Locunity — where decisions happen.
Planning Commission OKs Smaller Delivery Station, Trading Tax Revenue for Fewer Trucks

Planning Commission OKs Smaller Delivery Station, Trading Tax Revenue for Fewer Trucks

Planning Commission • Palm SpringsOctober 27, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

The Palm Springs Planning Commission voted 5-0 on Oct. 27, 2026, to approve a 174,891-square-foot last-mile delivery station north of Interstate 10. It replaces a 739,360-square-foot fulfillment center the city approved in 2024. The new project cuts daily line-haul trucks from 280 to 34, but staff said it brings no local sales tax and far fewer jobs than the plan it replaces.


  • Delivery station approved 5-0 on 38 acres at 19th Avenue and North Indian Canyon Drive
  • Line-haul trucks drop from 280 to 34 a day, with setbacks of 500-plus feet
  • Projected sales tax falls from up to $1.5M a year to zero, staff said
  • 2024 environmental impact report stands under an addendum, despite lingering traffic impacts
  • Three union representatives backed the project, and no one spoke against it

A Smaller Box at the Northern Gateway

The basics: PS Canyon Development, LLC sought a CEQA addendum and a major development permit for 63700 19th Street. The site sits in the M-2 industrial zone, where warehouses are allowed by right.

Why it matters: The property already held entitlements for a far larger fulfillment center. The City Council upheld that 2024 approval on appeal in January 2025. The new plan shrinks the building by more than three-quarters and sharply reduces heavy-truck traffic at the city's northern entrance.

Where things stand: Under the revised plan, a 174,891-square-foot delivery station would be paired with a roughly 5,000-square-foot fleet service building and an inspection building. Height is capped at 45 feet. The building would sit more than 500 feet back from Indian Canyon and nearly 400 feet from 19th Avenue.

Staff projected 34 line-haul trucks a day, plus 64 vans leaving every 15 minutes during non-peak hours. The station would employ 160 workers per shift and provide 921 parking spaces, including 153 electric van charging spaces. City code requires 233 spaces.

"In the previous approval, there were 280 trucks per day. So there's a significant reduction," said Principal Planner Glenn Malakar.

The applicant promised LEED Silver design, four-hour battery storage, low-carbon concrete and a sewer line extension to the Mission Springs Water District plant. Michael Lozano, design-build developer representative for North Point Development, said EV charging would exceed settlement requirements: "We're actually going up to 185, and they'll be Level 2 and Level 3." Commissioners also asked about interior layout, break areas, food access, plan check status and construction timing.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Chair Kathy Weremiuk moved approval, and Commissioner Scott Miller seconded. The motion passed (For: 5, Weremiuk, Vice Chair Lauri Aylaian, Miller, David Murphy, John Morrill; Against: 0; Absent: 2, Robert Rotman, Carl Baker). Residents along the I-10 corridor gain fewer heavy trucks. "Quite a few less long-haul trucks on the 10 Freeway. That will be appreciated," said Commissioner David Murphy.

What's next: The design goes to the Architectural Review Committee, which has the final word on design. Weremiuk raised concerns about wind exposure at the open van canopy and about tree well size. The applicant described breeze block and a 100-mph wind design. Luke, the landscape architect with HKS, said the tree wells measure 4 feet by 4 feet inside and that "based on the plants that we have specified, they're desert plants." Staff said the city cannot dictate where plants are grown. Miller and Aylaian asked the committee to push for more building articulation, show the windbreak detail and favor muted colors.


The Fiscal Trade-Off: No Sales Tax, Fewer Jobs

Why it matters: The 2024 approval was weighed partly against projected local revenue. Most of that revenue is now gone.

Where things stand: Commissioner Murphy asked for "a description of the economic benefits outside of the development fees." The applicant estimated 243 permanent jobs, which it called a conservative figure. It also projected fewer construction jobs and lower permit fees.

Planning Director Christopher Hadwin described the revenue gap. He said the 2024 project "assumed that operationally local sales tax revenue annually could be up to $1.5 million. And of course, in this project, we are now showing none." He said assumed property tax falls from $153,000 a year to $100,000.

Hadwin cautioned that the earlier figures were estimates the city could not verify. He added that they were not part of the statement of overriding considerations. Lozano confirmed the structural reason: "So this type of project doesn't have sales tax. It's only for the construction there's sales tax."

