Crocker Amazon Turf Plan Draws Wall of Opposition at Parks Commission

The loudest message at the Oct. 15, 2026, Recreation and Park Commission meeting came from public comment, not the agenda. Dozens of youth, physicians, environmental advocates and neighbors spent much of the session opposing artificial turf, tree removal and fencing at Crocker Amazon Park. Commissioners took no action on that issue. They did approve a nine-year Union Square café lease and a $2.2M increase to the Buchanan Street Mall contract, and they opened the door to a briefing on park rangers and homelessness.

---

• Crocker Amazon opposition dominates public comment as speakers demand environmental review and a seat at the planning table
• Coalition on Homelessness presses for hearing on its 12-recommendation park ranger report; a commissioner asks to schedule it
• Buchanan Street Mall contract rises to $23.7M; staff say the Fillmore park still reopens before the end of 2026
• Union Square West Café lease approved: nine years, $5,000 a month plus sales-based rent

---

Crocker Amazon: A Coalition Forms Outside the Agenda

The basics: Crocker Amazon Park was not on the agenda. Opposition to its renovation plan still filled both general public comment periods, Items 4 and 9. The first period was cut off at 15 minutes, and the remaining speakers were pushed past the break.

Why it matters: The opposition spans youth organizers, physicians, environmental and neighborhood groups, and a sitting Planning Commissioner. One commenter said the District 11 supervisor came out against the plan the previous day. That breadth puts pressure on a commission that has not formally taken up the issue.

Where things stand: Youth from Poder led off. Natalie Lopez, a 17-year-old Poder member, opposed covering about 75% of the park with plastic turf, citing water and tree concerns. Jairo, a Youth Poder organizer, said youth want a healthy, natural park and are not against improvements that avoid environmental harm. Speakers cited a youth comparison of 71 F grass versus 151 F turf, along with microplastics, PFAS, stormwater, fencing that limits access and the absence of an environmental impact report.

The health and climate case came from established voices:

• Dr. Robert Gould, President of San Francisco Bay Physicians for Social Responsibility, described the health risks of artificial turf and cited a 2025 Mount Sinai report.
• Xochitl Flores, a Hummingbird Farm land steward and former Urban Forest Council chair, said the project conflicts with the city's Climate Action Plan. She cited the city's roughly 13% tree canopy and more than 90 trees proposed for removal.
• The Visitation Valley Community Action Network is "in strong opposition to installing artificial turf and cutting down mature trees at Crocker Amazon," said Chaitanya Diwadkar. He argued that cost, recycling gaps and heat outweigh turf's benefits and urged investment in recycled water instead.
• Gilbert Williams, a Planning Commissioner speaking as a member of the public, raised the historic and cultural value of the park's two 1934 WPA grandstands. He also raised concerns about displacing programs housed beneath them.

The other side: No staff or commissioner defended the plan during public comment. Several speakers aimed their criticism at the San Francisco Giants' role. "To be clear, the San Francisco Giants Baseball Club LLC has not committed a single dollar to this project," said Wesley Saunders, a District 11 resident, who also alleged conflicts of interest involving a commissioner and a lobbyist. Another commenter called the $50M plan a "heist" and alleged the Giants keep fees from funds raised. These are speakers' claims and were not addressed on the record. Tilde Mao, an Excelsior parent, opposed the Giants partnership over homophobia concerns.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The commission took no action. Commission President Anderson thanked commenters and said the conversation would continue. Vivian Perez, a neighbor, said more than 5,000 letters and signatures have told the commission no, and she asked what it takes for the community to have a voice. Speakers repeatedly asked for a presentation slot and real input; one said they wanted to be collaborators. During the President's Report comment period, a speaker said the Harvey Milk LGBTQ Democratic Club has joined the Keep Crocker Real coalition. Kathy Lewis, a neighbor, contrasted spending on Jackson Playground with the Crocker Amazon plan.

What's next: Nothing is scheduled. Residents are seeking an environmental review and a formal agenda slot. Watch whether one appears.

---

Homeless Advocates Bring Ranger Report to the Commission

Why it matters: Recommendations on ranger policy, training and accountability would pass through this commission. They would shape how rangers engage unhoused people in city parks.

