Locunity — where decisions happen.
Planning Commission Clears Great Highway Large-Vehicle Enforcement in 5-1 Vote

Planning Commission Clears Great Highway Large-Vehicle Enforcement in 5-1 Vote

Planning Commission • San FranciscoNovember 19, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

San Francisco's last refuge for people living in oversized vehicles is set to close. On Nov. 19, 2026, the Planning Commission voted 5-1 to approve a coastal zone permit that lets the city enforce its 2-hour large-vehicle parking limit along the Great Highway. Commissioners also unanimously backed two narrowly targeted Planning Code changes: one to help LGBTQ+ bathhouses reopen and one to bring a culinary hub to the Western Addition.


  • Great Highway permit approved 5-1, ending the last enforcement gap for the city's large-vehicle rule
  • Commissioner Chavez dissents, warning the permit displaces people from their "last area" to stay
  • Fillmore second-floor catering backed 6-0, clearing the way for a publicly funded kitchen hub
  • Adult venues win storefront-window exemption, 6-0, a step toward reopening Castro and SoMa bathhouses

Great Highway: The Final Gap Closes

Why it matters: The city's large-vehicle ordinance, signed July 29, 2025, is enforced everywhere except the appealable area of the coastal zone. That area runs along the Great Highway from Skyline Boulevard to Point Lobos Avenue and includes small segments near Lake Merced. This permit closes that gap. Enforcement is expected to begin in early 2027.

Where things stand: The rule sets a 2-hour limit for RVs, trailers and other vehicles over 22 feet. No parking spaces would be removed. Planning staff member Jeff Horn said the project is not subject to CEQA, the state's environmental review law. He noted about 10 letters, mostly supportive, and said "the department recommends approval with conditions."

Matthew Davis of the Department of Emergency Management made the case that the program is working. "We've housed over 260 households through the program," he said. He also cited 190 vehicle buybacks, about 1,200 citations and 400 tows. He reported that the number of large vehicles dropped from 500 to 163.

Merchants pushed for approval. "We've been asking for this type of legislation for a long period of time, and this is welcome news," said Buffy McGuire, co-owner of Java Beach and member of the Ocean Beach Merchants Association. Patrick McGuire, Java Beach co-owner, said large vehicles take every spot in the neighborhood. A Taraval Street native called the measure a common-sense, compassionate step but said leaders must still find a practical approach for unhoused residents.

The other side: Charles Linker, a public commenter and homeowner, said he was not opposed in theory. "So this functionally amounts to evicting the remaining 163 users from the area," he said. He urged a warning period, designated parking with services such as the Cow Palace lot, and a transition to housing.

Commissioner Chavez drew on her family's experience with homelessness. "This is in fact the last area in which they are currently able to stay," she said. She noted that the program's 2-year housing offers are temporary and that more than 100 people have been placed outside San Francisco. "I also want us to not lose sight of the humanity," she said.

A commissioner asked what would happen to families living in large vehicles. Staff replied that homelessness programs fall outside the Commission's purview; its only role here is the coastal zone permit. Davis said affected people remain eligible for services at the city's homelessness access points. He added that many people placed near John Muir stayed close to their community. On a grace period, he said, "I don't know that we would have necessarily a grace period per se," and deferred to SFMTA.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The motion to approve with conditions passed. For: 5 (President Campbell, Vice President Koppel and Commissioners Chen, McDonald and McGarry). Against: 1 (Chavez). Commissioner So was not recorded voting. Westside merchants gain parking turnover. The roughly 163 remaining vehicle dwellers lose their last legal place to park long-term.

Vice President Koppel supported the permit and said, "Hopefully we can round up all of our resources to give more people access to permanent housing just for their own safety, peace of mind, and security."

What's next: Sean McCormack, SFMTA Director of Parking Enforcement and Traffic, said signs and outreach will come first. Enforcement is "probably going to be early in 2027," he said, and he expects minimal impact in this zone.


Fillmore Kitchen Hub Clears Zoning Hurdle

The basics: Planning Code Section 760 bars catering uses on every floor of the Fillmore NCT District. The ordinance from Supervisor Mahmoud would allow catering by right on the second story only. As Kat Yee of Planning staff put it, the change is "to principally permit catering uses at the second story."

