Oakland Advances Hybrid Meeting Rules, Fast-Tracks Police Commission Appointment

Oakland's Rules & Legislation Committee moved swiftly through a packed agenda April 16, unanimously routing more than a dozen items — including contracts totaling over $10 million — while advancing new hybrid meeting rules required by state law and accelerating a Police Commission appointment to fill vacancies left by recent resignations. Public commenters pushed for transparency on the expiring police officers' union contract and flagged gaps in remote participation across city commissions.

• New hybrid meeting rules advance to full Council to comply with state law mandating two-way public participation by July 1
• Police Commission appointment fast-tracked after resignations deplete civilian oversight body
• Coalition for Police Accountability demands open discussion of the police officers' union contract expiring June 30
• Joint public safety oversight meeting delayed five months, pushed from April to September
• Public commenter flags measurable improvement in OPD internal affairs investigation timelines

---

Rule 33: Oakland Formalizes Hybrid Meeting Procedures Under State Mandate

The basics: Senate Bill 707, which took effect Jan. 1, 2026, amended the California Brown Act to require local legislative bodies to adopt formal policies for conducting hybrid meetings — including protocols for when internet service fails. Rule 33 is Oakland's answer: a three-part amendment to the Council's Rules of Procedure that must be adopted before July 1.

Why it matters: The rule locks in two-way public participation for all City Council meetings and committee sessions, ensuring residents can speak remotely — not just watch. It also creates clear procedures for what happens when technology breaks down, preventing the kind of ad hoc responses that can shut the public out.

Where things stand: City Clerk Asha Reed presented the three provisions: all Council meetings must be held in hybrid format (which Oakland already does), the city must establish procedures for internet disruptions during hybrid meetings, and the rule defines limited circumstances where a meeting may proceed without a hybrid option.

"Senate Bill 707, effective January 1, 2026, substantively amended the California Brown Act. These amendments include a requirement that the City Council adopt a policy regarding disruption for Internet service occurring during hybrid meetings," said City Clerk Asha Reed.

The other side: Public commenter Rajni Mandal, a District 4 resident, raised a pointed concern: the Police Commission currently limits Zoom to observation only, directing the public to submit written comments instead. "Written comments are not the same as real time public participation and that approach does not align with state law or what this rule requires," she said.

City Clerk Reed clarified the boundary: "Rule 33 only applies to City Council bodies, so the City Council meetings and the City Council committees." Independent commissions like the Police Commission are not covered.

Public commenter Kevin Daly urged the city to go further. "State law sets a minimum on public participation, but it does not set a maximum," he said. "The city is allowed to find a way of having two-way remote participation for commission meetings and I encourage it to do so, even though the state law does not require it."

Decisions: The committee voted 4-0 (For: Councilmember Rowena Brown, Councilmember Carroll Fife, Councilmember Janani Ramachandran, Council President Kevin Jenkins; Against: none) to forward Rule 33 to the May 5 City Council meeting on non-consent, ensuring it receives full discussion rather than a quick consent vote.

What's next: The full City Council will take up Rule 33 at its May 5 meeting. Adoption must occur before the July 1 state deadline. The question of whether Oakland will voluntarily extend two-way remote access to independent commissions remains unresolved.

---

Police Commission Appointment Gets Urgency Finding After Resignations

Why it matters: Multiple resignations have left vacancies on Oakland's Police Commission, the civilian body responsible for overseeing the police department. Filling seats quickly is essential to maintaining quorum and keeping the oversight apparatus functioning.

Where things stand: The Mayor's chief of staff requested both a title change — adding the word "alternate" to clarify Doug Wong's seat designation — and an urgency finding to bypass the regular scheduling process.

"With the recent resignations on the Police Commission, we would like to move forward Mr. Doug Wong to the April 23, 2026 Rules Committee meeting to be heard urgently so we can get them onto the Police Commission as quickly as possible," the Mayor's chief of staff said.

Councilmember Janani Ramachandran voiced strong support, noting Wong is a constituent of her District 4.

During Open Forum, Rajni Mandal added broader context. She noted that a recent city attorney legal opinion clarified that selecting an alternate requires formal commission action, appropriate notice, and remains subject to the full selection panel and council confirmation process. She also highlighted a striking pattern: "Since 2020, about 1 in 4 public legal opinions from the city attorney have involved the Police Commission. That's not a small number. It suggests ongoing questions about structure, process, and governance."

Decisions: The committee voted 4-0 to approve the urgency finding and title change, scheduling Wong's confirmation hearing for the April 23 Rules Committee meeting.

