

Commission Backs $100M Chesky Park Gift as Turf Fight Shadows Vote
Recreation and Park Commission • San FranciscoNovember 19, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
San Francisco's Recreation and Park Commission on Nov. 19, 2026, endorsed what staff called the largest single-donor gift in city history: $100 million from Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky for five parks. The vote is a recommendation, so the Board of Supervisors must still act. Only four of seven commissioners were present, and a steady stream of residents opposed to artificial turf at Crocker Amazon Park pressed their case throughout the meeting.
- $100M Chesky gift advances to the Board of Supervisors after a unanimous voice vote.
- Crocker Amazon turf opponents dominated public comment across four agenda items. Commissioners did not respond to the substance of their concerns.
- Buchanan Street Mall equity plan adopted. Park hours will be 6 a.m. to 10 p.m., and some of the plan's 33 initiatives are still unfunded.
- $1.3M approved for three playground resurfacings and a 131,000-tree inventory, despite objections to rubber surfacing.
A $100M Gift, With a Maintenance Tail
Why it matters: The grant pays for capital projects and also covers five years of maintenance and programming. That addresses a gap critics often raise about philanthropy that builds parks the city then struggles to maintain.
Where things stand: General Manager Sarah Madeline first announced the gift in her report.
"Brian Chesky, the CEO of Airbnb, made the decision to give $100 million to the Recreation and Parks Department. It's the largest gift from a single donor in the city's history," said General Manager Sarah Madeline.
The first five projects are:
- Rachel Sullivan Park
- Garfield Square and Pool
- India Basin Waterfront Park
- Jackson Playground
- Embarcadero Park
More projects are to be determined later.
Staff presenter Lisa of Rec and Park explained how the sites were chosen.
"All of these projects were selected by Rec Park staff with input from the donor based on principles that he selected that we came to call the 5 Cs," she said.
Under the deal:
- Maintenance and programming support steps down over five years, from 100% to 75%, 50% and 25%.
- The donor will pay the first $50 million by February 2027.
- A second payment depends on the department's reporting.
When Commissioner Vanita Louie asked where the 5 Cs came from, staff said they came from the donor and are attached to the agreement. Louie also raised unmet playground needs, such as Lafayette Park.
The money question: "It's a breathtaking and transformative gift, and we're getting a lot of questions," said Commissioner Carey Wintroub. She asked whether the gift helps the department's budget. Madeline said it does not, adding that "our structural deficit does still exist."
"I know how important it is to have maintenance allocation," said Commissioner Sonya Clark-Herrera.
The other side: Supporters included:
- Elaine, president of Friends of Jackson Park, who thanked the donor after 12 years of volunteering for the renovation.
- Cal Callahan, district manager of the Leather and LGBTQ Cultural District, who noted Rachel Sullivan Park will be built about three years earlier.
Critics pushed on priorities and process:
- Tom Radulovich, steering committee member of the San Francisco Public Space Collective, welcomed the project list but urged transparent, merit-based project selection. "We shouldn't count on philanthropy replacing any kind of stable public funding for these things," he said.
- A longtime volunteer, Bob, urged a different use for the money: "Let's please put it in maintenance and the volunteer program."
- Sophie Constantino of the California Native Plant Society asked for support for natural areas and the understaffed Natural Resources Division.
- Public commenter Susan tied the donor to turf elsewhere. "Airbnb is funding artificial turf in 11 schools, mostly in the city's environmental justice burdened neighborhoods," she said.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The motion recommends that the Board authorize the department to accept and spend the grant. It passed by voice vote, which Commission Vice President Joe Hallisy declared unanimous (For: 4; Against: 0; Absent: 3, President Anderson, Commissioner Mazzola and Commissioner Williams). The southeast-side neighborhoods near India Basin and Jackson Playground and the Rachel Sullivan Park area gain near-term capital. Departmentwide budget pressures remain.
What's next: The Board of Supervisors must authorize acceptance and spending.
Crocker Amazon Turf Opponents Won't Let It Go
Why it matters: The campaign against artificial turf at Crocker Amazon Park was the meeting's dominant public theme. It surfaced during general comment and again under the gift, playground and Buchanan items, and it is shaping how residents view new spending.
Where things stand: Opponents said plastic turf:
- contains PFAS, the so-called "forever chemicals";
- creates heat islands;
- reduces stormwater absorption;
- replaces living green space in equity neighborhoods.
They pointed to the Keep Crocker Real community plan, a survey of 218 residents, and 11,000 petition signatures backed by 50 organizations. Bob Hall cited 5.2 million gallons of stormwater diversion.
