

Nutley Board Waives Garage Rebuild, Clears Addition Beside Regional Aqueduct
Zoning Board of Adjustment • NutleyOctober 23, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Nutley's Zoning Board of Adjustment approved an estate's request to leave a demolished garage unreplaced at 15 Edgar Place, so a pending home sale can move forward without new construction. The board also approved a two-story addition on Bloomfield Avenue, with conditions that protect a 74-inch regional water aqueduct running beneath the property. Both cases involved undersized or oddly shaped lots that could not meet standard zoning rules.
- Estate cleared to skip garage rebuild at 15 Edgar Place, citing a narrow 40-foot lot and ample driveway parking
- Two-story addition approved at 371 Bloomfield Avenue with an 11-foot-3-inch rear yard where 30 feet is required
- Aqueduct protections become binding conditions, including a 3-ton weight limit and a ban on storing materials over the pipe
Edgar Place Estate Wins Garage Relief
The basics: Nutley's R-1 residential zone requires two off-street parking spaces, with at least one in a garage. The zoning officer denied the estate's application under Section 700-9 because the property at 15 Edgar Place (Block 3301, Lot 6) no longer has a garage.
Why it matters: The decision lets an estate sell a home without building a garage that its lot can barely hold. It also shows how this board weighs hardship from small lots against off-street parking rules.
Where things stand: Daniel Cohen, counsel for the estate with Foxworth Tile LLP, and David J. Sprong, administrator of the Estate of Garrett R. Strong, presented the case. They said the garage was deemed unsafe in 2020 and demolished in early 2021.
The applicants said the lot measures about 40 by 100 feet. A garage that meets current code would need setbacks the lot cannot accommodate and would take up much of the backyard. They told the board the driveway holds two or more cars, that no complaints have arisen since the demolition, and that a sale contract is in attorney review.
"We believe it's appropriate to just leave the property the way that it's been for the last 6 or 7 years," said Sprong, Estate Administrator.
Board scrutiny: Board members asked about setbacks before acting. One member pointed to two factors in favor of approval: the hardship created by the undersized lot and the fact that the driveway already provides the two required spaces.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: A board member moved to let the applicant forgo rebuilding the garage, citing the undersized lot and the two retained parking spaces. The motion was seconded and approved on a roll call vote. The individual tally was not available.
- Estate and buyer: The sale can proceed without construction costs or delays.
- Neighbors: Off-street parking capacity stays the same as it has been since 2021.
- Future applicants: Owners of narrow R-1 lots now have a recent example of the board accepting open driveway parking in place of a garage space.
What's next: The board typically adopts a written resolution memorializing each approval at a later meeting, as it did this session for two earlier cases.
Bloomfield Avenue Addition Gets Aqueduct Guardrails
The basics: Applicant Ryan Hunter sought a variance under Section 700-46A for a two-story rear addition at 371 Bloomfield Avenue (Block 5603, Lot 17). The zoning officer's denial letter cited a required 30-foot rear yard. The plan proposes 11 feet 3 inches.
Why it matters: A 74-inch steel aqueduct operated by the North Jersey District Water Supply Commission runs through the area. It has no more than 3 feet of soil cover. A homeowner's project became a question of protecting regional water infrastructure.
Where things stand: Hunter described an irregular, triangular lot served by a shared 125-foot driveway. He said the addition would sit over an existing deck rather than expand onto new ground.
A board member read the commission's letter into the record. Its conditions include:
- A 3-ton surface weight limit over the aqueduct
- Copies of construction drawings and as-built plans submitted to the commission
- Access for commission inspections
- No storage of vehicles or materials on top of the pipe
"No construction vehicles, materials, etc., are going to be stored on top of the aqueduct," said a Board Member, reading the commission's terms.
Members recommended making the letter a formal condition of approval. They also urged contractors to request utility mark-outs through 811-type call-before-you-dig services before any excavation. Other questions covered siding, ownership of the shared driveway, and a pool fence.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: A board member moved to grant the variance. The motion was conditioned on the new roof and siding matching the existing house and on compliance with the water commission's letter. It was seconded and approved on a roll call vote, and the chair announced the variance was granted. The individual tally was not available.
- Homeowner: Can build despite the deep setback shortfall.
- Water commission: Gains enforceable protections over the aqueduct, including inspection access and plan review.
- Contractors: Face clear limits on equipment weight and where they can stage materials.
- Shared-driveway neighbors: Will see construction traffic along the 125-foot access.
What's next: The approval is expected to be memorialized in a resolution at a future meeting. The commission's plan-review and inspection conditions apply before and during construction.
Minor Items
- Secretary pay: The board approved $150 for the recording secretary.
- Resolutions adopted: The board approved resolutions for Stevens/Lane at 482 Kingsland Street and McCourt at 16 Whitford Avenue.
- Minutes: The board took up minutes from its Sept. 21, 2026, meeting. The outcome of that vote was not clearly announced.
Looking Ahead
The chair reviewed the board's proposed 2027 calendar, which moves several meetings off the usual third Monday to avoid holidays, including MLK Day. Rescheduled dates include Jan. 11, Feb. 8 and Dec. 13, 2027. The notice goes to the clerk for publication. Applicants planning 2027 filings should check the published schedule.