

Seventh-Grade Math Stalls at 42.9% as Contested Contract Clears Consent
Governing Board • San Francisco Unified School DistrictNovember 17, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
San Francisco Unified's seventh-grade math proficiency is stuck at 42.9%, the same as last year, and staff rated the district significantly off track against its long-term goal. In a Nov. 17, 2026 meeting that ran past 10 p.m., the Board of Education spent nearly two hours questioning the math strategy but declined to accept the report while old targets remain in place. Earlier, the board approved its consent calendar 5-1 after about an hour of public comment, much of it focused on a three-year student-services agreement with Arab Community Services (ACS) and the Arab Resource and Organizing Center (AROC).
- Grade 7 math flat at 42.9%, rated significantly off track; board withholds acceptance
- Consent calendar passes 5-1 after Commissioner Ray's motion to table the ACS/AROC deal dies
- English learner results draw scrutiny in a shortened literacy report; acceptance withheld again
- Organized teacher and parent blocs press the board on ethnic studies and an AI moratorium
- New general counsel hired 7-0 on a contract through June 30, 2029
Math Progress Stalls as Equity Gaps Surface
Why it matters: Seventh-grade math is a gateway to Algebra 1 and, later, UC/CSU-eligible coursework. Board members are tying math strategy to budget decisions.
Where things stand: Superintendent Hsu presented Interim Goal 2.2, which targets 44% grade 7 math proficiency by March 2027. Fall 2026 results came in at 42.9%, unchanged from last year.
"We are rating our progress monitoring status as significantly off track against our longer-term goal-to-target," said Superintendent Hsu. Staff rated the goal partially off track against the recalibrated target.
The companion measure, Guardrail 3.1, tracks classroom "learning walks" and targets 62% by May 2027. Almost 84% of observed math classrooms were rated yes or mostly on Core Action 1, with lower ratings on Core Actions 2 and 3. Enrollment in math labs rose from 235 to 539 students. Marina Middle School shared a story of 5% growth.
"We're not using these learning walks to evaluate teachers," said Dr. Steiner, district staff.
The equity picture: The discussion opened with a memo on math placement and course completion. "Roughly half of our African American students didn't earn 30 math credits with a C or above," said Commissioner Parag Gupta. He noted that about 40% of Latina students also fell short and asked for school-level analysis. Staff said no school-by-school review had been done and linked the question to Goal 3 monitoring.
Board President Phil Kim asked whether staff plan to investigate why students retake Algebra 1 in ninth grade. Earlier, during public comment, Guadalupe Elementary parent Roberto Guzman Rivera asked for a public timeline on the district's multi-tiered system of supports (MTSS) and for disaggregated reporting.
The other side: Commissioners questioned the measures, the theory of action and the quality of feedback. Commissioner Supryia Ray asked how well learning walks guide strategy. Commissioner Matt Alexander asked which traits of schools and leadership teams produce the outcomes the district wants.
Commissioner Alida Fisher asked "what it's going to take to invest and resource and scale this." The superintendent pointed to substitute coverage as a key cost: "In order to pull a teacher out of a classroom, you need to also pay for a sub to support that classroom."
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The board took no formal tally. Acting as facilitator, Commissioner Lisa Weissman-Ward explained the board's position: "I don't think we can vote yes based on the fact that we're voting on these old, old targets." The flat results leave the district off track for its 2028 goal. Black and Latino students, whose credit gaps were flagged directly, have the most at stake.
What's next: New one-year targets are expected at the next meeting.
ACS/AROC Contract Rides Through on Consent
Why it matters: A three-year agreement giving an outside group direct access to students passed in a routine block vote. Most of the roughly hour-long public comment asked the board to pull it for public debate.
Where things stand: Item F65 sat among consent items F1 through F67. Board Vice President Jaime Huling explained the board's broader approach: "We will be moving most agenda items to our consent calendar, as we have been, and identifying only our highest priority agenda items to discuss."
The opposition: Parents, teachers and a student urged removal. They cited statements attributed to an ACS/AROC youth coordinator, antisemitism experienced by Jewish students, and the lack of public discussion, curriculum review and competitive bidding.
- Eleventh grader Olivia Coleman described feeling suspicion after sharing she would travel to Israel.
- Parent Vivian Safran said F65 has a vague title and less oversight than the prior contract, and asked whether the curriculum had been reviewed.
- Alice Fong Yu parent Lillian Archer said future contracts should be competitively bid rather than automatically renewed.
- A commenter named Sarah argued that the contract names Arab Community Services while AROC runs the program, creating legal liability and distrust.
- Jonathan Minster echoed a JCRC Bay Area statement asking that the item be pulled and delayed for stakeholder input.
