Locunity — where decisions happen.
Trustees Back May 2027 Parcel Tax Vote as $33M Cuts Loom

Trustees Back May 2027 Parcel Tax Vote as $33M Cuts Loom

Board of Education • Palo Alto Unified School DistrictNovember 10, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Palo Alto Unified trustees on Nov. 10, 2026, reached consensus to target May 4, 2027 for renewing a parcel tax worth about $17M a year, after their campaign consultant argued that a March date risked losing it. They took no formal vote. A resolution is expected Jan. 19, while staff prepare an inventory of 74 cut options against a $33M ongoing reduction target.


  • May 4, 2027 parcel tax election wins consensus over March, despite the teachers union's push for an earlier date
  • $6.7M in better-than-expected revenue; trustees back using a $9.1M block grant for one-time employee payments
  • Outside review projects reserves at negative 2.27% by 2028-29 without changes
  • 74-option cut inventory totals $37.6M, with district office and operations carrying 64.4%
  • David Lee hired as general counsel after debate over whom the position should answer to
  • Parents press for fewer Chromebooks and call a May 2027 committee timeline too slow

Parcel Tax: Trustees Choose Caution Over Speed

Why it matters: The parcel tax brings in about $17M a year and expires if voters do not renew it in spring 2027. Renewals pass far more easily than new taxes. The timing collides with the state's March 15 deadline for layoff notices.

Where things stand: Charles Heath, a consultant with Team CVX, opened with a clear recommendation. "I'm here tonight to make a strong recommendation that we focus narrowly on the May 4th, 2027 target election date," said Heath.

He gave four reasons for preferring May. A March election faces a December deadline and could add up to $1.5M in costs. The campaign would also be squeezed by the holidays, with no time for polling.

Heath pointed to Measure B as a warning. It polled at 72% to 74% but won 62.5% on Election Day, after opposition the campaign had not anticipated. "Renewed taxes pass at an 85%+ rate," Heath said. "We have to do it once and we have to win."

The other side: The Palo Alto Educators Association (PAEA) wanted March, so the result would be known before layoff notices go out March 15. The union said its volunteers and finances were ready. "We are campaign ready for a March election," said Tom Culbertson, President, Palo Alto Educators Association.

Steven Davis, a public commenter, said the district did not need to repeat its polling. He was fine with either March or May. "You don't need polling," Davis said.

Board Vice President Rowena Chiu and Trustee Shana Segal initially leaned toward March. Chiu questioned whether a new poll was necessary.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Superintendent Jason E. Glass listed the campaign steps a March timeline would skip. "There are steps that you take to be ready to win an election," said Glass.

Trustee Josh Salcman said passing the tax was the top priority. "I find myself pretty persuaded that we're better off going with the May date," Salcman said. Segal then switched sides. "I can be the first to admit that I changed my mind," said Segal.

Board President Shounak Dharap said the board could not take action or direct polling at this meeting. He instead confirmed consensus for May.

The trade-off falls hardest on employees. Any March 15 layoff notices would go out before voters decide on roughly $17M in annual revenue.

What's next: Polling and community outreach come first. A resolution is expected at the Jan. 19 meeting.


The Budget: Good News, Bad Math

Why it matters: One-time money and stronger revenue shrink the gap but do not close it. Specific cut proposals arrive in December, and decisions are due by February.

Where things stand: District budget staff opened with "we have good news." The revenue picture improved in three ways:
- Assessed property values are projected to grow 4.64%, adding $3.1M.
- State AB 602 special education funding adds $3.6M.
- About $9.5M in one-time state grants is coming, including a $9.1M Student Support and Professional Development Discretionary Block Grant.

There is a new cost, too. A state mandate for paid pregnancy disability leave will cost about $700,000 in 2026-27 and about $1.4M in 2027-28.

Glass said the county certified the current-year budget. He recommended option 2, which uses the block grant for off-schedule payments, meaning one-time payments outside the regular salary schedule. Trustees voiced support, though no formal vote was taken.

The outside view: Matt Phillips, Associate Vice President, School Services of California, framed his review narrowly. "This is not a validation of the budget," said Phillips.

He found the district's assumptions reasonable but recommended changes:
- Raise the property tax growth assumption from 3.5% toward 4.5%.
- Count about $2.1M in pension savings, $1.8M in health benefit savings and $2.1M in utilities savings.
- Plan for larger district contributions to special education.

Without changes, he projected unrestricted reserves falling to a negative 2.27% in 2028-29.

Davis noted that enrollment has fallen by 2,361 students since 2015-16 and suggested considering school closures. He argued that the savings Phillips found point to problems in the district's estimates.

