Locunity — where decisions happen.
Piedmont Picks Eden, City Ventures for Moraga Canyon Housing Talks

Piedmont Picks Eden, City Ventures for Moraga Canyon Housing Talks

City Council • PiedmontNovember 16, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Piedmont took its biggest step yet toward its largest housing element commitment Monday, Nov. 16, 2026. The City Council voted to open exclusive negotiations with Eden Housing and City Ventures on 132 homes on city-owned land in Moraga Canyon. The vote came after a single developer response, 13 public commenters and an unresolved fight over where the homes should go. Later, a transfer tax windfall let the council put $1.9M toward long-deferred facilities needs.


  • Moraga Canyon team selected unanimously: 81 affordable apartments and 51 market-rate townhomes move to negotiations
  • Only one bid arrived, and staff defended the choice against calls to reopen the solicitation
  • Blair Park siting dispute persists: opponents cite oak loss and traffic safety, while developers cite cost
  • City rejects cemetery's deed claim on two Moraga lots
  • $1.9M moves to facilities funds after revenues finished $1.5M over budget

Moraga Canyon Moves to the Negotiating Table

Why it matters: Piedmont's sixth-cycle housing element assigns the city 587 units. Moraga Canyon is the centerpiece of that plan, and officials tied this vote to a year-end deadline for county Measure A-1 funds.

The basics: An exclusive negotiating agreement, or ENA, is a preliminary contract. It gives the city and a developer a set period to negotiate in good faith. It is not an entitlement. The ENA, a disposition and development agreement (DDA) and a development agreement will each return to the council.

Where things stand: The council adopted the Moraga Canyon Specific Plan in October 2025. It allows 130 multifamily units and two single-family homes. The city issued a request for qualifications in May 2026 under an exempt surplus land pathway. One team responded: Eden Housing, an affordable rental developer, and City Ventures, a for-sale townhome builder.

"We're in the driver's seat using the exempt pathway," said City Administrator Rosanna Bayon Moore. She said the city has to select a developer by the end of the year to keep A-1 funding and stay on the housing element timetable. "We've got a delivery date by the end of this year," she said.

Staff estimated the city's ENA costs at $50,000 to $75,000. Developer deposits would cover later DDA negotiations. Indemnities and bonds would manage risk. Public commenter Patricia Kerr said the site is ripe for development but asked who bears environmental, bankruptcy and hillside risks, and she cited the city's pool project as a cautionary example.

The single-bid question: Public commenter Marsha Lane asked the city to keep the solicitation open until at least three proposals arrive. Councilmember Tom Ramsey asked how the city protects its interests. Planning & Building Director Leslie Mendez said the selection committee shifted from comparing bids to a deeper review of this team's finances and references. Consultant Libby Seifel of Seifel Consulting led that review. "We do not believe that going out further would heighten the quality that we received," Mendez said. Seifel attributed the thin response to market conditions and to the site's infrastructure and funding needs. The two firms have not partnered before, but they are working together in Campbell.

Who gets in: Ramsey and Mayor Betsy Smegal Andersen asked about preferences for teachers, first responders or seniors. Staff and Eden said fair housing law and funding sources generally bar such restrictions beyond income limits, and that the project is designed for families. City Ventures' townhomes would run 1,400 to 2,000 square feet, mostly three bedrooms, with optional lifts.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Vice Mayor Conna McCarthy moved approval, and Councilmember Lorrel Plimier seconded. The mayor declared the motion passed unanimously on a voice vote. Most of the 13 commenters backed the selection. They included Carol Galante, who disclosed past leadership at Eden Housing, and Andy Madera, who disclosed prior service on the city side. Sarah Karlinsky rebutted social media claims that the project is a developer giveaway. Jill Lindenbaum cited $2.1M in A-1 funding and the chance for future public review.

What's next: Staff expects the ENA to come back on a public agenda in about 90 days. Fiscal analysis and phasing will be negotiating topics.


