ordinance 2034 removed that as an allowable eviction cause in two Canal census tracts and requires landlords to pay for temporary lodging.
Where things stand: Housing Program Manager Alexis Captanian presented a two-part plan.
- It extends Ordinance 2034 in the two Canal tracts.
- It creates a citywide right to reoccupy a unit within 30 days after rehab is finished or a vacate order is lifted. Tenants get 30 days to accept a written offer.
"Staff does not recommend letting this anti-displacement policy lapse in the middle of the projected El Niño winter storm season," said Captanian.
Staff said any citywide rule needs a direct link to El Niño. That legal limit is why relocation assistance stays Canal-only. Staff said eviction moratoriums and rent-increase limits were not included but could come back. The ordinance has no reporting mechanism. A permanent ordinance could replace it.
The other side: Advocates said the measure does not go far enough. "We urge you to go further to pass a strong urgency ordinance to protect San Rafael residents," said Gina Gilmette of Community Action Marin, which sought a dedicated relocation fund, a no-fault eviction moratorium and a rent freeze.
Lucy Hollingsworth, an attorney with Legal Aid of Marin, warned that relocation costs could fall on displaced tenants. "Negligent landlords are not going to pay that lawful relocation, and cities may pay that and then go after the landlords," she said.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: "What's before us this evening is a near-term, short-term proposal to address the impact of El Niño," said Mayor Kate Colin. Councilmember Maribeth Bushey said simply, "I support the staff recommendation." Vice Mayor Rachel Kertz backed the plan: "First for tonight, support extending the urgency ordinance and expanding the right to return citywide."
The vote was For: 4 (Colin, Kertz, Bushey, Councilmember Maika Llorens Gulati), Against: 0, Absent: 1 (Councilmember Eli Hill).
Canal tenants keep their lodging payments and eviction shield. Renters elsewhere gain a right to come back but no relocation money. Landlords citywide must offer units back after repairs.
What's next: The ordinance expires April 30, 2027. Staff expects a permanent ordinance in the first quarter of 2027, with a draft tentatively set for Jan. 19.
Tenant Coalition Pushes for Permanent Protections
Why it matters: The turnout shaped council direction on the permanent ordinance. Members asked staff to move faster on habitability inspections and to study utility fees, relocation funds and a vacancy fee.
Where things stand: Dozens of tenants, many speaking Spanish, described rent near $5,000 and hidden utility charges of $225 to $300 or more. They also cited mold, pests, fear of retaliation and eviction notices over utility bills. Speakers came from Parent Voices, Voces del Canal, Fuerzas Unidas, Marin Tenant Power Committee and Canal Alliance.
- Marina Palma, a Canal volunteer, described hidden fees of up to $550 a month.
- Tahiti Namburu, a Terra Linda High student, described an 18% rent increase.
- Clayton Harwood, a disabled senior on Section 8, described a utility bill followed by a three-day pay-or-quit notice.
Much of the frustration targeted RUBS, short for ratio utility billing systems. Under RUBS, landlords split building utility costs among tenants by formula. "We ask you to direct staff to consider adding permanent regulations on junk fees," said Dr. Lisa Levitt, a pediatrician and leader with Marin Organizing Committee.
Jesus Guzman of Community Action Marin listed the coalition's first demand: "First, to make just cause citywide and permanent." Samantha Silva, a community organizer with Prime Voices California, put it bluntly: "The city cannot declare an emergency for everyone while offering protections just to some." Daisy Mendez of Fuerzas Unidas criticized the council for hearing stories without acting.
The other side: Staff said state bills on utility fees died. To staff's knowledge, the county has not allocated relocation funds.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Gulati called tenant stability "priority number one for our city." She also said, "I would really love to see the update on the house inspections coming much sooner." In response to the mayor, Captanian said those updates are "scheduled for fiscal year 2027-2028."
Gulati asked staff to study utilities, a vacancy fee and relocation enforcement, and she noted the city's budget deficit. Kertz requested a comparison with Alameda's action on RUBS. Colin called the issue complex and urged continued work on the city's roadmap.
What's next: The permanent ordinance draft is tentatively set for Jan. 19, 2027.
El Niño Emergency Renewed as King Tides Approach
Why it matters: Renewal keeps the city's emergency powers in place as king tides return. About 16,000 residents live in vulnerable areas.