The cut inventory: Staff scored 74 reduction options against district values:
- 59 Tier 1 options total $28.9M.
- 14 Tier 2 options total $8.7M.
- Together they reach $37.6M, compared with the $33M target.
- District office and operations account for $24.2M, or 64.4%.
- Classroom instruction accounts for $2.7M, or 7.2%.

"Administration absorbed the largest share. The classroom absorbed the smallest," said the district's budget presenter. Staff called bridge funds tools, not solutions.

The other side: Sam Howells Banerjee, a public commenter, asked why roughly $10M in Fund 14 is not treated as one-time money. He also called it odd to group custodians and maintenance with the district office. Staff advised against tapping Fund 14 because reserves are already being drawn down.

Virginia DeJesus-Roof, a public commenter, urged a single round of structural cuts to give students and staff stability. "When you have to take your lumps, do it all at once," she said.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The board took no action on the framework. It did waive its two-meeting rule and approve a voluntary one-time separation incentive program by voice vote. The program is one tool to ease reductions.

Labor is positioning itself as well. PAEA said it will not open contract articles beyond compensation and benefits, class size and working conditions, the areas the district had put forward. The California School Employees Association argued that classified staff make up 19% of personnel costs and that their work cannot be contracted out.

What's next: Specific cuts return in open session in December, with decisions needed by February.


General Counsel Hired; Reporting Line Debated

Why it matters: Whether the district's lawyer answers to the board or to the superintendent shapes oversight and the flow of legal advice.

Where things stand: Trustees approved David Lee's contract as general counsel through June 30, 2027. His base salary is $170,338, prorated. The board amended the agreement to move his evaluation from six months to five.

The other side: John Craig, a public commenter, urged keeping the general counsel reporting to the board to preserve a separation of powers. He cited arrangements in 2018 and 2022.

Glass said current policy makes the position administrative. Dharap warned of unintended consequences if the reporting line changed and suggested a public study session on the question.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The contract was approved as amended by voice vote; individual tallies were not recorded. For now, counsel sits under the administration.

What's next: The board may revisit its policies after a study session.


Parents Push Back on Classroom Screens

Why it matters: Open forum was dominated by an organized parent push. Some parents said they may leave the district over the issue.

Where things stand: Ward Thomas, a district parent, said Chromebooks distract his son. He asked the board to act now at JLS, Gunn and Paly rather than wait for a May report. "Let teachers teach, not police," Thomas said.

Lindsay Chan, a high school parent, described easy access to YouTube and games on school devices. She also cited more than five hours of after-school screen time. She asked for device carts or parental opt-outs.

A representative of Schools Beyond Screens Palo Alto said parent volunteers produced a petition, surveys and a draft board resolution. Their reward, she said, is an ad hoc committee that finishes in May 2027 with only non-binding recommendations. Green Middle School's return to device carts was cited as a model.

What's next: The ad hoc committee timeline stands unless trustees choose to act sooner.


Farewells to Dharap and Segal

The board marked the departure of Dharap and Segal, who leave after eight and four years. Linda Hennigan and Avery Wang were named as incoming members. Jessica Spicer of the Santa Clara County School Boards Association presented certificates to both.

"Thank you for the counsel and the steadiness that you gave me as I started to work here," Glass told Dharap. Speakers praised Dharap's leadership during COVID and Segal's classroom perspective.

The farewells were not all warm. Chiu described clashes over equity initiatives and a resolution she saw as an attempt to silence her. Segal closed with a story about respectful disagreement. "Let us choose not to pop one another's balloons," she said.

Dharap looked ahead to his successors. "I hope that the incoming board and Linda and Avery will do a better one than I did," Dharap said.


Minor Items

  • HVAC and Hoover: Board pre-authorized up to $6.5M for HVAC upgrades at three schools and raised the Hoover project contingency from 5% to 10%.
  • Spending caps previewed: Staff seek to raise design authority to $150,000 per project and roofing authority to $1.5M; the item will return.
  • Teacher mentoring works: Of 11 intern or emergency-permit hires since the program began, 10 remain, compared with 1 of 10 before.
  • Closed session: Board approved superintendent evaluation goals and an $8,500 settlement, and denied two student-record appeals 4-1.
  • County committee: Trustees cast the district's ballot for Carol Prasunke, the sole candidate, for the county committee on school district organization.

Looking Ahead

Two new trustees join before December, when specific budget cuts come to open session. The parcel tax resolution is expected Jan. 19. Reduction decisions are due by February, ahead of the March 15 layoff-notice deadline.