Where things stand: Coalition on Homelessness organizers distributed "We Belong Here," a report based on a survey of 86 unhoused people. It makes 12 recommendations on ranger engagement, enforcement, support and accountability. "It is an ask for collaboration between unhoused community members and San Franciscans," said Lucas, a Coalition on Homelessness organizer.

The tone was conciliatory. Flo Kelly, a coalition volunteer, said the report does not blame Rec and Park for homelessness, and she praised rangers who do the job well. Shakima Straker, a coalition organizer, also praised rangers and department leadership while asking for a full agendized presentation. One speaker alleged that rangers had directed leaf blowers at people beside a park. John Stiefel of the San Francisco Outer Circle backed the report.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Under Commissioners' Matters, a commissioner asked to see the report on a future agenda. "I would suggest first that you ask for a briefing," said Commission President Anderson, pointing to the department as the starting place. The commission liaison offered to set up that briefing. No formal action was taken.

What's next: A department briefing comes first, with a possible public agenda item later. No date was set.

---

Buchanan Street Mall Contract Grows $2.2M

Why it matters: The Fillmore park renovation absorbed unforeseen underground and structural problems. Staff say the overrun fits within the contingency already reserved for the project.

Where things stand: The commission amended the McGuire and Hester construction contract (Public Works contract 1000035182). It rose from $21,513,550, awarded in December 2024, to $23,713,550, and the schedule grew by 60 days to 590 days. Staff cited five drivers:

• Added sewer work tied to a historic brick sewer, with more than $5M of that work funded by the Public Utilities Commission
• New electrical services
• Structural revisions required by the Department of Building Inspection
• An inadequate foundation for a historic spiral sculpture
• Fabrication of the Memory Walk artwork

"This requested contract amendment does not require additional project funds," said a department staff presenter.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Commissioner Clarke-Herrera praised the project and confirmed the 60-day extension. "I'm excited to see the memory walk come to life," she said. The amendment passed by voice vote with no opposition and no tally stated. Commissioner Winthrop was absent (excused).

What's next: Staff expect the park to reopen before the end of 2026.

---

Union Square West Café Gets Long-Term Operator

Why it matters: The lease replaces a one-year interim tenant at a key downtown park kiosk. The new operator will offer seven-day service as downtown recovers.

Where things stand: A request for proposals drew 14 responses. The commission chose Presmex, an entity of the family-owned Buen Rayo Restaurant Group, to run La Piazza. The lease runs up to nine years. Rent is $5,000 a month plus 4% to 8% percentage rent once annual sales pass a threshold. A full alcohol license and light cosmetic renovations are planned.

"This lease is supported by the Union Square Alliance as well as District 3 Supervisor Danny Sauter," said Neil Patel, of Rec and Park property management. Santiago Rayo introduced the group and its Bay Area locations. Laurel Arvanitidis, Director of Business Development at the Office of Economic and Workforce Development, backed the lease and cited its seven-day hours as part of Union Square's revival.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Commission President Anderson declared the lease approved unanimously by voice vote. No tally was stated, and Commissioner Winthrop was absent (excused). The city gains rent tied to sales, and a local operator gains a long-term downtown foothold.

What's next: The current tenant's lease expires at the end of February 2027. The new operator is set to open in March 2027.

---

Minor Items

• Jackson Playground: The state awarded $10M toward the $48M Potrero Hill project. Groundbreaking is expected late next year, per General Manager Sarah Madeline.
• Denny Kern honored: The structural maintenance yard will be renamed for the late operations leader on Nov. 17. "Denny Kern was the heartbeat of the San Francisco Recreation and Park Department," said Commissioner Hallisey.
• Zoo report: Attendance is 52% ahead of last year and revenue is 47% better, but both trail projections. Commenters raised concerns that light shows harm birds and moths.
• Swim team dispute: Leaders of the San Francisco Tsunami Masters, a 40-year-old team, said practice time has been cut. "We have exhausted our administrative remedies with the department," said founding member Joe Meyer.
• Consent calendar: Approved by voice vote, including a roughly $40,000 in-kind lighting grant from the Tenderloin Community Benefit District.

---

Looking ahead: Zoo Lights opens Nov. 6, the Denny Kern yard dedication is Nov. 17, and the zoo's accreditation inspection is set for early December. Commission President Anderson also flagged that "the budget season is going to ramp up again at the beginning of the year."