

San Mateo Adopts 5-0 City Property Protocol Amid ICE Fears
City Council • San MateoNovember 17, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
San Mateo now has a written playbook for what city staff must do when anyone, including federal immigration agents, uses city property without authorization. The City Council adopted an amendment to Resolution No. 114 on a 5-0 roll call at a Nov. 16, 2026, special meeting. The vote followed a pointed question-and-answer session that set out the legal limits on what the city and its police can do about ICE.
- 5-0 vote amends Resolution No. 114, creating a notify, document, review and respond process for city property
- Police Chief Barberini: SMPD learns of ICE activity from social media and can't share information with ICE
- "Cooperation is not participation": Staff say the city honors judicial warrants, not ICE detainers
- City manager named point person for incidents on city property; contractor limits get a staff look
- Two residents press council to turn Nov. 2 commitments into real implementation
Council Locks In Protocol for City Property
The basics: On Nov. 2, the council adopted two resolutions. One affirmed welcoming values and the other asserted city authority over city-owned property. Both built on a 2017 measure, Resolution No. 24. On Nov. 10, the council sent the matter back to staff, and the amendment returned at this special meeting.
Where things stand: Assistant City Manager Jennifer Yamaguma presented a four-step process:
- Employees report potential unauthorized activity through their management chain.
- Employees document the facts, including the nature, location and impacts of the activity.
- Management refers the matter for management and legal review.
- The city shares only verified information, as appropriate and within the law.
Under the amendment, the city manager or a designee would direct the activity to stop and the personnel to leave. If they refuse, staff would document the refusal and consult the city attorney.
"The amendment does not require city employees to confront, detain, investigate, or interfere with federal personnel," said Yamaguma.
Why it matters: The amendment gives staff a consistent protocol in a climate of fear over federal immigration enforcement. It does not expand the city's legal authority or put front-line employees between residents and federal agents.
"As mayor, I wanted to revisit this to make sure that we are doing what we can within the law to protect our residents and community members regardless of immigration status," said Mayor Adam Loraine.
The other side: Two public commenters argued that the Nov. 2 votes were a starting point, not a finish line.
- Emily Mendez, a San Mateo resident, tied the issue to police contract negotiations. She asked the city to strengthen policies so officers are never directed to avoid witnessing, documenting or verifying ICE activity. "We are asking for accountability, consistency, and equal enforcement of the law," said Mendez, a public commenter.
- Noelia Corzo said many residents are fearful and that it is unclear what the resolutions do beyond kind words. She also called some of the 2017 language questionable. She urged "that this council not just pass policies that sound good, but that are actually implemented well."
Both speakers said they were not asking for standoffs between city staff and federal agents.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The clerk recorded the motion from Deputy Mayor Nicole Fernandez. A second was voiced, but the seconder was not identified. The motion carried on a roll call (For: 5, Loraine, Fernandez, Cwirko-Godycki, Diaz Nash, Newsom; Against: 0; Absent: 0).
- City employees get a clear reporting chain and no duty to confront anyone.
- Immigrant residents get a single source of verified information after an incident.
- Federal agents can be told to leave city property, but no one will physically enforce that order.
What's next: Councilmember Lisa Diaz Nash urged colleagues to keep watching what other cities do and to consider future amendments. "We always need to be thinking about what's happening around us," she said. The agenda report and a regional jurisdictional comparison are posted with the item.
Police Chief Draws the Legal Lines
Why it matters: The longest stretch of council questioning came down to one issue: what local police can and cannot do when ICE is operating in San Mateo. The answers narrowed several ideas council members raised. They also rebutted claims that officers have been told to avoid ICE.
Where things stand: Councilmember Danielle Cwirko-Godycki asked about drones and about checking on residents after incidents. "If ICE has eyes on us, why don't we use our drones and put eyes in the sky?" she asked.
Chief Barberini said the department typically finds out after agents have already left. "The police department learns of that activity via social media," said Barberini, Police Chief. He noted that federal law penalizes impeding federal agents. He added that department drone policy requires "some type of a crime or some type of significant incident like a fire or flood or something like that."
