Pinole Roads Hit 'At Risk' as City Launches Fall Paving Blitz Before El Niño

The Pinole City Council returned from its August recess to confront a cascade of infrastructure and staffing challenges, anchored by a sweeping public works presentation showing the city's road conditions have deteriorated to their worst levels in years. The meeting also brought an emotional farewell announcement from Councilmember Cameron Sasai, who said he will not seek re-election, and urgent demands from a resident after a student was injured near Pinole Middle School.

• City roads decline to "at risk" status as pavement index drops from 59 to an estimated 51; major paving contract set to begin mid-September
• Councilmember Sasai announces he will not run again, opening a seat in the November election
• Student injury at Pinole Middle School escalates six-year push for traffic safety fixes; resident demands action on eight specific measures
• City manager reverses sewer lateral policy, eliminating inspection requirements for basic home remodels and restarting paused rebate program
• Public works engineering staffed below 50%, putting multiple capital projects at risk of delay
• Three appointed to Traffic and Pedestrian Safety Committee ahead of critical Sept. 9 school safety meeting

---

Pinole's Pavement Emergency: Roads Deteriorate as City Races Winter Rains

The basics: The city's average Pavement Condition Index — the standard 0-to-100 measure of road quality — has fallen from 59 in 2021 to 54 in 2024, with 2026 projections at approximately 51. That places Pinole squarely in the "at risk" category, meaning roads are approaching the point where basic maintenance won't work and far more expensive full reconstruction becomes necessary.

Interim Public Works Director Matt Brown laid out those numbers in a detailed presentation that consumed the largest share of the evening.

"We're in the at risk. That's where we are," said Interim Public Works Director Matt Brown.

Why it matters: Road deterioration follows a nonlinear curve — once pavement drops below a certain threshold, repair costs multiply. With a predicted El Niño winter approaching, cracks in deteriorating roads could allow water infiltration that accelerates structural failure, making this fall's repair window critical.

Where things stand: The city has awarded a paving rehabilitation contract to McGuire and Hester, with concrete work on Pinole Valley Road targeted to begin around Sept. 14 and asphalt paving starting Oct. 12. The project covers over a mile of Pinole Valley Road, half a mile of Shea Drive (grind and overlay), and 0.7 miles of Marlesta Road (slurry seal). The work includes raised sidewalk crossings, ADA-compliant curb ramps, and the relocation of a raised crosswalk from Wright/Pinole Valley Road to Owens/Shea Drive. A mid-September groundbreaking ceremony is planned.

Separately, Brown outlined an aggressive crack sealing campaign targeting streets with PCI above 69 across all five of the city's maintenance zones, using vehicle impact fee funds to hire two temporary maintenance workers.

"If we're going to do anything significant before the El Niño, that's something that's going to be coming to you very shortly," Brown said.

The other side: Residents and councilmembers raised practical questions about the plan's execution. Mayor Anthony Tave asked how the city would communicate construction impacts to the public. Councilmember Maureen Toms flagged potential conflicts with school traffic at Ellerhorst Elementary and Stuart School, noting that "construction, road construction can be quite inconvenient, especially for students and parents at school."

Councilmember Norma Martinez-Rubin asked about coordinating road rehabilitation with nearby HOA and property manager projects to reduce costs and disruption, pressing Brown on the logistics. Public commenter Rafael Menes asked what options exist between a basic slurry seal and full road replacement for extremely low-PCI roads like Marlesta, which sits at a PCI of 12.

Brown also proposed a morale-building idea: branded crosswalks featuring school mascot logos near campuses. Mayor Tave embraced the concept, suggesting the crosswalks could serve as visible markers of progress: "Every time they see a new one of those crosswalks, it's, 'Hey, this was something that was done.'"

Staffing Crisis Behind the Scenes

The road deterioration is compounded by a staffing emergency in the public works department. Brown reported that when he arrived July 6, the engineering division was staffed at less than 50%. Former Public Works Director Heba El Gwende resigned effective Aug. 17, and Brown was appointed interim director.

Key vacancies include the associate civil engineer position (vacant since 2023), senior project manager, environmental specialist, and a wastewater treatment plant operator. Former CIP Manager Misha Dhillon is returning as a consultant to provide continuity. Two public works specialist positions have been conditionally filled.

Brown said the staffing gap has created a backlog of plan checks — over 200 when he arrived, now reduced to under 75 — and put 48 total CIP projects at risk. He identified several that may face delays, including corporation yard upgrades, citywide pool improvements, roof repairs, the effluent outfall project, and the active transportation plan.

"I have identified potential projects that may be delayed," Brown said. "We do have projects that may be affected and they have been identified."

Vice Mayor Devin Murphy urged staff to return with a realistic assessment: "I'd love in the next couple months for you all to just be able to come back to the council about what is reasonably doable given that we did approve our budget, we did approve the CIP, but it might not be in line with where our current state is."

What's next: City Manager Naomi Kelly committed to providing road and CIP updates at every council meeting through the fall. Brown is using a consulting firm to recruit for the associate engineer position, which would be funded primarily by the Enterprise Fund. A part-time parks caretaker position funded by solid waste funds is also being created for weekend park maintenance.

---

Sasai Steps Down: Council Seat Opens for November

Councilmember Cameron Sasai announced during committee reports that he will not seek re-election to the Pinole City Council.

"After much thought and consideration, I've decided not to seek re-election to the Pinole City Council," Sasai said.

Why it matters: Sasai, who campaigned straight out of college four years ago, championed policies with both local and regional reach, including advancing a wage theft ordinance and representing Pinole on the WestCAT transit board. His departure opens a competitive November race during a period when residents are already vocal about city responsiveness on roads, public safety, and staffing.

