

Palo Alto Unified Board Targets May 2027 for Parcel Tax Renewal
Board of Education • Palo Alto Unified School DistrictNovember 10, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
The Palo Alto Unified School District Board of Education spent more than an hour Nov. 10, 2026, debating when to ask voters to renew a parcel tax worth about $17M a year. It ended with an informal consensus, not a vote, for a May 4, 2027, election. The timing choice came alongside an outside budget review projecting negative reserves by 2028-29 and a staff list of 74 possible cuts aimed at a roughly $33M structural gap.
- Board consensus favors May 4, 2027, parcel tax election over March; no formal vote was taken
- Outside review projects negative 2.27% unrestricted reserves in 2028-29 without changes
- Trustees back using a $9.1M one-time grant to offset one-time employee payments
- David Lee hired as general counsel, but who he should report to remains unsettled
- Parents press for limits on Chromebooks and YouTube in classrooms
- Board says goodbye to President Shounak Dharap and Trustee Shana Segal
Parcel Tax: May Wins Over March
Why it matters: The parcel tax brings in roughly $17M a year. If it lapses, any later measure would be a new tax rather than a renewal.
Where things stand: Consultant Charles Heath of Team CVX opened bluntly. "I'm here tonight to make a strong recommendation that we focus narrowly on the May 4th, 2027 target election date," he said.
Heath cited four reasons:
- A March election would cost more, about $1.5M.
- A May date gives the campaign more time to get ready.
- New polling is needed after a measure drew 62.5% last June, short of the two-thirds required.
- A March ballot would require board action by Dec. 31.
Superintendent Jason E. Glass made the procedural stakes plain. "If you want to be on in March, you need to do a special meeting, and now's the time to express that," he said.
The other side: The teachers union wanted March. Tom Culbertson, President, Palo Alto Educators Association, said PAEA supports the tax and is ready to campaign. "That's why we strongly support an early March election," he said. Culbertson's reasoning: a March vote would spare staff the stress of the March 15 deadline for layoff notices.
Public commenter Stephen Davis said polling is unnecessary and the campaign should start immediately. He said either month would work for him.
Board Vice President Rowena Chiu also questioned paying for new polling. "I do think the information we got from the previous poll is still valid," she said.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Trustees set teacher anxiety against election risk, and election risk won.
- Trustee Josh Salcman said of a failed measure, "the risk of getting it wrong is sort of unbearable."
- Trustee Shana Segal moved from March to May. "I can be the first to admit that I changed my mind," she said.
- Chiu acknowledged the count: "I don't think there's a majority in support of March."
- Board President Shounak Dharap closed it out: "Yeah, I think we have consensus."
The trade-off falls hardest on teachers and classified staff. Layoff notices will go out before voters decide whether to renew about $17M in annual revenue.
What's next: Staff may begin contracting for polling and outreach. The resolution calling the election is expected Jan. 19. Heath advised acting "as close to the deadline as possible to maximize the timeline for that district outreach."
Budget: Better News, Same Deficit Path
Why it matters: Revenue came in better than expected, but not by enough to close a roughly $33M structural gap. Staff and an outside reviewer both said the speed of cuts will shape how deep they have to go.
Where things stand: District staff member Sharon Yu opened the update with "we have good news." Revenue gains include:
- $3.1M from 4.64% growth in assessed property values
- $3.6M more in AB 602 special-education funding
- About $9.5M in one-time grants
There is a new cost, too. An unfunded state mandate for paid pregnancy disability leave will cost about $700,000 in 2026-27, rising to $1.4M.
The grant decision: Staff presented four options for the $9.1M Student Support and Professional Development Discretionary Block Grant. Administration recommended option 2: using the grant to offset one-time employee payments. Trustees Segal, Alison Kamhi, Chiu and Salcman each voiced support. There was no formal vote. The approach pays for a one-time obligation with one-time money, so it does not add to ongoing costs.
The outside review: Matt Phillips, Associate Vice President, School Services of California, set limits on his firm's work up front. "This is not a validation of the budget," he said. His findings, compared with the adopted budget:
- Property tax growth should be assumed at 4.5% to 4.75%, not 3.5%.
- Pension savings of about $2.1M.
- Health benefit growth near 7%.
- Utilities growth of 30%, not 64.6%.
- The district's special-education contribution is expected to rise.
Even so, Phillips projected unrestricted ending reserves of 18.2% this year, 7.3% in 2027-28 and negative 2.27% in 2028-29. "The sooner reductions are made, the more savings they will yield over a 3-year period," he said.
The other side: Public commenters pushed on long-term strategy:
- Stephen Davis pointed to steady enrollment loss and suggested consolidating schools.
- Virginia DeJesus-Roof urged a 10-year strategic plan.