The city attorney added a caution: "I think we need to be extremely careful when it comes to conducting activity anywhere in the vicinity of a federal law enforcement operation."
Councilmember Rob Newsom Jr. pressed on basic service. "I just want to make sure that if you get a phone call from my neighbor who says there's people out in my front yard with guns drawn, we're sending somebody there," he said. The chief agreed that officers would respond. On claims of a directive to avoid ICE, Barberini said: "We've never been given that direction, and that has not occurred in our city."
Mayor Loraine asked whether enforcement of the vehicle code changes when ICE is present. The chief said it does not. He added that using local laws to impede federal agents would create legal and constitutional problems.
Cooperation vs. participation: Mayor Loraine read item 4 of the reaffirmed welcoming resolution. It promises "appropriate cooperation" with federal immigration agencies in matters involving criminal activity and public safety. He asked whether that language conflicts with the new amendment.
"Cooperation is not the same thing as participation," said Yamaguma, citing valid judicial warrants and court orders as examples of cooperation. The chief drew the same line for ICE holds: "The detainers are not a judicial warrant, and there's no legal requirement to comply with those." He said the department would cooperate with a judicial warrant.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The information gap runs in both directions. "We're not getting any communication from ICE one way or the other as to why they're detaining the people they're detaining," said Newsom. The chief said state law also closes the channel from the city's side: "We are prohibited by law from sharing any information with ICE, whether a judicial warrant exists or not."
What this means for residents:
- 911 response is unchanged.
- Police will not honor ICE detainers.
- Proactive steps such as drones or advance checks remain off the table under current law and policy.
Point Person, Contractors and Unfinished Business
Where things stand: Deputy Mayor Fernandez pointed to Foster City's approach to public notification and pushed for an in-house spokesperson. Speaking to the city manager, she said she wanted assurance that "if something does occur on city property, you would be the first to tell the public."
City Manager Alex Khojikian said he would step up personally. "The city manager would be the point person regardless," he said, and noted that his role covers city property only. Mayor Loraine pointed out that the resolution already provides for sharing information after review by the city attorney. Staff added that the city manager issued a statement after the last incident, and that similar direction does not need to be written into the resolution.
The city manager said the city gets no advance warning of ICE activity. "We do not communicate and we don't engage," he said. Fernandez said she valued that the resolution "explicitly says that the city manager is the point person."
Contractors: Fernandez also asked whether the resolution could reach private third parties that contract with the city. She used a hypothetical Police Activities League program at a private site as her example. The city attorney saw no problem stating that city property cannot be used for unauthorized purposes, either directly or through a private third party. He cautioned, however, that a contractor is not necessarily an extension of the city: "It's an arm's-length relationship." Staff agreed to look into the question but later clarified that it was not part of the resolution before the council.
Detention centers: Cwirko-Godycki asked about a ban on ICE detention centers, comparing it to the data center moratorium the city is considering. "So I would like to include that to be looked into as part of this motion," she said.
The city manager said he would look into it but would need formal direction. The city attorney said the resolution before the council was the version in the agenda packet. Cwirko-Godycki also cited Half Moon Bay in asking whether the city could call ahead to learn of ICE's presence. The chief said that would be news to him and repeated that the city is prohibited from communicating with ICE.
What's next: It is not clear whether the detention-center or contractor requests were added to the final motion. Watch for any formal council direction to staff on either issue.
Minor Items
- Litigation, closed session: The council met privately on one anticipated-litigation matter and two lawsuits, Less Red Tape v. City of San Mateo and Rivera v. City of San Mateo, et al. No action was reported.
- Labor negotiations, closed session: The council met with labor negotiators under Government Code Section 54957.6. No action was reported.
Looking Ahead
The special meeting adjourned ahead of the council's regular 7 p.m. meeting the same evening. Follow-up on the contractor and detention-center questions will depend on whether council members give staff formal direction.