

Habitat Lapses Stall Hillside Home as Commission Delays Lot 4 Indefinitely
Planning Commission • PacificaNovember 16, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Pacifica's Planning Commission on Nov. 16, 2026, declined to approve a 4,258-square-foot home on a ridgeline lot. Neighbors and a biologist said the surrounding Harmony at One preserve is overrun with invasive pampas grass and has fallen out of compliance with its 2007 environmental commitments. Commissioners unanimously continued the hearing to a date uncertain, leaving staff and the City Attorney's Office to determine how much of a subdivision-wide problem the city can legally pin on one lot.
- Lot 4 hearing continued indefinitely after a roughly 95-minute debate over habitat compliance
- Four public commenters cited pampas grass, an unrestored gully and ridgeline visibility
- Staff said only site-specific mitigation measures clearly bind the Lot 4 owner
- Commissioners requested new visuals from Linda Mar, Highway 1 and Fassler
- Three-member ad hoc committee formed by unanimous voice vote
A Single Lot Becomes a Test for 2007 Promises
The basics: Lot 4 is a vacant 1.36-acre parcel on Ohlone Drive in the 67-acre Harmony at One subdivision. It is zoned planned development with a Hillside Preservation District overlay. The project's environmental impact report was approved in 2007 and carries a Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program, or MMRP. The MMRP is the checklist of environmental conditions a project must meet over time.
Why it matters: How the city resolves the issue could set the terms for the subdivision's remaining undeveloped lots. It will also signal whether 20-year-old environmental commitments can be enforced one building permit at a time.
Where things stand: Senior Planner James Lynn recommended approving File 2024-032, which includes Specific Plan SP-189-24 and Tree Permit TP-15-26. The plan calls for a two-story home with a 648-square-foot three-car garage and two guest parking spaces. About 12,500 square feet would be disturbed, against roughly 17,900 allowed on a lot with an 18% average slope. Staff found the project below hillside limits for coverage, floor area and height. Staff also recommended revising Condition of Approval 14(H) to include the full text of Mitigation Measure Bio 9.
Javier Chavarria, the applicants' engineer and agent with JC Engineering, described the project's key features:
- A LEED Gold-equivalent design scoring 65 points
- A 26.5-foot height and 7.5% lot coverage
- About 1,400 cubic yards of grading, with about 1,300 exported by small trucks in phases
"Everything within that envelope accounts to 12,487 square feet, which is substantially less than the 17,900 allowed," said Chavarria.
The other side: Patrick Coburn, a consulting biologist, urged the commission to halt further lots. He said the habitat management plan, conservation easement, HOA covenants and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service biological opinion are not being met. He cited pervasive pampas grass, an unrestored 2.25-acre gully, fire hazard and inadequate funding. Dinah Verbi, who helped negotiate the original conditions of approval, urged a continuance until the preserve is restored. She also questioned whether the commission can waive conditions such as berming, the home's footprint or LEED Gold. Peter Loeb backed a continuance so staff could review the noncompliance documents residents had submitted.
Commissioners largely agreed. Commissioner Briggs cited Biological Mitigation Measure 6, which requires quarterly invasive species removal in graded areas and adjacent open space. He said an MMRP callout would be needed for his approval. "I believe it has to happen now," said Briggs. He also read from a 2009 habitat management plan stating that funding would come from annual assessments of lot owners, collected by the HOA. Commissioner Marjory Davis cited the loss of habitat for protected species.
Chavarria said the owner should not answer for obligations owed by the HOA or land trust. "So we cannot make this one lot owner responsible for the entire subdivision issues," he said.
The legal line: "The MMRP lives on for the life of the project," said a representative of the City Attorney's Office. Staff, however, drew a distinction between measures that apply to Lot 4 itself and broader measures, such as open space upkeep, that fall to the HOA or trust. "For this particular lot, we don't have the authority to apply those MMRPs onto this lot," said Samantha Updegrave, Staff Liaison. Staff committed to researching responsible parties, the covenants and enforcement tools.
Commissioner Fischer offered a middle path. "I'm going to offer some constructive path forward for the applicant in that they work with the city and the HOA to develop a corrective action plan," said Fischer. Commissioner Chris Redfield asked whether HOA matters are a civil issue or a city responsibility. "I think it's a great project," he said.
Ridgeline Visibility Returns as a Flashpoint
Why it matters: The 2007 approval hinged on how visible homes would be from the coast. Commissioners said a neighboring home built since then proved more visible than an earlier commission expected.
Where things stand: Rich Campbell, a planning commissioner in 2007, said visual impacts were the central controversy that year. He urged the commission to require robust visuals from multiple vantage points so it is not left guessing. Loeb said modern tools make such renderings easy to produce.
Chavarria said the home's peak would sit about 10 feet below a nearby reference tree and that three sides would have 7-foot retaining walls. He acknowledged that no view from below or from Fassler Avenue had been prepared. He said a berm would disturb nearly half the lot. "What we can do is we can work with the staff during the preparation of the final grading plan," he said, offering to attempt a berm.
Davis pushed back on treating the berm and footprint requirements as optional. "I think those requirements were included for a reason," she said. She later added: "Nobody said you had to dig a hole and hide the house."
Vice Chair Lauren Berman pointed to the existing Lot 3 home. "So I think it's really important that we do see a visual from any applicable angle," she said. She also signaled opposition to the design itself: "I honestly don't agree with having a 2-story development."
The authority question: "Do we even have a say on what the visual looks like?" asked Fischer. Staff pointed to the design guidelines in the subdivision's covenants and to review by its architectural control board.
Continued, With No Return Date
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Davis moved to continue the item to a date uncertain, and Briggs seconded. The motion passed unanimously on a voice vote, with no individual tally announced. "I don't believe that a date certain is feasible with the question," said Updegrave.
The applicant, who has worked on the project for more than two years, now faces an open-ended delay. Residents and conservation advocates won a pause and a formal review of preserve conditions. The HOA and land trust face new scrutiny over whether funding and invasive species removal have kept pace with their obligations.
What's next: Staff will return with the following information:
- MMRP responsibilities and enforcement options
- HOA membership details
- Land trust reports, at Fischer's request
- A biological review of the habitat management plan and annual reports, at Briggs' request
- Visuals from uphill of Linda Mar, Highway 1 near Rockaway Brewery and Fassler Avenue, including the garage, at Davis' request
Briggs noted that some MMRP requirements appear to sunset six years after work is completed. "Some of the requirements of the MMRPs have expired," he said.
Minor Items
- Ad hoc committee formed: Vice Chair Berman, Chair Hauser and Commissioner Davis were named by unanimous voice vote. Berman moved and Fischer seconded. The working group will gather input, with at least one more joint study session before City Council.
- King tide warning: Redfield said king tides are expected Nov. 22–26. Sandbags are available at Station 72 on Linda Mar.
- Housing law briefing: Berman and Redfield attended a 21 Elements presentation on new affordable housing laws and objective design criteria.
- Staff updates: Terry Aiello joined as the commission's new administrative assistant. Davis asked that disturbed-area tables appear in the body of future staff reports.
Looking ahead: Staff has no items scheduled for December and expects to cancel both December meetings, with the commission likely returning in mid-January.