- Vaibhav Vash asked for employee counts measured against declining enrollment and questioned the 2% salary growth assumption.
Labor's markers: Earlier in the meeting, Superintendent Glass described the district's approach to cuts. "We start at the top. We protect the classroom as much as we possibly can," he said. Meb Steiner, President, California School Employees Association, said classified staff make up 19% of personnel costs and that cutting them would leave work undone. PAEA said it will respond only to the three areas management opened for bargaining: compensation and benefits, class size, and working conditions.
The cut list: Staff presented 74 reduction options. Tiers 1 and 2 total $28.9M ongoing and $8.7M one-time. That leaves ongoing savings $4.1M short of the target.
- District office and operations carry 64.4% of the savings.
- Classroom instruction carries 7.2%.
- Staff must show added justification before recommending cuts that reach classrooms, eliminate programs or trigger layoffs.
Yu warned that "every bridge dollar used in '27-'28 must be cut or replaced in '28-'29." Public commenter Sam Howells Banerjee made three points:
- He questioned grouping custodians with the district office.
- He asked why Fund 14 money is not being used as one-time funds.
- He urged a single-step approach to cuts.
The available recording ends partway through the board's discussion of the cut list.
What's next: The first interim budget report is due to the county Dec. 15.
General Counsel Hired, Reporting Line Debated
Where things stand: The board approved an employment agreement for David Lee as district general counsel. The term runs Nov. 16, 2026, to June 30, 2027, at a prorated $170,338. Trustees amended the contract to hold his evaluation at five months instead of six. The vote was by voice; no tally was announced.
The other side: Public commenter John Craig urged keeping the general counsel reporting directly to the board, citing separation of powers. Board Vice President Chiu agreed that the board should get direct legal advice, pointing to past lawsuits.
Superintendent Glass said current policy makes general counsel an administrative position. Board President Dharap said an earlier arrangement proved impractical. "It didn't make any sense for the general counsel to report to the board," he said.
Why it matters: Reporting lines determine whose interests counsel protects and how attorney-client privilege applies.
What's next: Trustees plan a public study session before changing the policy.
Farewell to Dharap and Segal
The board marked the last meeting for Board President Shounak Dharap, who served eight years, and Trustee Shana Segal, who served four.
Superintendent Glass credited Dharap with leading the board through a superintendent transition and the Cubberley negotiations. Others who paid tribute:
- Former trustee Todd Collins
- Jessica Spicer of the Santa Clara County School Boards Association, who presented certificates
- Maura Oman, Executive Director, Youth Community Service
Chiu acknowledged significant past disagreements with the departing trustees. "Disagreement does not have to mean disrespect," she said.
Segal recounted gains in early literacy and the creation of Palo Alto Middle College. "Let us choose not to pop one another's balloons," she said.
Dharap urged optimism about board members-elect Linda Hennigan and Avery Wang. "I hope that the incoming board and Linda and Avery will do a better one than I did," he said.
Why it matters: The new board inherits the parcel tax campaign and the deepest cuts in years.
Parents Push Back on Classroom Screens
During open forum, parents pressed the board to limit screen use in classrooms.
- Ward Thomas said his son reads less and doubts his own answers because of Chromebook use. He urged blocking YouTube and making paper the default for reading.
- Lindsay Chan said YouTube and games get past the district's controls. She described more than five hours of after-school screen time and asked for Chromebook carts, opt-outs and fewer online assignments.
- Commenters praised Green Middle School for returning to Chromebook carts.
Lior Melamedov of Schools Beyond Screens Palo Alto said the group submitted a petition and a draft resolution but has no clear path to a board decision. He objected that the ad hoc committee route will produce only non-binding recommendations, and not until May 2027.
Other speakers raised separate issues. Stephen Davis criticized special-education life-skills programs. Nicole Chu Wong, Executive Director, Pathwise, asked that every eighth grader districtwide get the challenge-day experience.
Minor Items
- Teacher retention: 10 of 11 intern or emergency-permit special-education teachers hired since 2023-24 have stayed, up from one of 10 before the mentoring program.
- Separation incentive: The board waived its two-meeting rule and approved a voluntary one-time separation incentive for employees.
- HVAC upgrades: Up to $6.5M approved for Duveneck, Fair Meadow and Ohlone, so work can start over winter break.
- Hoover project: The change-order contingency rose from 5% to 10%.
- Closed session: Trustees approved an $8,500 settlement and denied two pupil-record appeals 4-1.
Looking Ahead
Staff previewed a proposal to raise design-services authority to $150,000 per project and roofing authority to $1.5M for summer work; it returns for action at a later meeting. The first interim budget report is due Dec. 15, and the parcel tax resolution is expected Jan. 19.