Locunity — where decisions happen.
Richmond Council Grills Top-Ranked Jacobs Before Choosing Sewer Operator

Richmond Council Grills Top-Ranked Jacobs Before Choosing Sewer Operator

City Council • RichmondNovember 17, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Richmond's wastewater system is about to change hands. On Nov. 17, 2026, staff ranked Jacobs ahead of Inframark to run the plant, sewers and storm drains, but council members first questioned both firms about Palantir, ICE and past lawsuits, and asked for a path to bring stormwater work back in-house.

The council took no action on the sewer contract or on a 10-year transportation plan. Both items will return.


  • Jacobs ranked first to replace Veolia, whose contract expires May 15; staff return Dec. 1
  • Palantir, ICE and sanctuary compliance dominate council vetting of both wastewater bidders
  • Stormwater off-ramp sought as members push to eventually bring the work in-house
  • 10-year transportation plan not accepted after members demand parking, paving and evacuation answers
  • $158M veterans housing campus seeks fast-track SB 35 review and help with an $8M gap

Jacobs Leads Race for Richmond's Sewer Contract

Why it matters: Veolia's contract expires May 15. The next operator will run the wastewater treatment plant, sanitary sewer collection and stormwater collection for a proposed 10-year term.

Where things stand: The city issued a request for proposals Aug. 3 and received two bids on Sept. 29, from Inframark and Jacobs. Both were deemed responsive. A panel of city staff and a West County Wastewater District member scored the proposals, interviews and costs. The widest gap between the firms was in the project staffing and management plan.

"Either firm could do the work, but based on the proposal itself and the interviews, we rank Jacobs higher with more points," said Tawfic Halaby, Deputy Director of Public Works.

The proposed contract runs 10 years, with an option to extend five more and an off-ramp. Capital project management would move back to city staff. "In this contract, we remove that management and put it back to staff. That is a 16.5% basically savings," said Daniel Chavarria, Public Works Director. Staff reported no fiscal impact yet.

Vetting beyond the scorecard: Mayor Eduardo Martinez said the city asked both bidders about lawsuits and complaints and received written answers just before the meeting. He linked the questions to city values: "We have a trust relationship with our community, which is why we're proudly sanctuary city," he said.

Alberto Lázaro, President of Jacobs' O&M business, said Palantir is a vendor, not an affiliate, and that Jacobs complies with the sanctuary ordinance. "Jacobs does not have any contracts with ICE," he said, adding, "we will not use Palantir in this project."

Lázaro also addressed several legal matters:
- A Qatar World Cup lawsuit, which Jacobs disputes
- A client default dispute in Woonsocket, Rhode Island
- A BART matter, on which he promised a written response

Steve Meininger, President of Inframark's O&M group, described a sampling incident by a subcontractor in Houston. He said Inframark develops its own AI tools.

Staff acknowledged the panel ran a traditional public works review. They said the council would need to do more due diligence before deciding.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No vote was taken. "The council retains discretion over whether to direct staff to negotiate with the highest-ranked proposer," Halaby said. Jacobs holds the procedural edge, but its answers on Palantir and litigation are now part of the public record.

What's next: Staff plan to return Dec. 1 to ask for direction to negotiate. The mayor and city manager said a decision could slip past that date, which would shorten the time left before Veolia's contract ends.


Council Pushes Stormwater Back Toward City Hands

Why it matters: Stormwater is bundled into the operator contract. Several members want an exit ramp so the city can eventually do the work itself, but current funding cannot support that yet.

Where things stand: Councilmember Soheila Bana questioned combining stormwater with plant operations. She argued the work "we can give to a small contractor that does a much better job, quicker to respond and seasonal." Staff said two factors drove the bundled structure: the need to have a contract in place before May, and the need for an asset assessment.

Councilmember Sue Wilson asked for an early exit. "I think it is important that there be that off-ramp option at 5 years, at least for the stormwater collection part of it," she said. Wilson held off on a formal motion at the city manager's request.

The other side: Staff said the money is not there yet. "The parcel taxes that are bringing in funds for the stormwater system are actually insufficient," Halaby said. Staff added that bringing the work in-house would require a stormwater rate study and about three years of staffing groundwork.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Inframark said it would work with the city to bring stormwater back in-house. Councilmember Claudia Jimenez, the mayor-elect, said that priority must be written into the contract itself. Staff said both firms will be approached on equal terms. Ratepayers face a pending rate study, and city labor could gain positions if the work moves in-house.


Transportation Plan Stalls After Late-Night Debate

Why it matters: The 10-year plan sets citywide safety and paving priorities, and its funding choices will feed the next budget.

Where things stand: Gail Payne, Senior Transportation Planner, presented a plan with two parts: a Complete Streets program for major corridors and a neighborhood safety program. Crashes in Richmond average six deaths and 31 severe injuries a year. "63% of the crashes are on 8% of streets," Payne said.