Where things stand: Assistant City Manager Angela Robinson Piñon said the Oct. 5 declaration under Resolution 5620 followed the governor's Sept. 21 action. State Government Code 8630 requires a review every 60 days. With the next deadline on Dec. 4, staff brought the item early. "To date, there's roughly $490,000 that has been spent," she said, out of a $500,000 reserve authorization. Spending covered barriers, outreach and equipment. Staff said no reimbursement is expected now and no federal declaration exists.
Staff reported flooding in late October and early November. King tides are expected Nov. 24-26, around Christmas and in January. The city's response includes:
- Temporary barrier walls along the bayfront levee and levee patrols
- Flood-fight contracts and tabletop exercises
- Free parking in garages A and C
- Phased evacuations, voluntary first and then mandatory, with alerts through Alert Marin
Quinn Gardner, Deputy Director of Emergency Management, urged residents to stay off the roads during tide peaks: "Be wherever you need to be on any given day before 10:00 a.m. and plan on being there till at least 3:00 or 4:00."
The other side: Carly Finkle of Canal Alliance praised outreach and urged long-term investment in climate adaptation. A Spanish-speaking Canal outreach ambassador asked for flood-zone signs, more proactive Alert Marin messages and multilingual volunteers. Silva worried that remaining funds are low and asked about shuttles and equal support for unhoused neighbors. Dina Bliss, a Glenwood resident, said flooding on Point San Pedro Road comes up through drains. She asked the city not to spend on barriers that don't address it.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The council adopted the continuing resolution. For: 4, Against: 0, Absent: 1 (Hill). With nearly all the authorized reserve spent and no reimbursement in sight, further costs fall on the city.
Trash Bills Rise About 6.3%
Why it matters: Ratepayers face a roughly 6.3% increase starting in January, driven largely by landfill and organics processing costs. The city also restores a charge for road wear from garbage trucks.
Where things stand: Staff reported an overall 6.31% adjustment. Increases in collection operations were held to 2.5% to 5%, while landfill and organics processing costs rose sharply.
The vehicle impact fee has a long history:
- A study set the fee in 2004, and an update followed in 2020.
- Payments stopped after the Rogers v. Redlands court ruling, and the fee was repealed in April.
- SB 922, signed in August, reversed the ruling's effect.
"Refuse vehicles are 10 to 20 times heavier than most vehicles," said city staff presenting the item. The Finance Subcommittee preferred phasing the fee in over two to three years. As a result, only one-third of the fee is included now, and a new fee study is planned for early 2027.
The other side: Public commenter Mark Gaynor questioned paying about $493,000 for street sweeping that doesn't reach curbs, and he called for signage and enforcement. Staff said more than a dozen comments requested signage. Marin Sanitary Service is adding a sweeping alert to its app. City Manager Paul Navazio said "there's a staffing capacity question because right now there aren't parking enforcement officers." Public commenter Bill Carney supported the rates and urged the city to consider the Marin Biomass Study's recommendations for cutting landfill methane.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Bushey moved both resolutions, and both passed. For: 4, Against: 0, Absent: 1 (Hill). Council members praised the hauler's innovation. Colin adjourned the meeting in Bushey's honor for her long service.
Encampment Clearing Moves Ahead
During open time, speakers asked the city to delay clearing the Anderson Drive encampment ahead of forecast rain. "I am urging the city to postpone the sweep until January when the 21 tiny homes for Anderson Camp residents are slated to be completed," said Jason, a Gerstle Park resident.
Navazio said clearing would begin the next day, with a temporary Lindaro Street closure from 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. He said Mahone Creek residents will move to 350 Marydale on Nov. 23-24, rain or shine, subject to safety. Neighbors Wayne Rayburn and Gregory Andrew objected to the site's 10 p.m. quiet hours. They noted the city's municipal code defines nighttime as starting at 9 p.m.
Minor Items
- Consent calendar (items 2A–2I) passed 4-0; Kertz noted "the progress being made in our discussions with Marinwood regarding fire services."
- Measure W failed, leaving about $6M a year in infrastructure and public safety needs unfunded; Navazio called city finances relatively strong.
- Shop San Rafael proclamation was included in the consent calendar.
- Michael Glazener, a public commenter, thanked the city for Pickleweed Park improvements and requested speed bumps on Nevada Street.
- Salama Locks, a public commenter, sought council support for a San Rafael town hall on a county Community Land Trust.
Looking Ahead
King tides arrive Nov. 24-26. The Marydale move follows Nov. 23-24. The permanent tenant-protection draft is tentatively set for Jan. 19, 2027.