The Blair Park Fight Isn't Over

Why it matters: The council approved a team, not a site. But the developers have stated a clear preference for the south side, known as Blair Park, and opponents say that choice drives tree loss, traffic risk and infrastructure costs.

Where things stand: "We do think that the south side is the most financially feasible location for a development of this size," said Andrea, Chief of Real Estate Development, Eden Housing. The developers said the north side would require retaining walls, new utilities, relocation of city assets and drainage work, at prohibitive cost. "I think we might be in a situation where you might not have had any applications tonight," said Kelso Barnett, VP of Development, City Ventures, describing a north-side-only offering.

Staff said the city's one non-negotiable is a single integrated project. Officials also described interim pedestrian safety improvements on Moraga Avenue between Highland and Red Rock.

The other side: Public commenter Ralph Catalano urged the council to postpone action until it decides the location at a public hearing. He argued the developer should not effectively pick the site. Marge Blackwell said she did not object to the team but opposed building on Blair Park. She cited oak woodland loss, an expert traffic engineer's report, unanswered questions about who pays for infrastructure, and Measure GG priorities.

The mayor sought to narrow the debate. "We are not reopening our housing element that has been adopted," said Mayor Andersen.

The cemetery dispute: Public commenters Liz Loomis O'Neill and Lawrence Siskind asked whether Mountain View Cemetery's 1992 grant deed limits development on two lots on Maxwellton Road and Abbott Way. "We disagreed with that and do not believe that there are limitations," said the City Attorney. She added that a late letter from the cemetery appeared supportive of Blair Park and did not address the two lots. The developers called those lots hilly and outside City Ventures' core business. Staff said the city kept them in play as a possible fundraising mechanism.

What's next: Siting, infrastructure costs and the cemetery question remain open as negotiations begin.


Transfer Tax Windfall Pays Down Deferred Maintenance

Why it matters: Piedmont closed fiscal year 2025-26 in solid shape, but it got there on real estate transfer tax, its most volatile revenue source.

Where things stand: "Revenues finished about 3.6% over budget, or $1.5 million," said Finance Director Bauer. Expenditures came in $837,000 under budget. Transfer tax hit $5.9M, while property tax grew 3.1%. Fire overtime and workers' compensation ran over budget. The general fund ended with an $8.9M balance, or 23% reserves, before transfers. Bauer projected facilities capital shortfalls starting in fiscal 2028-29.

Relief is scheduled. "Measure GG passed, which is going to increase our real estate transfer tax rate on properties that sell from 1.3% to 1.75%, effective July 1st, 2027," Bauer said. The increase is projected to add $1.5M.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The council approved $1.7M for facilities capital and $200,000 for facilities maintenance, plus $620,000 in within-fund adjustments. Councilmember Jennifer Long asked how staff chose the amounts and why the reserve target is 18%. Staff said 18% equals about $7M, and city policy caps reserves at 25%. The mayor said deferred maintenance is repeatedly cut to balance budgets, and that this time "we have backfilled capital maintenance." Ramsey moved and McCarthy seconded. The mayor declared the motion passed unanimously on a voice vote. The council had earlier voted to extend the meeting past its 9 p.m. curfew to take up both finance items.


Minor Items

  • Consent calendar approved, including a five-year, $347,000 Rec Tech recreation software contract and acceptance of completed sewer and storm drain work.
  • Piedmont High School Wellness Center team honored for securing a $50,000 grant and planning a hygiene drive with Oakland Elizabeth House.
  • Girls varsity volleyball recognized for winning the school's first CIF North Coast Section Division III title.
  • Vacant property liability may be folded into a code enforcement study session in 2027, at Councilmember Ramsey's request.
  • Fire Department toy drive pickups are set for Dec. 1 and Dec. 16; staff also introduced two officers and permit technician Jacob Barkley.

Looking Ahead

Lights Up is Dec. 2. The council changeover meeting on Dec. 7 will welcome two new councilmembers. Mayor Andersen and Councilmember Long said this was their last meeting in these chambers before the changeover.