

Pinole Council Splits 3-2 to Pursue Construction Wage Theft Ordinance
City Council • PinoleNovember 17, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Pinole is moving to police wage theft on its own construction sites. On a 3-2 vote Nov. 17, 2026, the City Council directed staff to draft an ordinance requiring contractors to disclose past wage violations and unpermitted work before receiving city permits, after rejecting a broader version 2-3. The council also heard that most of the people its homeless outreach team serves have Pinole roots and confirmed nearly $21,000 in liens on two problem properties.
- 3-2 vote directs staff to draft a construction-focused wage theft ordinance
- Broader substitute fails 2-3, leaving non-construction industries for later
- Building trades unions cite state backlogs and unpermitted work in support
- Unanimous letter will seek a partnership with the state Labor Commissioner and county DA
- CORE reports 80 Pinole participants served and pitches a housing flex fund
- Nearly $21,000 in abatement liens confirmed on two properties, both 5-0
Wage Theft Ordinance Advances on Narrow Vote
Why it matters: Pinole has no wage theft ordinance. It relies on the state Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), whose backlogs leave judgments unpaid. Councilmember Cameron Sasai put the local stakes in numbers: "There's approximately $400,000 in wage-related judgments that have been issued against employers based in Pinole and approximately $275,000 in unpaid judgments for wage theft here in our city."
The basics: The state Labor Code lets cities adopt local enforcement. The City Manager said talks with the building trades moved the concept away from a full adjudication model, with an investigator, hearing officer and appeals, toward a disclosure ordinance with administrative procedures.
Where things stand: Sasai's motion directs staff to return with an ordinance covering public and private projects that require city permits. Contractors would disclose prior wage violations and unpermitted work. Enforcement could include contractor disqualification, financial penalties and holding final approvals or certificates of occupancy until violators comply. City Attorney Eric Kasher outlined options, including business-license affidavits like those used in Milpitas. He cited Mountain View as a benchmark: "the total cost of that program to administer annually is $45,000." By contrast, staff put the cost of one fully loaded new position at roughly $250,000.
Mayor Anthony Tave favored escalating fines for repeat violators. He framed the ordinance as a statement of values: "having the ordinance solidifies this is how we will be doing business in Pinole." Mayor Pro Tem Devin Murphy emphasized prevention and partnership: "businesses that steal wages, frankly, shouldn't get city licenses, shouldn't get city contracts, shouldn't get city dollars, period."
The other side: Councilmember Norma Martinez-Rubin pointed to small businesses such as salons and argued, "The ordinance ought to also be applicable to more than the building trades." Later in the debate, she questioned whether stronger permit processes would suffice: "But do we need an ordinance for that?" Councilmember Maureen Toms said a lean staff cannot take on labor-law specialization and favored a referral role: "... if there's a backup at the DA's office or the state for adjudicating that, I don't think we're equipped to fill that."
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Martinez-Rubin's substitute motion would have targeted the industries with the most wage theft in Pinole. It failed (For: 2, Martinez-Rubin and Toms; Against: 3, Sasai, Murphy and Tave; Absent: 0). Sasai said broader scope could be taken up later. His motion then passed (For: 3, Sasai, Murphy and Tave; Against: 2, Martinez-Rubin and Toms; Absent: 0). Murphy's follow-up motion passed 5-0. It directs staff to draft a letter to the DIR director and the Labor Commissioner seeking a meeting, a referral partnership and wage claim data, and inviting the Contra Costa District Attorney. Under the framework, contractors face permit and licensing consequences. Public Works would handle complaints on city contracts and Community Development would handle private projects, in a city with one code enforcement officer.
What's next: Staff will return with a full cost analysis and data on stop-work orders and violation notices. Industry data requested from DIR has not yet arrived. The City Manager said the letter could go out before the ordinance returns.
Building Trades Make Their Case
Organized labor turned out in force for the wage theft item.
Josh Vallis, a Pinole resident, called for strong enforcement against wage theft and unpermitted construction: "Wage theft isn't a payroll mistake." EJ Cire of Sheet Metal Workers Local 104 described check-cashing wage theft schemes and 102 unpermitted-work cases filed in Concord. Cire said such schemes cost cities permit revenue and safety inspections.
