Locunity — where decisions happen.
Nutley Weighs Stormwater Rules for Small Home Projects

Nutley Weighs Stormwater Rules for Small Home Projects

Planning Board • NutleyOctober 25, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Nutley's Planning Board spent about an hour on Oct. 25, 2026, on a question many homeowners never think about: where the rain goes after a new patio or addition. No vote was taken, but the board's consultant laid out a menu of dry wells, underground chambers and rain gardens that could become required for projects too small to trigger state rules.


  • Stormwater workshop explores mitigation for additions, patios below state thresholds
  • Homeowner costs of roughly $3,000 to $5,000 per system drive debate
  • Galaxy Investment application stays postponed to Jan. 6, 2027; resident's comments cut off
  • Vintom LLC's ShopRite addition hearing opens Nov. 4, expected to span meetings
  • Proposed state bill on converting retail and office sites to housing worries members

The Small-Project Stormwater Gap

The basics: Impervious coverage means surfaces such as roofs, patios and driveways that shed water instead of absorbing it. A dry well is an underground pit that collects runoff and lets it seep into the soil. Cultec chambers are a brand of buried plastic storage units that serve a similar purpose.

Why it matters: Under state Department of Environmental Protection rules, which Nutley's local law mirrors, mitigation applies only when a project disturbs 1 acre or adds a quarter acre of new impervious area. That leaves nearly every home addition, patio and driveway in town with no requirement at all.

Ken DeGennaro of Pinoni Associates, who presented the workshop, said small projects are exempt "unless it meets those thresholds, which are mirrored in Nutley's local law as well."

Where things stand: DeGennaro proposed amending the local stormwater law to supplement, not override, DEP rules. Asked whether a local rule would supersede the state's, he answered: "Okay, it would supplement."

His model is a one-page menu. Homeowners could choose a dry well, Cultec chambers or a rain garden sized to their new impervious area, or opt for an engineered alternative. Rather than designing for the 9-inch, 100-year storm, he suggested capturing about 2 inches of rainfall.

The biggest open question is the trigger. Options floated included 500, 1,000 or 2,000 square feet of new impervious area; one other town uses 400. A board member suggested scaling requirements to project size. "Can we implement something that's kind of like a graduated response, right?" the member asked.

The same member made the case for acting at all: "More runoff, even on a small scale, as you do that more and more and more throughout the town. It's part of the reason we have the flooding."

The Board Chair framed the workshop as overdue, noting the topic came out of joint meetings with the zoning board: "It's 2 years in a row we haven't done something."

The other side: Cost dominated the pushback. DeGennaro estimated "maybe around $5,000" for a single dry well and about $3,000 for a small patio-scale system. "I think we're all concerned about the average homeowner," said a board member. Another board member worried about families' ability to add on to their homes.

Members also raised practical limits: topography, the direction drainage flows, soil and groundwater conditions, overflow, proximity to foundations, and effects on neighbors and downstream properties. DeGennaro acknowledged that "dry wells work when it's not saturated by groundwater already."

An official described how little the current code covers. Standard one- and two-family projects face no requirement unless they come before the board. "There's not a requirement to put any kind of stormwater mitigation or anything in," the official said, adding that "the code is silent on grading. Totally silent." The one relevant sentence, in the property maintenance code, says you can't divert a drain onto a neighbor's property.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No vote was taken. A rule would add upfront costs for homeowners building patios, additions and driveways. In exchange, it aims to reduce the cumulative runoff that members linked to flooding. Contractors and engineers would likely see more design work. Downstream neighbors stand to benefit most.

What's next: DeGennaro will research rules in Upper Saddle River, Wayne and other towns. He will also add data correlating storm recurrence intervals and report back. The chair plans to review notes and convene the zoning committee.


Galaxy Stays Parked; Resident Told to Wait

Where things stand: Galaxy Investment's preliminary and final site plan for 536-544 Washington Avenue remains continued to Jan. 6, 2027.

During public comment, a resident who said she represented others asked what it would take to get the board to say no. She began raising potential legal standing, precedent, lack of use on the original application, and safety concerns about a warehouse. The Board Chair repeatedly stopped her, saying the board cannot address an application in its current state. "No, ma'am, that's absolutely inappropriate," the chair said, directing her to return Jan. 6.

Why it matters: New Jersey planning boards act as quasi-judicial bodies on pending applications. Comments are heard on the record at the formal hearing, not during general public comment.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Members confirmed the applicant has committed on the record to re-notice neighbors within 200 feet if the application changes substantially. Opponents keep their chance to be heard, but only at the hearing.

What's next: The Galaxy hearing is set for Jan. 6, 2027.


ShopRite Addition Hearing Will Run Long

Vintom LLC's application for 437 and 441 Franklin Avenue, the ShopRite addition, is scheduled for a Nov. 4 hearing. A board official warned it will not wrap up quickly: "It's unlikely that we're going to finish that in one evening." The traffic expert is unavailable that night, and the expert report has not been submitted.

What's next: Applicants and neighbors should expect a multi-meeting review. The official noted the board could continue into the first Wednesday in December.


State Bill Raises Local Control Worries

A board member raised a proposed state bill, referred to as 1766. It would allow certain retail or office areas that no longer operate as before to be rezoned for housing. The member asked whether it could apply to the Viola Brothers area and warned that "the state wants to kind of take the right away from planning boards."

A board official said the bill targets "converting certain office parks and retail centers that meet eligibility requirements of the bill into mixed-use developments," with size and vacancy parameters limiting its reach. Another member called it "a pro-development bill."

Why it matters: The bill could shift some land-use authority from local boards to state criteria, opening underused commercial sites to housing. Members also mentioned a separate accessory-dwelling bill.

What's next: No action was taken. Members said they will seek more information.


Minor Items

  • Treatment Works Approval: The board was copied on PB Nutcliffe Master LLC's sewer metering application for the Innovation Center. Engineering review must determine whether it affects the board's prior resolution.
  • Minutes: A motion to approve the Oct. 7 minutes was made and seconded and a voice vote called; no result was announced.
  • Bills: A $150 bill for preparing minutes went to a voice vote with an audible "aye"; no tally was announced.

Looking Ahead

The Vintom hearing opens Nov. 4, and the Galaxy hearing returns Jan. 6, 2027. A refined stormwater proposal will follow consultant research and a meeting with the zoning committee.