Locunity — where decisions happen.
Oakland Hills Evacuation Gaps Exposed as Wildfire Report Heads to Council

Oakland Hills Evacuation Gaps Exposed as Wildfire Report Heads to Council

Public Safety Committee • OaklandNovember 18, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Oakland's fire department has cleared about 470 hazardous trees from hillside escape routes. In a special meeting on Nov. 17, 2026, staff told the Public Safety Committee the city cannot guarantee a fast evacuation of Skyline High School and keeps no list of homebound residents. The committee forwarded that report, along with reports on ShotSpotter and October's 911 blackout, to the full council on 4-0 votes.


  • Wildfire evacuation report advances 4-0 as staff concede gaps for students and bedbound seniors
  • 40% of surveyed hills residents had no specific evacuation route in mind
  • 69-minute 911 blackout traced to cut AT&T lines, with no timeline for hardening
  • ShotSpotter resolution heads to the Dec. 1 council consent calendar after split public comment
  • OPD reports 612 sworn officers, and a 197th Academy class that began with about 40 recruits graduated 15

Fire Lanes Cleared, but Who Gets Out?

Why it matters: Hills residents face wildfire risk with uneven knowledge of their escape routes. There is also no guaranteed plan for students or mobility-limited seniors.

Where things stand: Oakland Fire Department and Public Works removed roughly 470 hazardous dead and dying trees along evacuation corridors. The work was paid for with CAL FIRE and local grants and supported by goat grazing. "Each year, the fire department inspects roughly 26,000 public and private parcels," said Michael Hunt, Chief of Staff and Public Information Officer, Oakland Fire Department.

Routes were set using regional Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC) routes, UC Berkeley modeling and a community survey. That survey showed deep confusion among residents. "40% of our residents said they didn't have a specific evacuation route in mind," said Jessica File, Emergency Services Manager. Another 52% did not know their zone, and Oakland has more than 250 zones. Alerts go out through Genesis Protect, AC Alert, wireless emergency alerts and 25 sirens.

Councilmember Ramachandran, who is not on the committee, asked: "How do people know where they're supposed to go in the moment of a wildfire?" She named several congested roads. Hunt replied that "those are still evacuation routes." He said Public Works has an internal tree-work dashboard "which I believe we can turn on to become public."

Students and seniors: Councilmember Rowena Brown asked whether staff could share the plan to evacuate Skyline High School students. Hunt said the department has recommended using the football field with buses, adding protective measures on red-flag days and possibly closing the school. "We can't say that we're ready to evacuate everybody on a moment's notice," he said. File said the school district has a contract for 70 buses on standby. She added that SB 959, a state bill, may allow fire-ordered school closures.

Councilmember Ken Houston asked whether responders know "which seniors are ADA bedbound." File said the city keeps no 911 registry. Such lists go stale, she said, and the state ADA coordinator no longer recommends them, so she urged family and neighborhood plans. "But that's not good enough for me," Houston said. Hunt said OFD can access PG&E's medical baseline roster and has requested two wheelchair-capable vans. He noted the department has no helicopter.

The other side: Public commenters pushed for specifics:
- Kim Harmon, speaking for the Redwood Ridge Neighborhood Organization, said a city-owned Skyline parcel is rated priority one in the management plan but is not on the work list.
- Eileen Evans, a 1991 firestorm survivor, said that unmanaged gully sits across from her home and contributed to losing her homeowner's insurance.
- Cynthia Barbera asked for a funded, public, data-driven plan with quarterly objectives.
- David Boatwright asked for a vegetation removal map and help for disabled residents.
- Another speaker urged letters to Skyline High parents and a one-way descent plan for Keller Road.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The committee forwarded the report on a motion by Councilmember Charlene Wang, committee chair, seconded by Houston. For: 4 (Wang, Brown, Fife, Houston), Against: 0, Absent: 0. No timeline was set for the public dashboard or for expanded outreach.

What's next: The report goes to the Dec. 15, 2026, City Council consent calendar. Staff report


911 Went Dark for 69 Minutes

Why it matters: One cut line silenced Oakland's emergency number. The city cannot fix that weakness on its own.

Where things stand: "At exactly 8:37 PM, the outage began," said Tony Battala, Information Technology Director. He was describing Oct. 21, when fiber and copper lines were cut at the city's Edgewater 911 site. Staff believe it was theft, and a criminal investigation is open. Calls were rerouted to the Alameda County Sheriff at 9:46 p.m., and copper repairs finished the next morning.

About 60 callers "very likely received a busy signal," said Gina Chang, Police Communications Manager. Whether any of those calls involved major incidents is unknown.