Tim Sbranti, Executive Director, Contra Costa Building Construction Trades Council, thanked Sasai. He said DIR backlogs justify a local ordinance backed by partners such as the district attorney. David Vincent, Compliance Director, Sheet Metal Workers Local 104, urged meaningful consequences and coverage of unpermitted work: "our union alone has filed and is still awaiting judgment on 534 complaints."
The other side: Anthony Vosbrink, a public commenter, asked staff to study similar-size cities. He also requested a cost-benefit analysis covering judgment recovery and the effects on union versus non-union contractors.
Homeless Outreach Data Shows Pinole Roots
Why it matters: The county's Coordinated Outreach, Referral and Engagement (CORE) team said its Pinole clients are overwhelmingly local. That data bears directly on the city's budget choices.
Where things stand: Presenters from Contra Costa Health said Pinole's point-in-time homeless counts were 7 in 2024, 12 in 2025 and 10 in 2026. From July 1, 2025, to June 30, 2026, the West County team served 80 unique participants with more than 200 contacts. Of those participants, 80% have roots in Pinole, 61% were homeless for the first time, 56% had no income and 25% reported surviving domestic violence. Of 22 exits, or 40%, 10 went to permanent housing, with 100% still housed at six months. Eight went to shelter and four to friends or family.
The presenters pointed to El Cerrito and Richmond housing security funds, which cover move-in costs, arrears and vehicle registration. A CORE presenter told the council: "if the City of Pinole is looking to have a housing flex fund, that would be a really great way to support those folks who are at risk of losing their housing."
The other side: Funding is tightening. CORE relies on partnerships, Medi-Cal CalAIM billing and about 30 contracts. Presenters also noted that state-funded teams are sunsetting, and council members asked about HR 1 impacts. Vosbrink asked about city policy on encampments near the Pinole Creek bridge, the library and the high school: "there's 2 homeless encampments underneath the bridge." No staff response was recorded.
What's next: No action was taken. The flex fund idea now moves into budget conversations.
Two Problem Properties Get Nearly $21,000 Liens
Why it matters: The city fronted overtime-based cleanup costs on recurring nuisance properties. The new special assessments place those costs on the owners' property tax bills.
Where things stand: Staff walked through progressive enforcement under Pinole Municipal Code 8.24, which runs from a courtesy notice to an abatement warrant to an assessment. At 1054 Belfair Drive, complaints have recurred annually. The city obtained a warrant July 2, and the home went into foreclosure this year. The abandoned property at 923 Kittery Way has enforcement cases dating to 2009-2010. Crews removed dumped furniture and debris there June 17. Owners were invoiced Sept. 30 and given until the end of October to pay.
When a council member asked about relocation help for owners losing homes, staff said the city has only notified owners of their tenant relocation responsibilities. No one spoke at either hearing.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The council ordered a $10,944.82 assessment on Belfair Drive (moved by Toms, seconded by Murphy) and a $9,986.30 assessment on Kittery Way (moved by Toms, seconded by Martinez-Rubin). Both passed (For: 5, Against: 0, Absent: 0).
Minor Items
- Consent calendar approved 5-0 with no items pulled.
- City Clerk Heather Bell Spears, leaving for Concord, was honored for modernizing agendas and records retention. "it's really hard to believe that this is my last meeting with you all," she said.
- Mann Drive: Public commenter Yasin Arif demanded release of a traffic study and restriping near Pinole Middle School. The City Manager said staff will return after meeting with the school district.
- Closed session on a public employee appointment ended with no reportable action.
- Public commenter Rafael Menis warned that COVID-19 wastewater levels are rising again.
Looking Ahead
City Hall closes Nov. 26-27 and Dec. 24-Jan. 1, reopening Jan. 4. Staff are gathering feedback at the senior center and youth programs on whether to seek a competitive state parks grant for Fernandez Park, Meadow Park or Louis Francois Park. County repairs to the Pinole Creek bank behind Sprouts off Henry Avenue, damaged in January 2023 storms, are essentially complete.