Pacifica's Pier Faces $64M Repair Bill as Council Races to Stabilize Before Winter

The Pacifica City Council unanimously renewed its emergency declaration for the battered municipal pier June 22, learning that the damage estimate has ballooned to approximately $64 million — more than triple a pre-existing $20 million repair need identified after 2023 storms. With a Super El Niño forecast and storm season approaching, the city is pressing Sacramento and San Mateo County for emergency aid while crews work to shore up the crumbling abutment with nearly a million pounds of boulders.

• $64M pier damage estimate submitted to the state, including $3M in emergency repairs and $60M+ to restore the structure
• 900,000 pounds of boulders placed around the pier abutment over 10 days to slow further deterioration
• City seeks governor's emergency proclamation after county executive declared emergency June 18
• Resident calls for managed coastal retreat, arguing the pier destruction proves Pacifica must stop fighting the ocean
• July 4th crackdown launched with highway message boards, $1,000 fines, and community outreach to deter illegal fireworks

---

$64 Million and Counting: Pier Emergency Deepens

Why it matters: The Pacifica Municipal Pier — a beloved civic landmark — now carries a repair price tag that dwarfs the city's capacity to pay alone. Securing state and federal disaster assistance is critical, and the clock is ticking before the next round of winter storms.

Where things stand: City Manager Kevin Woodhouse told the council that crews have spent the past 10 days placing approximately 300 large boulders — roughly 900,000 pounds — around the damaged pier abutment to temporarily stabilize it.

"We submitted an initial damage estimate, or IDE, for approximately $64 million, which includes about $3 million in emergency repairs and then another $60-plus million to bring the pier back to its original uses," said City Manager Woodhouse.

The $60 million figure builds on a pre-existing 2023 repair estimate of roughly $20 million and adds costs for reconnecting the pier to shore, replacing the abutment, and accounting for the destroyed restrooms and Chit Chat Café structure — though City Manager Woodhouse confirmed those facilities are not expected to be rebuilt on the pier. "We don't envision any scenario where those would be replaced back on the pier, but they were destroyed and we are seeking damages for those," he said.

The city's engineering firm, GHD, and several maritime contractors are evaluating options to brace the first span from below with new piles, but constructability challenges remain due to severe tidal conditions and distance from shore.

State and County Aid in Motion

Mayor Christine Boles and City Manager Woodhouse visited the governor's office in Sacramento the previous week to advocate for a state emergency proclamation and financial assistance. On the county level, San Mateo County Executive Mike Callagy proclaimed a county emergency on June 18, with the Board of Supervisors set to ratify it June 23.

Mayor Boles flagged a complication with the boulder work: "The rocks that were put in front of the abutment were taken away from the seawall," she noted — meaning the city now faces additional work to replace those stones before storm season.

Deputy Director of Public Works Roland Yip confirmed the boulders range up to three to four tons. "The larger stone that are 3 ton plus are pretty sufficient. They hold pretty well," said Deputy Director Yip, though he acknowledged some movement among smaller stones in heavy surf.

Beach Boulevard and Public Communication

Vice Mayor Greg Wright asked whether staff could consider opening a separated section of sidewalk for pedestrian access along Beach Boulevard. City Manager Woodhouse said the city needs to preserve construction access and staging. "We're still looking at options to brace the first span, and we would like to preserve all access for potential construction equipment and staging until we figure out that next stage," he said.

Councilmember Sue Beckmeyer pressed for better public outreach about pier developments: "I would much rather have the community understand how the information is going to get out to them and that when there is going to be a critical meeting about the pier, they will definitely know." City Manager Woodhouse committed to updating the pier webpage and using the City Manager's Connect newsletter for regular updates.

Community Weighs In

Three public commenters spoke during the pier discussion. Ron Michael suggested the city install informational kiosks and spotting scopes — similar to those on the Devil's Slide Trail — and called attention to marine life on approximately 50 pier columns, including mussels, barnacles, starfish, and crabs.

Kimberly Finale raised alarm about sections of the pier that appear ready to collapse and cited Super El Niño predictions. "They're predicting 6 inches of temporary sea level rise to accompany that," she warned.

Cindy Abbott, a West Sharp Park resident, asked when sidewalks and portions of Beach Boulevard would reopen to pedestrians, acknowledging the need for construction equipment access but urging the city to communicate a timeline.

Decisions: The council voted unanimously (For: 5, Against: 0) to continue the local emergency declaration. Vice Mayor Wright moved; Councilmember Beckmeyer seconded.

What's next: The engineering evaluation from GHD remains in progress. The city will continue pursuing a governor's emergency proclamation and state financial assistance while monitoring abutment stability ahead of winter.

---

'Mother Nature Wants Her Coastline Back': Resident Demands Managed Retreat

Why it matters: The pier collapse is sharpening a policy fault line in Pacifica — whether to keep investing in coastal infrastructure or begin pulling back from the shoreline. As repair costs mount, the managed retreat debate is likely to intensify.

During general public comment, Kimberly Finale delivered a pointed call for the city to stop resisting coastal erosion. "The emergency destruction of the Chit Chat Café — another example of what happens when an elected body, and therefore the city, refuses to plan ahead for the imminent future. Mother Nature called and she wants her coastline back," she said.

Finale argued the city has spent millions on studies and planning that can never be realized and urged the council to begin nature-based solutions by pulling infrastructure back from the shoreline. No council members responded directly to the remarks, consistent with Brown Act public comment protocols — but the tension between a $64 million repair bill and calls for strategic retreat frames a debate Pacifica will likely revisit as storms approach.

---

City Launches $1,000-Fine Campaign for July 4th Fireworks

Why it matters: With America's 250th anniversary expected to drive heavy celebrations, Pacifica is deploying its most comprehensive illegal fireworks prevention strategy yet.

City Manager Woodhouse outlined a plan that includes a lighted message board on State Route 1 warning that illegal fireworks carry a $1,000 administrative fine under the city's "Host the Show, Pay the Dough" social host ordinance. The campaign also features posters at the community center, library, and other public locations emphasizing distress to animals and veterans with PTSD, along with direct engagement with schools, HOAs, and neighborhood groups.

During public comment, Patrick Kavanaugh of the Pacific Beach Coalition announced July 5th beach cleanups at three sites from 8 to 10 a.m. "We'll be at three different sites to pick up all that garbage that people are blowing up into the sky to celebrate our country's 250th anniversary," he said. Kavanaugh also raised a question about whether Safe and Sane fireworks are legal through July 5 — which falls on a Sunday this year — potentially conflicting with cleanup timing. He noted 12 groups are participating in the Safe and Sane program.

---

Minor Items

• Consent calendar approved unanimously (For: 5, Against: 0), with Item 2 (pier emergency) pulled for a separate discussion. Moved by Councilmember Beckmeyer, seconded by Vice Mayor Wright.
• PG&E's Marjorie Ruiz introduced the free Reported app for non-emergency utility safety concerns — available on Android, Apple, and desktop — allowing residents to photograph and submit issues like suspicious poles or trees near power lines. She emphasized it is not a replacement for 911. Mayor Boles thanked PG&E for their responsiveness during the pier emergency.