Locunity — where decisions happen.
Advocates Push San José Council to Make Affordability a Focus Area

Advocates Push San José Council to Make Affordability a Focus Area

City Council • San JoseNovember 16, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

San José’s City Council spent its Nov. 16, 2026, study session on the cost of living. Councilmembers and a coalition of nonprofit and labor speakers pressed to make affordability an official council focus area with measurable goals. No votes were taken, but the session sets the fact base for February priority setting and the next budget, where that question will likely be decided.


  • Affordability focus area gains momentum as councilmembers and nearly every public commenter push for metrics
  • Councilmember Peter Ortiz proposes a San José Affordability Fund tied to major developments, including data centers
  • 26% of county working families can’t meet basic needs, Sobrato Philanthropies reports
  • Mayor Matt Mahan asks for evidence on which income and housing strategies deliver
  • Councilmember Anthony Tordillos floats a minimum wage review as the $18.45 rate lags neighboring cities
  • Staff say city tools have limits on childcare costs, where labor dominates prices

The Push to Make Affordability Official

Why it matters: Focus areas steer the council’s budget dollars and staff time. Putting affordability on that list would move it from a theme that runs through many programs to a goal the city measures itself against.

Where things stand: Councilmember Peter Ortiz went furthest, calling for affordability to become a focus area backed by a dedicated revenue stream. “We should establish a San Jose Affordability Fund, supported by legally permissible contributions from major developments, including data centers,” said Ortiz.

Councilmember Pamela Campos argued that the city’s existing efforts need a unifying goal. “There is a difference between doing the work that contributes to affordability and making affordability in and of itself a measure of our city’s success,” said Campos. She also asked how the city might measure displacement and whether it could set a shared 10- to 15-year goal.

Councilmember David Cohen offered a different structure: build affordability into every department’s goals. “Integrating affordability into the department goals where we can actually have departments come back and say, here’s the levers we can pull,” said Cohen.

Councilmember Domingo Candelas backed institutionalizing affordability as a lens for reviewing policy. Councilmember Rosemary Kamei asked staff to bring back options for the council to consider. Mayor Matt Mahan said affordability should at minimum be a key lens for city work, a position short of committing to a formal focus area.

Measuring progress: Staff said the city’s quarterly resident survey will continue. They described adding the self-sufficiency standard as a separate, additional effort, since the city currently has that data only at the county level. The standard is a bare-bones estimate of what a family needs to cover basic costs. John Matthew Sobrato, Director of Impact and Learning at Sobrato Philanthropies, walked through the methodology from the University of Washington’s Center for Women’s Welfare and Joint Venture Silicon Valley’s Financial Well-Being Survey.

An organized coalition shows up: Public comment was dominated by speakers tied to the REAL Coalition, Working Partnerships USA, Catholic Charities, SIREN and allied groups, nearly all asking for a vote. “We urge the council to please make affordability a city council focus area with clear metrics,” said Jeremy Barros of Amigos de Guadalupe Center for Justice and Empowerment and the REAL Coalition. He said far more families are seeking services.

Jeffrey Buchanan of Working Partnerships USA criticized the current focus areas, contrasting delivery robots with a threatened food pantry. He asked the council to add affordability and quality jobs. Darcy Green of Latinas Contra Cancer urged the council to agendize a vote and cited research showing Latinas earn $21 an hour against $38 regionally. Brittany Stonehouse of Catholic Charities of Santa Clara County said her organization serves more than 100,000 residents a year, many well below the poverty line.

Allison Singhalani, Director of Policy at SV at Home, called for dedicated funding for deeply affordable housing and said an affordable housing funding measure will be requested. Isela Reyes of Sacred Heart Community Service said she was priced out of East San José in 2021. Huy Tran, Executive Director of SIREN, said surveys of immigrant families ranked housing and health care as top concerns.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No action was taken. The coalition, made up of service providers, housing advocates, and immigrant and Latina-led groups, is plainly organizing for a formal vote before next year’s budget. Developers, including data center builders, would be the contributors under Ortiz’s fund concept, though no details on contribution levels were offered.

What’s next: Staff framed the session as groundwork for February priority setting, where a focus area vote could surface.


Jobs Aren’t Closing the Gap

Why it matters: The mayor acknowledged that the council has spent less time on raising incomes than on lowering costs. That leaves the income side largely open heading into budget season.

Where things stand: Camille Llanes-Fontanilla, Senior Vice President for Community Impact and Systems Change at Sobrato Philanthropies, set the stakes. “26% of working families in Santa Clara County cannot meet their basic needs,” she said. She reported that East and Downtown San José are hardest hit. “Having a job isn’t enough,” said Llanes-Fontanilla.