The other side: Weremiuk objected that the economic comparison was not provided in advance. "Those actually would have been helpful to have in our packets so that we could be better prepared for this meeting, as I think they matter to the city," she said. "That's a significant difference in terms of the economic impact that we were told about when we did the original."

Vice Chair Aylaian noted that induced economic impact drops to about 20% of the earlier proposal. Permanent jobs drop to 30%.

Miller pushed back: "We're taking a desert site which has absolutely no economic benefit, and we're putting in a last-mile delivery station that is going to serve the surrounding community."

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Weremiuk asked the applicant to commit to buying construction materials locally and to put that in writing. The applicant agreed to use best efforts, and the commitment was noted in the motion, along with best efforts on local plants. Aylaian voted yes, "recognizing that the financial implications are not favorable, but I think that this will better serve and better blend into the community." The city's general fund loses projected revenue. Neighbors gain a smaller, less truck-intensive neighbor.


Old EIR, New Project: Environmental Review Holds

The basics: A CEQA addendum updates an existing environmental impact report when a revised project causes no new or worse significant impacts. A statement of overriding considerations is the finding that a project's benefits outweigh impacts that cannot be avoided.

Where things stand: Nicole Christ, the city's CEQA consultant with Terra Nova Planning, said transportation impacts are measured by vehicle miles traveled, or VMT, rather than intersection level of service. She said "projects such as this one that still have long-haul trucks do not meet VMT, vehicle miles traveled, standards." The shortfall is smaller than in the original analysis.

Air quality and greenhouse gas impacts fall with fewer trucks, based on CalEEMod modeling and South Coast Air Quality Management District thresholds. Christ concluded that "the Commission can rely on the previously adopted statement of findings and statement of overriding consideration."

Planned improvements at three intersections move from EIR mitigation into conditions of approval. Those intersections are Indian Canyon at 19th, Indian Canyon at Garnet, and the eastbound I-10 ramps at Garnet. Malakar confirmed a Mission Springs Water District letter on water and sewer service. Christ said the project will connect to the sewer plant, so no septic systems will be used.

The other side: Aylaian did not want the commission to appear to approve the overriding considerations itself. Commissioners agreed to revise finding 11 to reference the "previously adopted" statement. They also clarified in finding 10 that the EIR, not the addendum, was prepared in 2024.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The commission accepted the applicant's revisions to Planning conditions 8, 9, 10 and 15. Condition 8 now references settlement agreements, as amended Sept. 19, 2026, whose parties include the Sierra Club. Condition 15 was imposed by the City Council. It requires a report in about five years on whether environmental impacts have worsened. Asked whether the commission could modify a council condition, the city attorney said: "I do not have significant concerns about modifying the language, given that it does implement what you understand the city council to have desired." The attorney suggested flagging the change if the item returns to the council.


Building Trades Fill the Public Comment Line

Why it matters: Organized labor provided the only public testimony on the project.

Where things stand: Juan Serrato of Labor International Union North America cited private investment and good union jobs. He praised the developer's commitment to union labor.

Mario Gamboa, business agent for LIUNA Laborers Local 1184, spoke as a Palm Springs resident. He said his local has more than 1,000 members in the Coachella Valley, and he cited the site's location north of I-10.

Louie Lopez, business agent for Ironworkers Local 433, pointed to a 2021 community workforce agreement with the building trades. He asked the commission to approve the project.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The applicant also pledged to hire local and union labor. With fewer construction jobs than the 2024 plan, the trades' backing signals they still see meaningful work on the site.


  • Minutes approved: Oct. 13, 2026, minutes passed by roll call, with four yes votes recorded; Rotman and Baker were absent.
  • In-N-Out call-up: One council member called up the Architectural Review Committee's In-N-Out decision. Review is limited to architecture, design and landscape, and the hearing is likely Nov. 23 or in December. Hadwin said "any one member of the city council can call up any decision of any subsidiary body of the city council."
  • PA-1 appeal extended: An HOA appeal of the PA-1 planned development district amendment was pushed to Nov. 23 while the parties negotiate.

The commission holds its only November meeting on Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2026, with the Tramview Heights specific plan amendment on the agenda.

Planning Commission OKs Smaller Delivery Station, Trading Tax Revenue for Fewer Trucks | Planning Commission | Locunity