Locunity — where decisions happen.
Police Commission Presses SFPD on Flock Renewal Before Audit Lands

Police Commission Presses SFPD on Flock Renewal Before Audit Lands

Police Commission • San FranciscoNovember 18, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

San Francisco's police surveillance contract with Flock Safety runs through February 2027, and the chief expects to renew it. At the Nov. 18, 2026, Police Commission meeting, commissioners pushed to make sure the public and the city's police watchdog weigh in before that happens. The commission also accepted more than $8M in private donations for police recruitment and operations.


  • Flock renewal likely, chief says, as commissioners seek a Dec. 2 briefing on license plate reader changes
  • DPA's license plate reader audit still ongoing, with no firm timeline relative to renewal
  • $8M+ in private gifts accepted 5-0, including a $2M lateral signing bonus donation
  • Gun violence down 30% year to date, while organized retail theft is up 12%
  • Live camera monitoring requests fell from about 41 to 11, all approved, with 10 arrests

Flock Contract Clock Ticks Ahead of Oversight

Why it matters: Automated license plate readers (ALPRs) are cameras that capture and log vehicle plates. SFPD's contract with vendor Flock Safety expires in February 2027. If the department renews early, the commission's review and the Department of Police Accountability's (DPA) audit could arrive after the decision is made.

Where things stand: During the chief's report, Commissioner Kevin Benedicto confirmed with Police Chief Derrick Lew that the Flock contract expires in February 2027 and has not been renewed early. Lew said timing is not set.

"I think we are looking at all our options, but right now I believe it will be renewed," said Lew.

Benedicto asked that if early renewal looks likely, SFPD present newly announced ALPR data retention changes at the commission's Dec. 2 meeting. Lew said he understood the request.

"I think it's important that the Commission and the public hear the details of those changes and how they're rolled out before any renewal," said Benedicto.

The audit question: Later, DPA Executive Director Henderson reported that the agency's review covers ALPR use from March 2025 through March 2026, spanning both Flock and Motorola's Vehicle Manager system.

"DPA's audit of San Francisco Police Department's use of automated license plate readers is still ongoing," said Henderson.

Commissioner Larry Low pressed the timing directly. "Will any of the audit results, preliminary or otherwise, be available for the police department to consider prior to the renewal of the Flock contract?" he asked.

Henderson did not commit to a date. She said DPA and the chief share information continuously during an audit. "There's no surprises in an audit typically," she said.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No vote was taken. The commission is relying on the chief's willingness to bring a presentation forward rather than on a formal directive. For privacy advocates and residents concerned about vehicle tracking, the key question is whether public review happens before the contract decision or after it. For SFPD, renewal keeps an investigative tool in place without a gap. DPA's findings may shape conditions on that tool. As of the meeting, though, they had no public release date.

What's next: Watch the Dec. 2 commission agenda for an ALPR retention presentation. The Flock contract expires in February 2027.


$8M in Private Gifts Fuel Police Hiring Push

Why it matters: Private money is now directly funding SFPD recruitment incentives and a major operations facility. This shifts part of public safety staffing onto donor support.

Where things stand: The consent calendar accepted three gifts. Consent items are routine matters approved in a single vote without separate discussion.

  • Ripple Labs: in-kind office space for the Real-Time Investigation Center, valued at $5,867,083
  • San Francisco Downtown Development Corporation: $2M to fund a one-time lateral signing bonus under a memorandum of understanding with the SFPOA
  • Lateral recruit pilot: in-kind digital marketing worth about $250,000

The item also received and filed quarterly and Internal Affairs Division reports. No one offered public comment.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The consent calendar passed on a roll call vote (For: 5, Against: 0, Absent: 2). Voting yes were Commission President C. Don Clay, Vice President Pratibha Tekkey, and Commissioners Larry Low, Kevin Benedicto and Cindy Elias. Commissioners Mattie Scott and W.S. Wilson Leung were excused.

Lateral hires are officers recruited from other departments. They stand to benefit most from the signing bonus. The donations tie a downtown business group and a tech company to SFPD's staffing and investigations strategy. No commissioner questioned that arrangement on the record.


Gun Violence Down, Retail Theft Up

Where things stand: Lew reported year-to-date figures compared with 2025:

  • Part 1 crime is down 14%, violent crime 9% and property crime 15%.
  • Homicides are even with last year.
  • Robberies are down 20%. Firearm robberies fell 36%, knife robberies 48% and strong-arm robberies 14%.

"Overall gun violence is down 30% for the year compared to last year," said Lew.

The outlier is organized retail theft, which is up 12% over the same period.

Staffing pipeline: The academy has 79 recruits. The 292nd recruit class starts Nov. 30 and targets 40 to 50 recruits.

When Clay asked about lateral hiring, Lew said interest remains strong and is supported by the private funding mechanism. "In particular, what we're working on is a recruitment effort to target out-of-state officers," he said.

Why it matters: Falling violent crime gives SFPD a strong talking point. Rising retail theft, however, keeps pressure on business corridors. The recruitment strategy connects directly to the $2M signing bonus donation approved earlier in the meeting.

Lew also noted the Bikes for Vets event and upcoming holiday toy drives.


Private Camera Monitoring Use Drops Sharply

The basics: Under city Administrative Code 19B, a 2022 ordinance (205-22) lets SFPD temporarily live-monitor cameras owned by private, non-city entities. Monitoring is allowed during exigent circumstances, significant events or active criminal investigations approved by a captain or higher.

Where things stand: Asja Steeves, Director, Policy Development Division, walked through the safeguards:

  • Monitoring cannot be recorded.
  • Public reporting is limited to the census tract level.
  • Monitoring based on race, gender or religion is banned.
  • The cameras cannot be used for immigration enforcement or to enforce reproductive-care prohibitions.

"Live monitoring must cease within 24 hours," said Steeves.

In the first half of 2026, SFPD made about 11 requests across nine census tracts, covering about 40 hours of monitoring. The requests led to 10 arrests, and every request was approved. "Our peak request in 2024 was about 41, and now we're down to 11," she said. Reporting has shifted from quarterly to twice a year.

Why it matters: Use is falling, but the 100% approval rate means the internal sign-off has not denied any request. That number deserves watching as the commission weighs surveillance tools like Flock. No commissioner asked questions, and no one offered public comment.


Minor Items

  • DPA joins reform group: DPA will join the multidisciplinary working group implementing SFPD sexual assault investigation reforms announced Oct. 8, 2026.
  • State appointment: Gov. Gavin Newsom named DPA Policy Director Jamal Anderson to the state POST accountability advisory board under SB 2.
  • DPA caseload: DPA opened 55 cases and closed 51 in four weeks; "conduct unbecoming" was the top allegation.
  • Trans March town hall: SFPD set an in-person-only meeting for Nov. 24, 6-7 p.m., at Police Headquarters Room 1025. A public commenter noted an online listing says 6 to 8 p.m. SFPD said it would look into posting an agenda.
  • Closed session: Votes to enter closed session and not to disclose the discussion each passed 4-0. Yes votes came from Clay, Tekkey, Low and Benedicto; Scott and Leung were absent. One commissioner recused, citing a spouse's firm representing a party in related litigation.

Looking Ahead

The Trans March town hall is Nov. 24, and the next academy class starts Nov. 30. The commission's Dec. 2 meeting may bring an ALPR retention presentation, ahead of the Flock contract's February 2027 expiration.