Locunity — where decisions happen.
Palo Alto Presses SFPUC on Drought Math as Child Care Reform Stalls

Palo Alto Presses SFPUC on Drought Math as Child Care Reform Stalls

City Council • Palo AltoNovember 16, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Palo Alto's leaders spent nearly two hours on Nov. 16, 2026, questioning whether San Francisco's water planning could leave local ratepayers with a multibillion-dollar bill they may not need. The joint study session with the Utilities Advisory Commission ended without a vote. Later that night, a push to make child care easier to permit was continued after a long fight over motions.


  • SFPUC's 8.5-year "design drought" scrutinized as council weighs limited leverage over San Francisco
  • Child care zoning memo continued unanimously after split over infant care, financing and process
  • 470 Olive Avenue rezoned 6-0 with a recorded daylight-plane covenant; Councilmember George Lu recused
  • Measure J supporters celebrate, ask for fast and transparent Cubberley spending

Water Fight: How Dry a Drought Should Palo Alto Pay For?

Why it matters: The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) plans for an 8.5-year "design drought." That assumption drives rationing projections and potential spending on alternative water supplies, which would be passed through to Palo Alto ratepayers.

The basics: A design drought is the worst-case dry period a water system plans to survive. The Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BASCA) represents wholesale customers that buy water from SFPUC. Council asked for this study session after its June vote on the Urban Water Management Plan.

Where things stand: Palo Alto has limited influence on its own. "Palo Alto only purchases about 4.5% of the regional water system water," said Lisa Belair, Assistant Director of Resource Management, Utilities Department.

BASCA CEO and General Manager Tom Smigel said he sent SFPUC a letter on Nov. 12 asking it to review the drought's severity and length. He acknowledged the limits of that request. "We don't have official authority under the contract to say you must do this," Smigel said.

Peter Dreckmeyer, Policy Director, Yosemite Rivers Alliance, called the design drought an outlier. He said no comparable drought appeared in 25,000 model runs, and he argued that $17 billion to $25 billion in alternative supply costs are unnecessary. He also called one proposed study "just a delay tactic."

The rate math: Dreckmeyer warned of a fixed-cost "death spiral," in which fixed costs are spread over shrinking water sales. Utilities Advisory Commission Vice Chair Phillips said rising SFPUC costs and declining use could mean double-digit local rate increases. "That means we've got the numerator increasing, the denominator decreasing," Phillips said.

"I see real critical problems with the BASCA demand projection," said Commissioner Croft. Chair Mauter said the system is more sensitive to demand than to future climate changes. Councilmember Patrick Burt questioned the population growth assumptions behind BASCA's model.

The other side: Not everyone trusted BASCA to carry Palo Alto's case. "Why did the letter come out now and not months ago?" asked Commissioner Tooker. "I felt that I had the authority to write the letter in response to the request," Smigel answered.

Public commenter Dave Warner called the letter biased and said it omits favorable climate data, though he defended Smigel personally. Councilmember Julie Lythcott-Haims asked whether Palo Alto's needs are "getting met by membership in BASCA." Staff pointed to savings from debt refinancing, annual audits and regional coordination. Smigel said BASCA can "raise a ruckus" but has no veto.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No vote was taken. Vice Mayor Greer Stone, who represents Palo Alto on the BASCA board, said "we are at the mercy of the SFPUC" and favored a wait-and-see approach to San Francisco's response. Mayor Vicki Veenker agreed: "I would at least like to see that given a chance before we would kind of go off on our own."

Others floated escalation options:
- Councilmember Ed Lauing suggested bringing in state legislators. "Monopolies have been dealt with before," he said.
- Commissioner Gupta urged outreach to the other member agencies.
- Councilmember Keith Reckdahl asked about independent analysis. Smigel said BASCA lacks the expertise and budget for it and worries about consultant bias.

Mark Shahinian of the Sierra Club said SFPUC and BASCA overproject demand. Ratepayers, river advocates and Palo Alto's utility budget all have a stake in the outcome.

What's next: The council will wait for SFPUC's response to the BASCA letter. No date was set.


Child Care Push Hits Pause

Why it matters: A county survey cited 817 unfilled infant spaces. Council agreed the shortage is real but split on whether zoning is what's holding supply back.

Where things stand: Councilmember George Lu's colleagues memo would let child care centers open and expand by right, which means without discretionary approval. It would also cut parking minimums, extend incentives and align city rules with state law on family home daycares. "We do have a real shortage of childcare, especially infant spaces," Lu said.