Where things stand: Sasai said he believes democracy sometimes means passing power to the next person. He encouraged all eligible residents to vote and pledged to continue serving during his remaining months and as a Pinole resident afterward.

Sasai also used his remarks to flag a forward-looking governance concern: the rising use of AI-generated public comments in local government. He warned that as technology advances, cities may encounter AI-generated written and vocal comments with little ability to confirm whether speakers are real people, and urged the council to incorporate this challenge into its forthcoming AI policy.

---

Student Injury Puts Spotlight on Six-Year School Traffic Fight

A recent student injury during dismissal at Pinole Middle School brought a resident's long-running frustration to a boiling point.

Yassine Arif, a Main Street resident, told the council that "just this past week a student was injured during middle school dismissal and transported to a medical facility." Arif cited six years of what he described as minimal physical improvements despite written acknowledgments from city leadership that the issue was a high priority.

Arif directed sharp criticism at Interim Public Works Director Brown, saying he "completely failed to implement corrective measures agreed upon" at an October 2023 TAPS meeting and "recently claimed that the city measures were halted due to resident opposition," calling that claim "factually false."

Why it matters: Arif presented eight specific demands, including intersection delineators, repaving, dedicated police enforcement, and a formal demand letter to the school district under California Vehicle Code 2137. He called on the council to place the crisis on the Sept. 15 voting agenda.

Where things stand: City Manager Kelly confirmed the Sept. 9 TAPS committee meeting would address the issue and reported 17 police responses and 22 enforcement stops over a recent two-week period. Brown detailed improvements made by public works including no-left-turn signage, repainted stop legends, and plans for double yellow stripe restoration. He noted the school district merged the Betty Soskin campus with Pinole Middle School without notifying the city about traffic impacts and said he has engaged a traffic consultant and is expecting a recommendation report. Brown also indicated he may add a rapid rectangular flashing beacon at the middle school if funding can be secured.

What's next: The council unanimously appointed Allison Carrillo and reappointed Ben Doyle and Crystal Pasco to the Traffic and Pedestrian Safety Committee for two-year terms (5-0; Tave, Murphy, Sasai, Martinez-Rubin, Toms all voting yes). Filling those seats ensures the committee has quorum for its Sept. 9 meeting, where the middle school traffic crisis will be the primary agenda item. One vacancy remains.

---

Sewer Lateral Policy Reversed, Rebate Program Restarts

City Manager Naomi Kelly announced she reversed sewer lateral processing requirements on Aug. 18, restoring the 2013-era policy.

"I made a decision on August 18 to go back to the way we process sewer laterals from 2013 until just a little over a year ago," Kelly said.

Why it matters: Under the restored policy, sewer lateral video inspections are required only when building permits involve two or more additional plumbing fixtures, a change of property use, repair or replacement of a lateral, or purchase of a new building. Interior remodels unrelated to increased water consumption — such as roofs and windows — no longer trigger the requirement. This reduces the permit burden for homeowners doing routine home improvements.

Where things stand: The rebate program, which offers 50% of construction costs up to $4,500 for full replacement and $1,000 for repairs, was temporarily paused due to staffing vacancies but will resume as two new staff members are onboarded. Kelly emphasized that all existing applications remain in order with their original timestamps.

Kelly is also exploring a voluntary sewer line insurance program modeled after East Bay MUD's partnership with SLWA Insurance Services, with monthly premiums ranging from $3 to $20.

---

Minor Items

• Consent calendar approved 5-0, including a NetFile contract at $7,050 per year. Public commenter Rafael Menes questioned why the item listed no fiscal impact; City Attorney Casher clarified the cost is stated in the staff report and was previously budgeted.
• Building Staff Appreciation Day proclaimed. The city's four-person building division conducted approximately 2,900 inspections and issued roughly 900 permits covering about $30 million in construction value in FY 2025-26.
• Rosh Hashanah proclaimed by the council.
• WestCAT transit updates: Councilmember Martinez-Rubin was elected chair of the WestCAT board for the remainder of the year. The board adopted the WestCAT Evolution Operations Analysis, which proposes route and schedule changes to roll out in early 2027; no changes will occur through the rest of 2026. The board approved cost increases in its agreement with MV Transportation, which provides the bus fleet and drivers, and adopted a balanced FY 2025-26 operations budget. A November transportation funding ballot measure could affect WestCAT's ability to implement the evolution plan.
• Councilmember Toms reported on the East Bay Wildfire Government Coalition's review of July 4th emergency responses and noted preemptive road closures in Berkeley and Oakland as a takeaway.
• Pinole Community Theater representative Ben Nakamura asked the council for permission to install drama mask signage on the theater building, create a banner rental program similar to Hercules', and add the theater to municipal directional signage downtown.
• Student-led tree planting nonprofit: Emiliana Rodriguez, a Pinole Valley High School student, presented One Tree at a Time, a nonprofit planting trees in urban areas to combat air pollution. The organization is fundraising toward a $500 goal to plant trees in Pinole and plans to seek city permits.
• COVID-19 wastewater levels at 5.87 in Pinole, per public commenter Rafael Menes, who flagged that a late July CDC reclassification raised the threshold for "moderate" risk — levels previously categorized as "high" to "very high" now register as "moderate" under the new system.
• Public commenter Anthony Vosbrink raised concerns about illegal dumping near 7416 Pinole Valley Road, requested improved security at Bayfront Park (cameras, lighting, signage), and questioned whether senior staff departures signal deeper organizational problems.
• Closed session on labor negotiations yielded no reportable action.
• Meeting adjourned in remembrance of flooding victims in Nepal and Amber Schwartz.