

Pleasanton Sewer Rate Hike Nears Vote Despite 60 Protests
City Council • PleasantonNovember 17, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Pleasanton's proposed multiyear sewer rate increase came before the City Council on Nov. 17, 2026. It drew 60 written protests, far short of the 10,526 needed to block it, along with a pointed plea from a laundromat owner. Council deliberation was under way, with Councilmember Julie Testa defending the increase, but the final vote was not available at publication. Earlier, Meadows and Fairlands neighbors packed the chamber to fight plans to open the Arroyo Mocho north-bank gates and learned that no vote is coming until the new council takes over.
- Sewer rates: 60 protests fall far short of the 10,526-customer majority needed to block the increase
- Laundromat owner seeks separate rate class as his annual bill heads toward $7,000
- Arroyo Mocho trail: organized neighbors oppose opening the north-bank gates, and no vote is scheduled
- SB 580: residents press the city to document immigration policy compliance before Jan. 1, 2027
Sewer Hikes Clear Protest Bar, Laundromat Seeks Relief
The basics: Proposition 218 requires mailed notice and a public hearing before cities raise property-related fees such as sewer rates. Connection fees are exempt, staff said.
Why it matters: The new rates would take effect Jan. 1, 2027, on a multiyear schedule to fund aging sewer infrastructure. Every household and business on the system would pay them.
Where things stand: The hearing caps a process that began in June 2025. The Prop 218 notice was mailed Sept. 1, 2026. Staff said 60 protests had been received and answered.
“If a majority of affected customers, which is 10,526 out of 21,050 customers, submit written protests, the proposed sewer rate cannot be adopted,” said Public Works Director Siew-Chin Yeong.
Staff also made two changes since the notice went out:
- Staff adjusted the cost allocation for Castlewood.
- The single-family connection fee was updated from $2,250 to $2,233.
Mayor Jack Balch confirmed that water and sewer are separate enterprise funds. He also asked about the debt and new-rate elements of the proposal.
The other side: Speakers framed the increase as another blow to affordability. One public commenter said he had talked to more than 300 people and warned of increases of 80% to 131%. Retired longtime resident Doreen Paradiso said the new rate will be hard on fixed-income households.
The sharpest pushback came from Kassem Abul, owner of Plaza Speed Wash. He said his bill would rise from about $5,400 to $7,000. He noted that some of his water leaves as steam rather than entering the sewer, and he asked for a separate laundromat classification, a study or a cap.
“A laundromat is not a typical commercial business,” said Abul.
Staff held the line on methodology. All non-residential customers share one flow-based rate.
“We have determined that wastewater return factor based on the city's data at 90.6%,” said Nancy Pam, sewer rate consultant.
Yeong added that a laundromat-specific rate “will change the entire methodology that we use in the sewer rate study.”
Councilmember Jeff Nibert pressed for alternatives: “Are there any programs that the public can avail themselves of?” The city manager responded that any relief would likely come as a general fund rebate rather than a change in methodology.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Testa said rates had been artificially low and remain below Livermore's. “This is the responsible thing to do,” she said.
Councilmember Craig Eicher opened his remarks by agreeing with speakers. “The cost of living around here is out of control,” he said.
The clerk reported no further protests, and the council chose to finish the item that night. The burden falls hardest on fixed-income households and water-intensive small businesses. A general fund rebate would shift some of that cost to all taxpayers.
What's next: The final vote was not available at publication. If the rates are adopted, they take effect Jan. 1, 2027. Watch whether the council pursues a rebate for laundromats.
Meadows Neighbors Mobilize Against Arroyo Mocho Gates
Why it matters: At a March workshop, the council directed staff to consider opening the north-bank maintenance road gates as a work plan priority. That direction galvanized organized opposition, and the decision now falls to a new council.
Where things stand: The north-bank maintenance road along the Arroyo Mocho has long been gated. Staff said the connection appears in the general plan and the 2019 Trails Master Plan. So many people turned in speaker cards that speaking time was cut from 3 to 2 minutes.
Assistant City Manager Alexa Jeffress reported more than 600 survey responses, “showing a split between support and opposition to the trail.” She said staff are evaluating costs and will update the council before any further action.