Pavement is rated fair, with more than $100M in repairs needed. The plan also calls for "dig once" coordination with utilities, so streets are not torn up repeatedly. Payne highlighted a $4.2M federal rail-crossing grant and a corridor planning grant for 23rd Street.

Public commenters pressed for specific streets:
- Danny Lannis, Advocacy Manager, Bike East Bay, urged $23M and quick-build safety fixes for 23rd Street, citing two recent pedestrian deaths.
- Michael Hibber, a Grant Avenue resident, asked for speed bumps to address speeding.
- Cordell Hendler, a public commenter, asked to add the Barrett (39th) and Ream Avenue corridors.

The other side: Vice Mayor Doria Robinson made parking a condition of her support: "I don't see parking included in the plan." She also asked for "a plan to improve our rating over some period of time" on pavement.

Jimenez worried that cheap, quick fixes would replace long-term solutions. Councilmember Cesar Zepeda said "I'm still advocating concrete is going to live longer." Members also raised evacuation routes, a feedback channel for resident requests, EV charging and the timing of Carlson Phase 2.

Earlier, during open forum, Philip Rosenthal, a neighborhood council president, said a Point Richmond bike-lane meeting drew more than 200 people. He warned that Public Works recommendations would reroute evacuation routes toward the Chevron refinery.

Chavarria offered a one-year option for $5M to $10M: roadway lighting. "You can make Richmond the best-lit city in the entire Bay Area, reducing crashes by 40% nighttime," he said.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The council voted to extend the meeting so the item could be heard (For: 6, Bana, Jimenez, Wilson, Zepeda, Robinson, Martinez; Against: 0; Absent: 1, Brown). Time still ran out before any vote. "I do think that you should come back with answers to our questions before we approve this plan," Wilson said.

What's next: "We are going to bring it back, but we're going to bring it back in several forms," Martinez said.


Veterans Campus Pitched for Long-Vacant Carlson Lot

Why it matters: A privately financed, 268-unit veterans campus at 338 Carlson Boulevard would add housing on a contaminated lot. The project still faces an $8M funding gap and has not yet entered the approval process.

Where things stand: The Veterans Resource Program, founded in 2011 by Rhonda Harris, acquired the land in December 2018. The plan calls for three buildings, for transitional, independent and assisted living, plus space for services. "The need for veterans housing is severe," said Harris, Founder and Executive Director.

The developers cited:
- A budget of roughly $157M to $158M, financed through HUD's 221 program
- A $500,000 EPA revolving loan
- An 18-month construction schedule
- Goals of 50% local and minority business participation

Cleanup of lead left by a former Union Pacific maintenance site will run under state Department of Toxic Substances Control oversight and cost just under $2M. "We have about an $8 million gap currently," said the project's co-developer, the CEO of Eagle Environmental Construction Development.

The team has not yet submitted an application under SB 35, the state law that streamlines approvals for qualifying housing. They asked the city to expedite that review.

Robinson, who sponsored the item, said "this project just takes a lot that's been vacant for over a decade or longer." Sandra Alexander, a public health advocate with the program, cited about 2,400 Richmond veterans. Jack Cottle, a disabled veteran, said he regularly meets homeless veterans.

The other side: Ben Terrio, President, Richmond Police Officers Association, and a veteran, said the Veterans Day proclamation should be routine rather than pulled from consent. Martinez conceded the point: "A lot of times my eagerness to get city business done makes me forget how important it is to come together and honor the community the way that we should."

What's next: No action was taken. Requests for the fast-track review and gap funding will come back to the council later.


  • Consent calendar approved (For: 6; Against: 0; Absent: 1, Brown), including an Urban Greening Master Plan amendment adding 30 native trees.
  • Storm prep: Self-fill sandbags are available at 10 Harbor Way, 5100 Hartnett Avenue and 5201 Valley View Road. Report downed trees to 510-231-3011, and text your ZIP code to 888777 for alerts.
  • Neighborhood councils at 70: A proclamation honored the Richmond Neighborhood Coordinating Council, whose first council was founded by Lucretia Edwards in 1956. A celebration is set for Dec. 14, 2026.
  • Native American Heritage Month was proclaimed, acknowledging Ohlone land. Courtney Belletti, who has coordinated the Richmond powwow since 2009, accepted it.
  • Budget retirements: Staff and IFPTE Local 21 honored retiring analysts Vernecia Ward (28 years) and Bert Jones (nearly 20 years).

Looking ahead: The council met in closed session on city manager recruitment and anticipated litigation. No final decisions were reported. The wastewater operator item is slated to return Dec. 1.

Richmond Council Grills Top-Ranked Jacobs Before Choosing Sewer Operator | City Council | Locunity