"Tearing down trees and replacing actual living green space with harmful plastic is an absolute insult to the very ideals SFRPD was founded on," said public commenter John Briceño.
Susan said the department found that artificial turf at Kimball Fields had contaminated the soil with lead when it was being replaced.
"Real equity is funding proper groundskeeping and organic turf management so every child in San Francisco gets to play on living grass, not just kids in wealthier neighborhoods," said public commenter Olivia Qureshi. Under the gift item, she was blunter: "Pause this project. Come sit down with us in our neighborhood."
Frustration ran high. "You know who you'll say yes to? Special interests," said Hall. Public commenter Leslie called the plan "a preventable disaster."
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No action was taken. Commissioners did not respond on the merits. Speakers said the coalition is being ignored, and several contrasted that with the community-led process at Buchanan Street Mall.
What's next: Opponents are asking for a pause and for community meetings in the neighborhood.
Buchanan Mall Plan Becomes a Model, With Gaps
Why it matters: Staff and supporters described the Buchanan Street Mall Equity Action Plan as a replicable template for community-led capital projects. The park sits in a Fillmore neighborhood shaped by the harms of redevelopment.
Where things stand: Lamont Bishop, senior manager of policy and public affairs for Rec and Park, walked through the plan:
- The project budget has grown past $34 million.
- The plan uses the PAEA toolkit and includes 33 initiatives in five focus areas.
- All six qualified workforce referrals were hired.
- The park will include a Memory Walk.
Bishop also proposed cutting hours from the neighborhood-park standard of 5 a.m. to midnight down to 6 a.m. to 10 p.m., in response to neighbors' requests for quiet.
Wintroub asked whether the Commission was approving future initiatives that have no funding yet. "We are working to identify where the funds are," Bishop said. He added that partners are targeted "within 6 months after the park opens."
"This is part of what we in the reparations world believe is a culture of repair," said Clark-Herrera.
The other side: Liz Jackson Simpson, CEO of Success Centers, endorsed the toolkit, saying "this should be a model that is used in every single city project that there is."
Not everyone agreed the neighborhood has benefited:
- Ace, a Fillmore Corridor Ambassador, cited a $43 million figure and said the community saw little of the money. He asked for a $10,000 to $20,000 set-aside fund.
- A Mission resident warned that Fillmore-style displacement could repeat: "Please, no more gentrification."
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The plan and the new hours passed by a voice vote declared unanimous (For: 4; Against: 0; Absent: 3). Neighbors get quieter nights. Local artists, workforce partners and Citizen Film have a stake in initiatives that still need funding.
What's next: Staff will seek partners and funding for the remaining initiatives.
$1.3M for Playgrounds and Trees
Where things stand: Director of Operations Eric Anderson reported an Open Space Fund deferred maintenance balance of $2.659 million. He requested $1.3 million for:
- resurfacing and minor equipment at Cabrillo, Sunnyside and Bodecker playgrounds, part of a prioritization pilot;
- a $400,000 tree inventory contract that will feed the department's STEMS tree management system and map 131,000 trees for risk management.
The other side: Speakers objected to poured-in-place rubber surfacing. "These poured-in-place surfaces are made of recycled tires and they are toxic," Susan said.
Qureshi reported surface temperatures of 93 degrees on rubber and 104.7 degrees on turf when the air was 68 degrees. Another commenter, Bob, argued that engineered wood fiber is ADA-compliant and cited field readings of 144 and 155 degrees.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Commissioners asked no questions. The allocation passed on a voice vote; no tally was announced.
- Kezar Pavilion: NYA/Maffei JV won a contract of up to $1,879,500 for structural engineering on the seismic renovation, after Public Works declined to continue due to staff capacity. About $5 million has been spent so far.
- San Francisco Zoo: First-quarter results are about $1 million better than last year, and the work-order backlog fell from over 600 to double digits ahead of an accreditation inspection. Earlier attendance figures were overstated, though revenue was unaffected.
- Golden Gate Park parking: Maureen Berry called paid parking "an onerous, regressive parking tax." Clark-Herrera and another commissioner asked staff to present the analysis behind it.
- Homelessness report: Coalition on Homelessness members asked again for agenda time for "We Belong Here," a survey of 86 unhoused residents. No commitment was made.
- Consent calendar: Approved items include an $11,950 cash grant for commemorative benches and $95,000 in in-kind trees for the Japanese Tea Garden.
Looking ahead: The Board of Supervisors takes up the Chesky gift, with the first $50 million due by February 2027. The zoo's accreditation inspection is about 20 days out. The general manager warned of a long El Niño season and urged care in parks during storms.