The neighbors' case: Roughly a dozen speakers opposed the opening, many under the banner of the Coalition of Meadows Fairlands Neighbors. They raised these concerns:
- A 90-degree blind turn
- Unprotected drops of 20 to 35 feet
- Backyard privacy and security
- Redundancy with the south-bank trail
- Silica dust and wildlife
- CEQA (the California Environmental Quality Act) and the Zone 7 license agreement
Divya Bahadur, speaking for the coalition, called the trail redundant and a safety and privacy risk. Janie Dobbs cited a 6-foot chain-link fence, noise and property values. Gary Dobbs said by his count 36 homes are affected, not 17, and invited councilmembers to visit. Clinton Beacham cited past disturbances, gunshots and harm to wildlife.
The most memorable testimony came from the youngest speaker.
“I love taking risks on my bike, but riding on a trail with these kinds of hazards is not a risk I'm willing to take,” said Arjun Rajput, a 10-year-old public commenter.
Chris Hanam, of the Trails Coalition, asked for a safety assessment and a fire and emergency review. “An additional exit is not necessarily a safer exit,” he said.
Atif Qureshi asked, “How were residents' concerns evaluated, and how did their feedback influence the decision?” He also raised erosion, lighting and costs. Staff's answer was that the cost review is still underway.
The other side: Sharon Pokarski was the lone supporter. She said the south trail offers no privacy either, cited a 1971 Zone 7 agreement and an 8-foot trail standard, and rebutted claims about crime. “I ask that you base it on facts, not wild speculation,” she said.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No action was taken. “There's no vote to open or close at this time,” said Balch.
Adjacent homeowners won time. Trail advocates keep the project's place in adopted plans. Zone 7, which owns the license agreement, remains a key party.
What's next: The mayor said the matter will be taken up in the new year with the new council, after staff's budget review.
Residents Press for SB 580 Accounting
Why it matters: SB 580 requires local agencies to adopt immigration-interaction policies based on the Attorney General's model guidelines by Jan. 1, 2027.
Where things stand: Public commenter Julie E. described canvassing neighborhoods affected by ICE detentions. She also described a therapeutic art project for children and food networks run with the Muslim Community Center. She asked what the city will do to protect children, families and workers.
Jerry Geyer said the only public documents he could find were a July 31 interim city manager memorandum and a statement from the police chief. “I'm therefore asking council to direct the city manager and city attorney to provide a written public accounting of Pleasanton's SB 580 compliance,” he said. He also asked that the matter be agendized before the deadline.
At the mayor's prompt, a staff member said the city is aware of the Attorney General's model guidelines. “We're in the process of developing those administrative policies, and we intend to comply with the law,” the staff member said.
What's next: The council took no action. Advocates will be watching for written policies before Jan. 1, 2027.
Minor Items
- Consent calendar approved: The council approved items 1 through 11, except item 3, by voice vote, declared unanimous. Nibert moved and Testa seconded, and all five members were present. The package included:
- The 2027 council meeting schedule
- ADUs at Kensington Apartments
- A Zone 7 easement for the Mocho PFAS treatment plant
- An Eagle Scout StoryWalk at Delucchi Park honoring musician Don Lewis
- Animal shelter deal delayed: The agreement with Alameda County and Dublin was continued to Dec. 1 after a councilmember called the staff report thin.
- Diwali proclamation: Eicher proclaimed Nov. 8, 2026, as Diwali. An Association of Indo-Americans representative said the festival drew nearly 40,000 people and that “Pleasanton has become a home for this festival.”
- JustServe award: Bruce Byrd of JustServe.org presented the city a JustServe City Award for promoting volunteerism.
- Subdivision dispute: Rakesh Jain said staff refused his agreement, bonds and $181,000 check for 865 Clara Lane (Parcel Map 9455) and denied his appeal. He sought administrative review, and staff did not respond.
Looking Ahead
The Dec. 1 meeting brings back the animal shelter agreement and holds the public hearing on the Downtown Pleasanton Business Improvement District's 2027 assessment.
Outcomes were not available at publication for three items:
- The final sewer rate vote
- Item 15: a Housing Opportunity Site Overlay rezoning on about 30.71 acres, which the agenda ties to a settlement with the Housing Action Coalition
- Item 16: new standards for sports courts and canopy signage