Vice Mayor Stone cited a Human Relations Commission (HRC) audit finding that "access to affordable childcare is a gender equity issue."

Public comment: Supporters included:
- Melanie Fore of Upwards, who said permitting, fees and space limits deter home providers.
- Steve Levy, a League of Women Voters board member, who said the league's board unanimously supports drafting an ordinance.
- Parents Yuri D. and Scott O.

Lee P. of Palo Alto Community Childcare (PAC) described closing an infant center that a conditional use permit (CUP) limited to 12 children. PAC recommended a task force and an updated child care master plan. "It's not the solution to our bigger problems," Lee P. said of the memo.

The other side: "I'm not sure if what we have in the memo right now pulls the right levers to make an impact," said Reckdahl, who called financing the main barrier. Lauing said council "probably needed a bit more data on true demand." Burt opposed eliminating CUPs for larger centers in single-family (R-1) zones without more study. "I would be very hesitant to do that," he said. Lythcott-Haims favored continuing to back PAC's center-based model over promoting in-home care.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Burt moved to continue the item until council can review the HRC report, and Reckdahl seconded. Lu offered a substitute motion to refer the work to the Planning and Transportation Commission and the HRC. He later narrowed it, then withdrew it after colleagues said PAC's expertise was not integrated. "A fast decision isn't good unless it's a good decision," Reckdahl said.

City Manager Ed Shikada suggested the authors "come back with a slightly tighter recommendation." The continuance carried unanimously; the numeric tally was not stated. Providers and families will wait longer for parking, fee and permitting relief.

What's next: The item returns at the earliest opportunity, possibly in 2027.


470 Olive Rezoning Clears With Neighbor Protections

Where things stand: Continued from Sept. 9, the rezoning of 470 Olive Avenue from R-1 to NVMXM returned with a new condition. The applicant must "record a restrictive covenant prior to issuance of a building permit," said Emily Callas, Senior Planner.

The basics: A daylight plane is an angled limit on building height near property lines, intended to protect neighbors' light. The covenant keeps a 16-foot, 45-degree daylight plane and bars waivers of it.

Elaine Breeze, Senior Vice President of Development, Summer Hill Apartment Communities, said the applicant worked with staff on the covenant language. "I would first just like to really commend the applicants for their willingness to enter into the restrictive covenant," said Burt, who moved the staff recommendation.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The site joins the city's housing inventory, and adjacent single-family neighbors gain binding protection against density-bonus waivers. Vote: For: 6, Against: 0, Recused: 1 (Lu, due to proximity).


Measure J Backers Celebrate, Ask for Accountability

Speakers at public comment thanked council, staff and volunteers for passing Measure J for the Cubberley Community Center.

  • Giovanna Sardelli, artistic director of TheaterWorks Silicon Valley, said the company is eager for a new home at a revitalized Cubberley.
  • Jennifer D. relayed voter concerns about slow progress and diverted funds, and she floated a fiscal oversight committee.
  • Ken Horowitz thanked Lythcott-Haims for keeping Cubberley on the agenda.

Lythcott-Haims described narrow polling and the roughly 4% of undecided voters the campaign had to win. "You got Cubberley over the line," she told supporters. Mayor Veenker said much work lies ahead.


Minor Items

  • Executive pay: Council unanimously set base salaries of $448,593 for the city manager, $391,414 for the city attorney and $230,838 for the city clerk. There was no public comment.
  • Consent calendar: Items 2 through 9, including a Foothills park improvement ordinance, were approved; the tally was not stated.
  • Flock cameras: Matt Schlegel of the Safety Over Surveillance Coalition urged council to agendize covering the city's license plate cameras.
  • Climate diplomacy: Veenker said Palo Alto's EV and heat pump data resonated at the UN climate conference in Antalya, Turkey. "There is no doubt in my mind that this city is a global climate leader," she said.
  • Small business: Menlo College student Jonathan Moxie asked staff to evaluate a pilot offering longer leases and relocation help.

Looking Ahead

The Baylands Preserve access road closes Nov. 23–27 for king tides. The deferred closed session is expected Nov. 30. Coming agendas include the 450 Lytton Avenue hearing, follow-up on the accessory dwelling unit ordinance and an audit of the city's automated license plate reader (Flock) cameras, which is listed for December.

Palo Alto Presses SFPUC on Drought Math as Child Care Reform Stalls | City Council | Locunity