

Design Panel Approves Scaled-Down Delivery Hub, Demands Fixes to Facade, Trees
Architectural Review Committee • Palm SpringsNovember 20, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Palm Springs' Architectural Review Committee unanimously approved a 174,891-square-foot last-mile delivery station on 19th Avenue, much smaller than the 739,000-square-foot warehouse previously proposed for the same 38-acre site. Members attached a long list of design and landscape conditions, and those revisions will go to city staff for sign-off rather than back to the committee. Members spent much of the debate on one question: whether a building designed to code can still survive a site where, as one member put it, the wind blows "like a hurricane every day."
- Unanimous voice vote approves the Palm Springs Fulfillment Center with conditions on design and landscaping.
- The project shrinks from 739,000 square feet to 174,891, with 480 workers a day and 921 parking spaces.
- Members criticized the blue banding, nonfunctional windows and "eyebrow" canopies and ordered revisions for staff review.
- Wind-hardy tree substitutions and a maintenance requirement were added after Committee Member Charles Elliott pressed for changes.
- Full rooftop solar is tied to settlement agreements with the Sierra Club and other environmental groups.
A Smaller Warehouse, a Bigger Fleet Operation
The basics: The Architectural Review Committee, or ARC, advises on building design. It does not decide land use. This project's environmental review, a CEQA addendum to an earlier environmental impact report, had already been approved by the Planning Commission.
Why it matters: The 38-acre M-2 industrial site at North Indian Canyon Drive and 19th Avenue, at 63700 19th Avenue, will now hold a delivery hub instead of a megawarehouse. That changes the traffic pattern from trucks to vans and puts hundreds of workers' cars on a large, exposed parking lot.
Where things stand: The applicant, Palm Springs Canyon Development, LLC, proposes a 45-foot-tall main building plus a fleet service building and an inspection building. Setbacks are far greater than in the version the ARC reviewed in 2025. Loading docks with 34 truck spaces sit only on the north side, with van canopies on the east and west. Under the plan, 64 vans would depart every 15 minutes.
The site would employ 160 workers per shift, up to 480 a day. It would have 921 parking spaces, 153 of them with EV charging. Michael Lozano of North Point presented for the applicant team. He described LEED Silver design, low-carbon concrete and a sewer extension to the Mission Springs Water District.
Staff recommended approval, saying the project meets code standards. Staff and the applicant also noted that permits are already in plan check and that design changes could put those permits at risk.
The parking question: Staff and the applicant said the parking count covers about 200 permanent employees plus van drivers, who park their personal vehicles before taking vans out. One member warned the heat island effect would be "unbelievable" and noted the north side lacks a windbreak. Vice Chair John Walsh asked about shade structures. He acknowledged their cost but argued that common sense should go beyond code. The applicant said no shade structures had been proposed and that landscaping exceeds the city's shading requirement by 10%. Walsh conceded that tree shade will take years to arrive.
Solar by settlement: Asked whether solar was a permit condition, Glenn Mlaker, Principal Planner, said solar requires a separate permit. However, conditions of approval require the project to follow third-party agreements that mandate rooftop solar. Those agreements came out of an appeal and lawsuit. "There were a series of settlement agreements that were done with the Sierra Club and some other environmental groups," said Mlaker.
Staff said the agreements are not public and would be enforced at final inspection. A separate condition imposed by the City Council requires studies within five years or after operations begin. The applicant pledged 100% rooftop solar with four hours of battery storage, double the two-hour requirement.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Walsh moved approval with conditions. The motion passed by a voice vote declared unanimous, with Chair O'Donnell absent. No numeric tally was stated, and the seconder was not identified. Nearby residents get a smaller footprint and more distance from the building. Workers face a large parking field whose shade depends on young trees. Environmental groups' leverage over the project runs through private agreements rather than the public record.
Fake Windows and Arbitrary Canopies Draw Fire
Why it matters: These conditions will shape how a very large industrial building looks along 19th Avenue for decades. Members acknowledged their limited power to enforce them. "All we have as a tool is our words," said Walsh.
Where things stand: Architect Steve Bain of HKS led the design presentation. The applicant said the color banding, breeze block and canopies were added after the Planning Commission asked for more articulation, meaning variation in the facade. The blue is the tenant's corporate color.
Members found much of it unconvincing. Under questioning, the team confirmed the upper glazing does not function as actual windows. Members also asked what the punched-metal "eyebrow" canopies actually shade.
"I either don't have them at all or have some function to those," said Committee Member Danny Castro, referring to the windows. Another member called the placement of breeze block and windows arbitrary.
Walsh set the tone for the conditions. "On the balance, I'm happy to deal with a building that risks looking boring to something that has elements integrated to it that sort of don't carry a logic to them," said Walsh.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The approval requires:
- removing the nonfunctional glazing
- exploring other paint applications and an even parapet, subject to staff approval
- lowering and extending the south-side canopies to roughly 7 feet 6 inches of clearance and 4 feet 6 inches of projection
- integrating more breeze block
- studying how to visually tie the fleet building to the main building, which members viewed as an outlier
The other side: Not everyone was comfortable sending so much to staff. "I'm always worried when we give so many comments without the opportunity to review," said Elliott, who warned that open-ended direction could go sideways.
What's next: Revisions go to city staff, not back to the ARC. Because the permits are already in plan check, the applicant has a strong incentive to keep changes minimal.
Elliott's Push: Trees That Can Survive the Wind
Why it matters: Plants on this site face constant wind, heat and drought. Whether they survive determines whether the parking lot is ever shaded. "It's windy. Let's underscore how windy it is. It's like a hurricane every day," said Elliott.
Where things stand: Elliott, working with the applicant's landscape architect from Kimley-Horne, said Tipuana tipu and holly oak do not belong on the site. He recommended Aleppo and Afghan pines as windbreaks, along with Ulmus parvifolia, Prosopis, Pistache, Quercus virginiana, milkweed and Baccharis. He doubted that hydroseeding, a sprayed seed mix planned for the stormwater basins, would take hold, and he asked whether a nearby hydroseed example had worked. He also recommended quarterly maintenance.
Elliott wanted enforceable upkeep, including staking and guying trees so wind doesn't topple them. "I really think there needs to be something in place as an overlay for this district," said Elliott.
Staff pointed to the mitigation monitoring program, which the applicant pays for. "Yes, you can add a condition that when we do a final inspection that those things are in," said Mlaker. The applicant committed to sourcing plants locally and offering a 90-day warranty.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The approved motion includes a landscape maintenance obligation with prompt review after installation. It also adopts Elliott's substitutions: pines and Ulmus parvifolia in, Raywood ash, holly oak and Tipuana out. The applicant must also explore an alternative to hydroseed in the basins. The 90-day warranty is short compared with the years Walsh said shade will take to grow.
What's next: Compliance will be checked at final inspection. Elliott's broader idea of a districtwide maintenance overlay was not acted on.
- Consent calendar: Two Hillside Lot items approved unanimously by voice vote without discussion.
- Agenda corrections: The resolution's wrong date and duplicate "item B" labels were fixed before adoption.
- ARC appointments: Staff said interviews with ARC applicants are being scheduled.
- Design kudos: Members praised the College of the Desert building during reports.
Looking ahead: The fulfillment center's facade and landscape revisions now rest with planning staff, and the solar commitments will be checked at final inspection under agreements the public cannot see.