- Frank Chung cited AROC's response to Oct. 7 and a federal investigation.
The other side: Supporters said the program serves newcomer Arab students.
- Mary Cadena, a former SFUSD educator, questioned whose realities the board is weighing.
- Rachel Jones, a director at Coleman Advocates, said her organization stands with the resources AROC has given students, families and SFUSD.
- A Jewish SFUSD teacher of 26 years said she had seen students benefit, and noted that few speakers addressed Arab and Muslim students' needs.
- Another teacher argued that anti-Zionism is not antisemitism.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Huling noted that under Board Policy 9322, the only motion allowed on the consent calendar is a motion to table to the next meeting. "I would like to make a motion to table item F65, specifically the first contract," said Commissioner Ray. No one seconded, so the motion died. The full calendar then passed.
- For: 5 — Alexander, Weissman-Ward, Gupta, Fisher, Huling
- Against: 1 — Ray
- Recused: 1 — Kim, who has a standing recusal from the consent calendar
Student delegate Anna Nguyen cast an advisory yes vote, which does not count toward the tally.
The agreement proceeds without separate public discussion. Opponents' demands for content review and oversight remain unanswered on the record.
English Learner Gains Remain Elusive
Where things stand: The board shortened the Goal 1.2 literacy report after the long math discussion. Glen Park's principal described a year spent observing, followed by a focus on designated English language development (ELD), aligned schedules for teacher collaboration and small-group ELD.
Why it matters: English learner outcomes remain weak. The district also lacks a master scheduler to help schools build in collaboration time.
The questions: Vice President Huling asked whether the central office could help schools set up collaboration time so each principal doesn't have to reinvent the wheel. Commissioner Alexander asked how the district is processing weak English learner results. Staff cited recent changes to reclassification law, an 18.3% figure for Interim Goal 1.3 and plans to add multilingual learner coordinators.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No tally was recorded. The facilitator again signaled that the report could not be accepted under the old targets.
Teacher and Parent Blocs Press Two Causes
Ethnic studies: A bloc of teachers asked the board to publicly affirm ethnic studies as a full-year course. They cited a lawsuit by the Brandeis Center and StandWithUs that, they said, would eliminate parts of the curriculum on Palestine and U.S. militarism.
- Ethnic studies teacher Brendan Fong urged the board to join an amicus brief against the lawsuit.
- Balboa High special education teacher Eric Schatzstedt warned that the case sets a precedent.
- Speakers cited UC Irvine and Stanford studies on student outcomes.
- Jewish speakers, including retired educator Eric Brenner and a member of the Or Shalom community, said they opposed censorship by outside organizations. The Or Shalom member called the lawsuit "lawfare."
AI and screens: Members of Tech in Check said their group has 393 members in 65 schools and more than 1,200 petition signatures calling for a temporary moratorium on student AI use.
- Speakers cited a California Federation of Teachers (CFT) call for a moratorium and Common Sense Media testing of Google's AI.
- Retired instructional coach Karen Osher urged limits on screen time and generative AI.
- Diana, a kindergarten parent and former substitute, described classrooms where students spent hours on YouTube or phones.
- Members called pen and paper a simple alternative and cited Board Policy 6163.4 as an obligation.
What's next: Neither issue was on the agenda, and the board took no action.
Board Hires General Counsel 7-0
Where things stand: As required by Government Code 54953, Dr. Harrell, associate superintendent of human resources, read the contract terms aloud before the vote:
- Term from Nov. 18, 2026, through June 30, 2029
- Salary of $315,773.99 for 2026-27 and $322,089.47 for 2027-28
- 260-day work calendar and 20 days of annual vacation
- Management-level health benefits
- Annual evaluation by the board president
On termination without cause, "the district shall pay to the general counsel an amount equal to the monthly salary of the general counsel multiplied by 6," Dr. Harrell said.
Why it matters: The hire completes the superintendent's cabinet. It is the first fully non-interim cabinet since this board was constituted.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Approved 7-0 (For: 7, Against: 0, Absent: 0).
Minor Items
- Settlement: In closed session, the board approved a $65,000 settlement in Student HD v. SFUSD by seven ayes. It took no reportable action on an arbitration against the Northern California Regional Liability Excess Fund.
- Teacher staffing: PIPs and waivers (H4) and local assignment options (H5) each passed 7-0. These items are legally required to be heard as action items rather than on consent.
- PEFCAC appointments: Commissioner Gupta appointed Salmani Rahimi and President Kim appointed Jill Santandro to the Public Education Enrichment Fund Community Advisory Committee.
- Late night: The board voted 7-0 to extend the meeting past 10 p.m.
Looking Ahead
New one-year targets for the math and literacy goals are expected at the next meeting. They will reshape how the board votes on future progress monitoring reports.