Locunity — where decisions happen.
Neighbor Objection Tests Second-Story Bid on Undersized Humbert Street Lot

Neighbor Objection Tests Second-Story Bid on Undersized Humbert Street Lot

Zoning Board of Adjustment • NutleyNovember 19, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Nutley's Zoning Board of Adjustment spent most of its session on whether a homeowner can build up on a lot less than half the size the code requires. A motion to grant the Humbert Street addition, with drainage and gas-meter safeguards, went to a roll call, but no result was announced. A High Street teardown-and-rebuild followed, and both cases showed the board pairing relief for undersized lots with stormwater conditions.


  • 33 Humbert Street second-story addition draws one objector and one supportive neighbor. A motion to grant with conditions went to a roll call, and no result was announced.
  • 354 High Street owner seeks six variances to replace a flood-damaged, mold-damaged house. Four "yes" votes were recorded, but no formal tally was given.
  • Stormwater conditions in both cases: applicants offered a rear recharge pit and a seepage pit to manage runoff.

Humbert Street: Building Up on 2,389 Square Feet

The basics: The applicant needs "C" variances, which are relief from bulk rules such as setbacks and lot size. A C-1 variance rests on a hardship unique to the property. A C-2 variance requires showing that the benefits outweigh the detriments.

Why it matters: The case tests how far the board will let owners stack a story on severely undersized lots with no side setback. Many older neighborhoods are built on lots like this one.

Where things stand: The property is in the R-2 district (Block 6703, Lot 15). The original denial cited a 0-foot side yard and a 5.6-foot front yard under Section 700-4. Matthew Evans, the applicant's architect and planner, testified that the lot is 2,389 square feet, compared with 5,000 required. It is 35 feet wide, compared with 50 required. Lot coverage would stay at 41.27%. The project adds new siding, a new roof, new windows and a new front entry.

"The home will remain a single-family, 3-bedroom residence," said Evans.

Jen Ting, attorney for the applicant, AGC Construction, argued hardship under C-1 and net benefits under C-2. "We are keeping within the current footprint, and we're not expanding the footprint," said Ting.

Board members pressed on windows, HVAC condensers, the gas meter, Bilco doors and construction access. On the zero-setback side, Evans said there would be "no gutters, no eaves." He said the leaders "could tie those into a recharge pit in the rear," and he agreed to make that a condition.

The other side: Sebastian Ilardi, a public commenter who owns the house next door at 27 Humbert Street, said he had no problem with the plan. "I just wanted to make sure it was going straight up," said Ilardi. He also noted a fence-line discrepancy unrelated to the construction.

Joseph Coviello, a public commenter, argued for denial. He said the lot falls below 80% thresholds and that a 0-foot side yard requires testimony on fire separation, drainage, privacy and shadowing. He called the C-2 case conclusory.

"The fact that an owner desires additional living area does not by itself establish an exceptional hardship unique to the property," said Coviello. "I honorably request that the board deny the application."

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: A board member moved to grant the application, citing the preexisting undersized lot. The motion carried two conditions. First, a safety device such as a bollard, approved by the building department, must protect the gas meter. Second, roof gutters and leaders must be pitched to the back into a recharge pit. Responses to the roll call were audible, including at least one "no," but no tally or result was announced. If granted, the owners get a second story without expanding the footprint, and the neighbors get runoff directed away from the shared property line.

What's next: Look for a resolution recording the outcome. The board adopts resolutions on prior applications at later meetings.


High Street: Rebuilding After the Flood

Why it matters: The plan would replace a vacant, mold-damaged house on a busy county road. Doing so requires trade-offs on driveway width, front-yard greenery and stormwater.

Where things stand: Owner and architect Joseph Haines seeks six variances to demolish the house at 354 High Street (Block 2503, Lot 38) in the R-1 district. He would build a two-story, four-bedroom home on the 40-by-110-foot lot. "I recently purchased 354 High Street," said Haines. He said the house flooded last winter and is beyond repair.

The denial cited five shortfalls against code:
- Lot area: 4,400 square feet, versus 5,000 required.
- Lot width: 40 feet, versus 50 required.
- Lot coverage: 37.6%, versus a 35% limit.
- Front-yard landscaping: 38%, versus 60% required.
- Driveway and curb cut: 18 feet, versus a 16-foot limit.

The design includes a basement garage, an open floor plan and Dutch colonial-inspired massing. Haines argued C-1 hardship for lot size and C-2 benefits for coverage, landscaping and the driveway. He cited safety on a busy street as a reason for the wider driveway.

Haines offered stormwater mitigation beyond what is required. "I'm going to go above and beyond on a storm and take as much water as I can from the roof and the driveway and put into a seepage pit under the driveway," said Haines. He said a large rear tree "needs to come down."

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No audience members remained to comment. A motion to grant was made and seconded by Board Chair Frank Graziano. Four members were recorded voting yes: Board Member Yvette C. Wallace, Board Member John Cafone, Board Member Daniel Tolve and Graziano. Other responses were not clearly audible, and no formal result was announced. If approved, the street would lose a vacant, damaged house and gain an occupied four-bedroom home. The trade-offs are a wider curb cut, less front-yard landscaping and the loss of a mature tree.

What's next: Watch for a memorializing resolution at a coming meeting.


Minor Items

  • Resolutions approved by voice vote for Ryan and Maria Hunter (371 Bloomfield Ave.) and the Estate of Garrett Sprong (15 Edgar Place).
  • Oct. 19 minutes approved by voice vote.
  • Recording secretary's $150 pay was moved, but no vote was captured.

Looking Ahead

The board's next meeting is Dec. 14, not the Dec. 21 date posted automatically on the town website. "We are meeting on the 14th, not the 21st," said Graziano. One application is expected.