---

Coalition Demands Transparency on Police Union Contract Expiring June 30

Why it matters: The memorandum of understanding with the Oakland Police Officers Association governs not just compensation but also overtime control and civilianization policy — issues with direct budget and public safety implications. The current contract expires June 30, and advocates argue the public is being shut out of negotiations.

Where things stand: During Open Forum, Paula Hawthorne, speaking on behalf of herself and the Coalition for Police Accountability, called on the committee to schedule a city administrator report on the Public Safety agenda detailing planned changes to the MOU.

"The memorandum of understanding with the Oakland Police Officers Association expires June 30th. I'm asking you, and also the Coalition for Police Accountability is asking you, to put in the Public Safety agenda a report from the city administrator on what changes the city will be making in the MOU," she said.

Hawthorne pushed back on any notion that contract talks are solely about dollars. "Don't you want to hear what changes the people of Oakland would like to see? There's a lot in that MOU that's not just about money. It's about policy. And you really need to have an open, transparent discussion about it."

What's next: No formal action was taken on Hawthorne's request. The June 30 expiration date creates a narrow window for any public hearing before Council votes on a new agreement.

---

Joint Police Oversight Meeting Pushed Five Months to September

The committee canceled the April 28 joint special meeting of the Public Safety Committee, the Police Commission, and the Community Policing Advisory Board, rescheduling it to Sept. 29.

Why it matters: The joint meeting is one of the few sessions where all three police oversight bodies convene together. Pushing it from April to September delays a key cross-body accountability session by five months.

Assistant to the City Administrator Felicia Verdin recommended the cancellation and rescheduling, noting the Homeless Strategic Plan item from the canceled meeting would move to the May 5 City Council consent calendar and the OPD Crime Data Report would be added to the May 12 Public Safety Committee agenda.

On the same item, Rajni Mandal requested that the independent monitor's most recent sustainability report be included in the April 21 Public Safety Committee NSA update, citing real progress. "Internal affairs investigations are being completed faster, with most minor cases now meeting the 85% timeliness goal and major cases getting really close. The monitor specifically commended OPD's progress. This is the first time in years we are seeing consistent, measurable improvement."

Decisions: Approved 4-0 as amended.

---

Minor Items

• Floodplain management ordinance (item 3.1) scheduled to the April 21 Public Works and Transportation Committee. Federal compliance keeps Oakland residents eligible for FEMA flood insurance.
• L/SLBE certification update (item 3.2) scheduled to April 21 Life Enrichment Committee to assess local small business contracting impacts.
• Peregrine Technologies contract (item 3.3), a $1.024 million OPD records search platform that waives competitive bidding, scheduled to April 21 Public Safety Committee.
• CPAB reappointments (item 3.5) scheduled to May 5 City Council on consent.
• Business tax collections audit (item 3.6) scheduled to May 12 Finance and Management Committee.
• Pedestrian safety beacon project (item 3.7), a $304,900 construction contract, scheduled to May 12 Public Works and Transportation Committee.
• Graybar Electric cooperative agreement (item 3.8), $1.5 million over five years for electrical equipment, scheduled to May 12 Public Works and Transportation Committee.
• WIOA workforce contracts (item 3.9), $2.65 million in new contracts plus $584,000 in amendments for adult job training and youth employment, scheduled to May 12 Community and Economic Development Committee.
• USC social work internship MOU (item 3.10) embedding graduate interns in OPD operations through 2031, scheduled to May 12 Public Safety Committee.
• LN Curtis firefighter equipment (item 3.11), up to $2.5 million with competitive bidding waived, scheduled to May 12 Public Safety Committee.
• CPRA bi-annual report (item 3.12) scheduled for May 12 and Oct. 13 Public Safety Committee hearings.
• Disability commission annual report (item 3.13) scheduled to May 26 Life Enrichment Committee.
• 2026–2031 Local Hazard Mitigation Plan (item 3.14) scheduled for May 26 Public Safety Committee and a June 2 City Council public hearing. Required for FEMA grant eligibility.
• Four Special Education Partnership Committee reports (items 3.15–3.18) covering children's initiatives, illegal dumping near schools, the Youth Commission, and OUSD school safety were received and filed.
• Councilmember Rowena Brown recognized Dispatcher Appreciation Week, honoring OPD and OFD dispatchers: "I just wanted to make a special shout out to all of our OPD and OFD dispatchers for their dedicated and crucial work in the City of Oakland."
• Kevin Daly flagged that a parking administrator item appeared to be missing from the Finance Committee pending list despite plans for a May council hearing.
• Draft minutes from March 26 and April 2 committee meetings approved 4-0.
• Pending list of outstanding committee items approved 4-0 with no changes.