Why it matters: The amendment is the final barrier for the Western Addition Culinary Entrepreneurship Hub. The city's Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD) funded the New Community Leadership Foundation (NCLF) to build the hub at the West Bay Conference Center on the 1200 block of Fillmore. The program includes 250 hours of one-on-one technical assistance and 24 workshops.

Where things stand: Raynell Cooper, legislative aide to Supervisor Mahmoud, explained the upper-floor limit: "Above the ground floor, catering uses do not detract from the vibrancy of a corridor." Keeping caterers off the ground floor protects street-facing retail and restaurant space.

Supporters spoke as a coordinated bloc. Larry McClendon of OEWD said Western Addition caterers have had to cross the city or go to Daly City for commercial kitchens. "There's a lot of chefs in the community. They go to Bayview for the commissary kitchen," said Majid Crawford, executive director of NCLF. Floyd Trammell, a West Bay leader for 23 years, recalled the Fillmore's history of displacement. "I would like the Lower Fillmore to be like the Upper Fillmore," he said.

The other side: No one opposed the change. The only debate was over its scope. Commissioner Chen asked whether other districts had been considered. Cooper replied, "We just felt like at this point it made the most sense to address the issue that was at hand and move as swiftly as possible on it." Chen noted that a broader change "needs to be discussed at Planning Commission before I think it can actually be amended at Land Use."

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The recommendation for approval, moved by Vice President Koppel, passed 6-0. Commissioner Chavez praised the measure: "We really are having community shaping policies that are impacting their own communities." Commissioner Sean McGarry said he hoped the change could be expanded.

What's next: The ordinance heads to the Board of Supervisors' Land Use Committee. Commissioner McDonald welcomed a closer look at second-floor uses across all NCT districts.


Window Rule Exemption for Adult Venues

The basics: Planning Code Section 145.1 requires at least 60% of ground-floor street frontage to be transparent in many districts. Childcare centers, reproductive health clinics, homeless shelters and religious institutions are already exempt. Board File 261019 adds adult sex venues and adult businesses to that list.

Why it matters: Supporters said the rule has blocked LGBTQ+ bathhouses and sex venues from lawfully reopening in the Castro and SoMa.

Where things stand: Ranel Bajoy, legislative aide to Board President Mandelman, described the ordinance as the latest in more than six years of changes. Those include 2020 health code reforms, a 2022 Planning Code correction and the 2024 repeal of a requirement that venues keep a patron register. He tied the latest fix to a variance case heard Nov. 5. "Each time one barrier fell and another appeared," he said.

Sarah Richardson of Planning staff said the change is consistent with other sensitive-use exemptions and with efforts to bring back uses shut down during the AIDS epidemic. "The department finds that the proposed ordinance is limited in scope," she said.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Commissioner Chavez moved approval, which passed 6-0. Commission President Amy Campbell acknowledged that transparent storefronts benefit the public realm. Still, she said, "privacy and safety sometimes outweighs the benefits of a transparent storefront." Commissioner McGarry was blunter: "If there was ever an example of an exception required to an ordinance and rule, I think this is it." Vice President Koppel noted the change could also apply in parts of SoMa and the Tenderloin.


Minor Items

  • 36-38 Gough Street: Request to convert a ground-floor dwelling unit to commercial use continued to Dec. 17, 2026, 6-0.
  • Consent calendar approved 6-0: Teatro ZinZanni project-validity change, 401 32nd Avenue child care expansion, 749 Grant Avenue conditional use, 1821 Haight Street beer and wine service, and 24-hour indoor golf at 2226 Taraval Street.
  • 749 Grant Avenue variance: The acting zoning administrator said he was inclined to grant the site-coverage variance in the Chinatown Mixed-Use District.
  • Board of Supervisors roundup: The data center moratorium extension passed first reading. The Transamerica Pyramid landmark designation went back to committee, and Mandelman's landmark ordinance was continued in committee.
  • Permit Center holiday hours: Closes at 3 p.m. Nov. 25 and all day Nov. 26–27.

Looking Ahead

Planning Director Sarah Dennis-Phillips said the merger of Planning, the Department of Building Inspection and the Permit Center into a new Department of Planning and Building will take effect "July 1st unless something goes very wrong." Transfer-of-function legislation cannot be introduced until the election is certified, likely in December. It must then win Board of Supervisors approval and will trigger meetings with staff labor unions. A joint budget with the Building Inspection Commission is also coming. The Director told commissioners that "if anything, your role will probably just get a little bit bigger." Commissioners asked for a presentation on the merger in the new year.