Jen Baker, Director of the Office of Economic Development and Cultural Affairs, reported that Work2Future had a $14.44M operating budget in 2025-26, served 2,422 job seekers and focuses on the traded sector. The program is mostly federally funded through the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA).

“I think on the income side, we have spent less time as a council talking about what we can do to empower people economically,” said Mahan. He asked where the highest return lies among small business support, education, apprenticeships and youth jobs. He requested more evidence-based analysis during budget study sessions. Llanes-Fontanilla pointed to quality jobs frameworks, the Spartan Eastside Promise with San José State and small business navigation.

The minimum wage question: Staff noted that San José’s minimum wage began in 2012 and reached $15 by 2019 under a 2016 ordinance. Annual inflation adjustments have since brought it to $18.45. Councilmember Anthony Tordillos said it now trails Mountain View, San Francisco, Sunnyvale and Santa Clara. He attributed part of the lag to a 5% cap that kept the wage from keeping pace with inflation.

A full-time minimum wage worker earns about $38,000 a year, he said. That is nearly $5,000 below the threshold for 30% of area median income (AMI), a common benchmark for deed-restricted affordable housing. “I do think it may be time for us to at least consider how our minimum wage is working for our residents,” said Tordillos. He added that any review should weigh the effects on small businesses.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No direction was formalized. Low-wage workers and residents of affordable housing have the most at stake in a wage review. Small businesses would bear the costs, and Tordillos flagged that tension himself.

What’s next: Workforce investment priorities are expected to be debated during budget study sessions.


What Austin Got Right on Housing

The basics: “Missing middle” housing refers to duplexes, triplexes and small multiplexes that fall between single-family homes and large apartment buildings.

Where things stand: Christopher Burton, Director of Planning, Building and Code Enforcement, said 84% of San José’s residential land is zoned single-family. The city also faces geographic limits on expansion, and cost-of-development studies show many projects do not pencil out. He noted that Austin’s housing stock grew about 10.5% from 2021 to 2024 while rents fell about 4%. The key policy difference from San José, he said, is that Austin allows two or three homes on a single-family lot.

Mahan pushed back on that framing. “But how much housing did they build? Of what type?” he asked. He noted that about half of Austin’s new homes were large multifamily buildings near transit. Burton agreed that “the biggest return will be on multifamily housing when the economics shift.” With construction costs constraining larger projects, he said, the city is looking to missing middle housing for now.

The other side: Ruth, a public commenter, opposed further housing deregulation, citing a 2021 city study and environmental and fiscal concerns.

Why it matters: Planning staff time is limited. The state-required housing element also obligates the city to report on the impact of its policies, so council wants evidence on which reforms deliver the most homes.


Childcare: Where City Power Runs Thin

Where things stand: Staff cited the council’s October direction to add childcare land-use revisions to the Planning, Building and Code Enforcement work plan. They pointed to models in Los Angeles, Sacramento and Long Beach, as well as San Francisco’s commercial rent tax.

When asked how much the city can do without a countywide ballot measure, a staff presenter was blunt: “The real challenge is the staffing costs for childcare.” That means zoning reform may have limited effect on prices. Campos said permitting changes will save prospective operators more than $30,000. Mahan pointed to voter-approved county measures elsewhere and to the state’s expansion of transitional kindergarten.

Councilmember Bien Doan asked about moderate-income families and childcare-sharing. Staff described the Family, Friend, and Neighbor program. Public commenter Angelica Ramos Allen of Grail Family Services said her own family pays $35,000 a year for infant and after-school care.

Why it matters: Childcare is the largest line in many family budgets. Large-scale subsidies elsewhere rely on voter-approved taxes, a lever that sits mostly beyond City Hall.


  • Clean energy rates: San José Clean Energy rates are the lowest ever, but “those rates are not sustainable long term,” said Lori Mitchell, Director, citing PG&E’s exit fee known as the PCIA.
  • Stormwater backlog: Jeff Provenzano, Environmental Services Director, said stormwater rates are unchanged in 15 years, creating a maintenance backlog.
  • Water and trash: The municipal water system serves about 12% of San José; garbage and sewer rates are mid-range or low regionally.
  • Transit pressure: Public commenter Jordan said the city is off track on Move San José goals and linked transit costs to food access.
  • Property tax idea: A statement read by the clerk proposed fixing base property tax rates at purchase, with increases subject to voter approval.

Looking ahead: Staff will return with further analysis on metrics, focus area options and high-return investments. Watch for those to resurface at February priority setting and in budget study sessions.

Advocates Push San José Council to Make Affordability a Focus Area | City Council | Locunity