

Franklin Avenue Liquor Store Plan Moves to Vote With Truck, ADA Conditions
Planning Board • NutleyNovember 19, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
The Nutley Planning Board spent most of its Nov. 19, 2026, meeting reworking how trucks, shoppers and wheelchair users will share a crowded ShopRite lot. The board heard a plan to add a liquor store at 437-441 Franklin Avenue, and member Jerry DelTufo moved to approve it with about 21 conditions. A roll call followed, but no formal result was declared. Members also moved to track zoning recommendations that have sat with the Board of Commissioners since late 2024.
- Approval motion with about 21 conditions for the Franklin Avenue liquor store addition drew roll-call "yes" responses. The final result is unconfirmed.
- 26-foot delivery truck cap, head-in deliveries and an added ADA space reshape the busy ShopRite site.
- 40 employee parking spaces will move across Franklin Avenue under the conditions read into the motion.
- Monthly tracking spreadsheet will follow stalled zoning recommendations, including pawn shop and bail bondsman bans.
- Board Chair Mark Arcuti warns that state housing bills could strip power from local boards.
Franklin Avenue Liquor Store Clears Hearing, Result Unconfirmed
The basics: Fintom LLC is seeking preliminary and final site plan approval for 437-441 Franklin Avenue (Block 4501, Lots 24 and 25). The plan adds a liquor store next to the existing ShopRite and needs no variances. This was a continued hearing, and the applicant had already rested its case.
Why it matters: The site is already congested. The conditions attached to the motion change how delivery trucks move, where accessible parking sits and where employees park. Shoppers, nearby pedestrians and the store's workers will all feel those changes.
Where things stand: Lee Klein, the board-retained traffic engineer, walked members through delivery circulation, parking and ADA spaces. He recommended pavement markings, do-not-enter signs, reconfigured front ADA stalls and a new approach for trucks.
"My suggestion was to make that a head-in," said Klein, describing deliveries.
On parking, Klein said the front lot can handle the busiest periods. "That's more than adequate for the peak demand," he said.
The applicant did not resist. "We would certainly accept them as conditions," said Thomas DiBiazzi, applicant counsel for Fintom LLC.
Architect Muhammad Shama of Barbary Architects presented the exterior materials, entered as exhibit A8. Board members later praised the design and said it improves the Franklin Avenue streetscape.
Some members asked why shoppers can't walk straight from the ShopRite into the new store. Joseph Frustelli, the applicant's representative, cited ABC (alcoholic beverage control) rules and the stores' separate ownership. "We are not allowed to have access to the liquor store from the ShopRite," he said.
The other side: Not every member was convinced the lot can handle the added activity. "I do have some concern with traffic flow and pedestrian flow," said a board member. That member also pressed on pedestrian congestion, 8-foot ADA stalls and ramp width. Other members questioned whether trucks would have to back up on site.
The ramp question drew a direct answer from the applicant's engineer. "The railing actually is not needed because that's not really a ramp," said David Fantina, project engineer for Fintom LLC. He added that the sidewalk railing could be removed.
Board Chair Arcuti then set a firm limit on delivery vehicles. "The maximum truck will be 26 feet," he said.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: DelTufo praised the plan before moving approval. "My position is a well-thought-out plan," said Board Member Jerry DelTufo.
The conditions read into the motion include:
- An additional ADA parking space
- Directional signage
- A 26-foot maximum for delivery trucks
- Stormwater review, including dry wells
- Photocell-controlled lighting
- Relocation of 40 employee parking spaces across Franklin Avenue
A roll call followed, and members answered "yes." No "no" votes were heard. However, the board did not formally declare a result, and individual votes could not be attributed (For: unconfirmed, Against: none heard, Absent: unconfirmed).
If approved, the plan gives Fintom a path to open with no variances. Shoppers and wheelchair users get a redesigned front lot and an extra accessible space. Employees will park across Franklin Avenue, which frees up spaces near the stores but means more pedestrians crossing the street.
What's next: The board's written resolution and minutes should confirm the outcome and the final list of conditions.
Planning Board Moves to Track Stalled Zoning Fixes
Why it matters: Several Planning Board recommendations have not been adopted by the Board of Commissioners, Nutley's governing body. Until they are, gaps remain in local rules. For example, there is still no ban on pawn shops or bail bondsmen along corridors like Franklin Avenue.
Where things stand: DelTufo described a tracker covering the board's outstanding recommendations:
- Prohibited uses, including pawn shops and bail bondsmen
- Accessory dwelling units (ADUs)
- Warehouses
- Off-site parking
- A review of Washington Avenue
- A noise ordinance
"We've got outstanding recommendations from the fourth quarter of 2024," said DelTufo.
Board Member Anthony Malfitano asked that the spreadsheet explain where each item came from, not just its status. "Is there a way that you can put a little narrative together what that process comes from?" he asked. He also requested a column for follow-up actions.
Board Chair Arcuti laid out the options available to the commissioners and acknowledged frustration with the delays. Another participant suggested creating a part-time liaison position in the code office to keep planning items moving.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No vote was taken. The board will build the spreadsheet and update it monthly. That gives members, and the public, a running record of which recommendations the commissioners have acted on and which have stalled. Business owners and residents near commercial corridors have the most at stake in the prohibited-use bans.
What's next: Look for the first version of the tracker at an upcoming meeting. Watch whether the liaison idea is formally proposed.
Chair Pushes Back on State Housing Mandates
Why it matters: State legislation could limit how much say local boards like Nutley's have over housing and mixed-use projects. Members said local infrastructure is already under strain.
Where things stand: Board Chair Arcuti handed out copies of State Bill 1766, which addresses mixed-use conversion. Members also discussed a separate ADU bill.
"I just don't like the idea of the state trying to step in and take the power away from the local boards," said Arcuti.
A board member said the pressure from the housing shortage is only beginning. That member pointed to limits on sewer, water and power capacity. "The housing's needed, but the infrastructure isn't being improved," the member said. Members also raised how land uses such as "fast casual" restaurants are defined in local rules.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No action was taken. The discussion signals that the board is likely to scrutinize any state-driven housing changes. It also flags utility capacity as a concern for developers and residents alike.
What's next: Members floated holding a formal workshop on the state bills. No date was set.
Minor Items
- The board took up the prior minutes and a $150 bill for the minutes-taker; both were moved and seconded by voice, though the outcome was not clearly recorded.
Looking Ahead
Watch for the board's resolution on the Franklin Avenue plan, the first monthly zoning tracker and a possible workshop on state housing legislation.