

ShopRite's Franklin Avenue Liquor Store Plan Draws Traffic Questions, Hearing Continues
Planning Board • NutleyNovember 5, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Nutley's Planning Board spent its Nov. 5, 2026, session reviewing a plan to put a new liquor store beside the ShopRite on Franklin Avenue. The board took no vote. Instead, it continued the hearing so the applicant's remaining experts can return on the 18th, while traffic, stormwater and construction conditions take shape.
- New 5,000-square-foot liquor store proposed beside the Nutley ShopRite at 437 and 441 Franklin Avenue
- Inactive "pocket" liquor license would move into a new two-story detached building
- 10 Electrify America EV chargers included, with employee parking relocated
- Chair challenges traffic study projecting 84 weekday evening peak trips and unchanged congestion
- Applicant agrees to board engineer's conditions, including dry well study and construction phasing plan
ShopRite Makes Its Case for a Liquor Store
The basics: Vincom LLC is seeking preliminary and final site plan approval for 437 and 441 Franklin Avenue. A pocket license is a liquor license held without an operating premises. This plan would put that license to work in a new building.
Why it matters: The project would add a new retail use and 10 EV chargers. It would also reshape parking and pickup at one of Nutley's major grocery sites.
Where things stand: The applicant's attorney presented a full slate of witnesses: the company president, an architect, an engineer, a traffic expert and a planner.
The president of the family supermarket company described the competition the business faces. He said the store would use the pocket license. He also said police would be on hand during holiday peaks and that employee parking would be relocated to make room for the project.
The president said the building's second floor would be used for storage only. The board treated that commitment as a possible condition of approval, which would make it enforceable rather than a verbal promise.
The architect described a 64-by-83-foot, two-story building detached from the supermarket. A gap between the two structures is planned for structural reasons.
The other side: Board questioning focused on design. Board Chair Mark Arcuti pressed the applicant on screening, the canopy and why the building would stand apart from the existing store. Members also asked about deliveries.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Applicant planner Sal Corvino testified that the project improves the site's facade and does not harm the zone plan. That kind of testimony matters because a board weighing a site plan must consider whether the project fits the town's zoning goals.
The trade-offs are clear. Shoppers and EV drivers would gain a new store and charging access. Employees would park in a new location. Neighbors along Franklin Avenue would absorb whatever new activity the store generates.
What's next: No vote was taken. The hearing continues when the applicant's remaining experts return on the 18th.
Traffic Numbers Meet a Skeptical Chair
Why it matters: Franklin Avenue is a busy county road. The conditions now being negotiated will shape the board's final resolution and how the project affects drivers, pedestrians and neighbors.
Where things stand: Applicant traffic engineer Connor Hughes projected 84 new trips during the weekday evening peak and 56 during the Saturday peak.
Those figures include an 8% "internal capture" reduction. That adjustment assumes some trips will be shoppers already visiting the ShopRite who add a liquor store stop, rather than new cars on the road. Hughes reported that level of service would be unchanged. Level of service is the letter-grade measure engineers use to rate congestion at intersections.
The other side: The chair was not convinced the store would come without a traffic cost.
"It's definitely going to add more traffic," said Mark Arcuti, Board Chair.
That skepticism goes to the heart of the applicant's case. If the board doubts the study's assumptions, it may push for more mitigation or more detailed analysis before voting.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The applicant's counsel agreed to follow the board engineer's review letter. That commitment covers a series of conditions:
- Investigate a dry well, subject to soil testing. A dry well is an underground structure that lets stormwater soak into the ground.
- Provide a construction phasing plan.
- Add a curb cut and ramp.
- Add landscaping.
- Install timed lighting.
Counsel also said the applicant would seek county approvals only after winning local approval. Because Franklin Avenue is a county road, Essex County review is a second gate the project must clear.
For residents, the phasing plan and lighting limits are the most direct protections. They address how disruptive construction will be at an active grocery site and how the finished building will affect the street at night. For the applicant, agreeing to the engineer's letter up front narrows the issues left for the next session.
What's next: The traffic and stormwater conditions remain open. Expect them to resurface when testimony resumes on the 18th.
Looking Ahead
The Vincom LLC hearing resumes on the 18th, when the applicant's remaining witnesses are expected to testify. Residents interested in traffic, stormwater or design along Franklin Avenue should watch whether the board's open questions turn into formal conditions before any vote.