Three fixes are on the table: hardening the site, adding wireless redundancy and moving lines off copper. All depend on AT&T, the city budget and state approval from Cal OES. "This is AT&T's infrastructure, and they were responsible for the restoration, which we coordinated," Battala said. He added that the city does not pay for 911 service directly because the state does.

The other side: Wang pressed on accountability. She urged staff to use "whatever way that we can play hardball with them instead of just requesting that." "I do want to see more of a concrete timeline in terms of what next steps are," she said.

Michelle Phillips of the City Administrator's Office urged caution. "There is still an open and ongoing criminal investigation," she said, and she noted possible litigation. "We cannot provide a good timeline at this moment," she added.

Brown floated wireless connectivity as a backup. Councilmember Carroll Fife said "this is not a victimless crime" and pledged to pursue state legislation. Houston said "we got to bring back law and order." One public commenter asked why AT&T began repairs hours after it was notified. Blair Beekman urged a public cybersecurity process for future upgrades.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: On the city attorney's advice, members dropped a request for a supplemental report. For: 4, Against: 0, Absent: 0. Residents remain exposed to a repeat outage until AT&T hardens its lines.

What's next: The report goes to the Dec. 1 council consent calendar.


Police Ranks: 612 and Holding

Why it matters: Sworn staffing is at a historic low. Academy washouts and long-term leave strain both police response and the budget.

Where things stand: "Our sworn field staffing is at 612," said Amber Fuller, Human Resources Manager, Oakland Police Department. OPD has 235.5 professional positions filled and loses six officers a month. The 197th Academy graduated 15 recruits, and 37 are now in the 198th.

Wang questioned that drop. "I'm just really trying to get at the heart of ensuring that our academies, which are not cheap, they're expensive, that are being used most effectively," she said. Deputy Director Kiona Suttle pointed to early resignations, minimum physical standards set by POST (the state's police training commission) and academic and driving failures. She also noted the department budgets for the resulting salary savings.

Sgt. Michael Roman, who supervises recruiting, said the share of recruits who live in Oakland rose about 10%. "We had over 70 people show up this time," he said, and 64 of them passed the test. Houston asked how OPD prepares trainees. Roman described weekly webinars and biweekly physical agility workshops.

Fife asked about the 71 officers on long-term leave. Staff said 25 officers are on transitional assignment and explained the disability retirement process. Staff also said eight lateral applicants meet minimum qualifications.

The other side: Boatwright calculated a 37% post-graduation retention rate and suggested hiring failed recruits for administrative jobs. Beekman said he is satisfied with low recruit numbers and urged a gradual shift to community policing.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The committee received and filed the report. For: 4, Against: 0, Absent: 0.


ShotSpotter's Future Goes to Council

Why it matters: The council will decide whether Oakland keeps gunshot detection under a policy that treats every alert as top priority.

Where things stand: The updated policy means "each ShotSpotter alert is a priority 1," said Lt. Gabriel Urquiza, who commands real-time operations in OPD's Ceasefire section. A new agreement (MOU) also gives Oakland Housing Authority police access to the system. Activations fell to about 4,600 in 2025, down from roughly 6,000 the year before. Urquiza cited uses in medical response, critical incidents and investigations, including a homicide case.

Fife asked whether other vendors "might have … better outcomes than this particular brand." Urquiza said the current contract extension runs to next September. "We are conducting that assessment, and we'll have that over the next year," he said. He added that radar-based alternatives would require more units at much higher cost. Wang asked how many alerts were triggered by negligent discharges of a firearm.

The other side: Public comment split.
- Dr. Rajni Mandal, a District 4 physician, called ShotSpotter an emergency-response tool.
- Kyle McCoy of Black Lives Matter, New Generation of Black Panthers supported the system and suggested sharing alert locations with security crews.
- Another supporter cited Chicago voters' 72% vote to bring the system back.
- Joshua Jackson opposed it, citing falling firearm incidents nationally, tripled Priority 1 response times and a study that found no significant effect on arrests or homicides.
- Beekman called it more troubling than license plate readers.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Brown noted that a resolution must go to the council. For: 4, Against: 0, Absent: 0.

What's next: The resolution is on the Dec. 1 council consent calendar.


Minor Items

  • Pending list approved 4-0: A speaker said the fire chief cannot use Measure NN funds for fire station exhaust ventilation.
  • Quorum shift: With Ramachandran present, members voted 4-0 to convene as a special council meeting.
  • Open forum: One speaker reported repeated break-ins and asked how residents can get help.
  • Open forum: Another speaker called copper theft organized and asked when the city will have a facility security contract.
  • Surveillance watch: Beekman urged Oakland to follow San Diego in dropping license plate readers and smart streetlights.

Looking ahead: The council takes up the ShotSpotter and 911 outage items on Dec. 1. The wildfire evacuation report follows on Dec. 15, 2026.