

Nutley Residents Rally Against Kingsland Data Center as Board Cites Settlement
Board of Commissioners • NutleyNovember 6, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Not one person in a packed Nutley Board of Commissioners meeting raised a hand to support a data center at the Kingsland site. Commissioners said a 2025 legal settlement already makes a data center a permitted use there, and that any proposal would go to the planning board, not to them. Earlier, two state legislators told residents that New Jersey's new data center laws address water and energy but not noise.
- No support voiced for a Kingsland data center as residents, students and a Belleville neighbor spoke against it for more than an hour
- Settlement traded a truck terminal for a data center use, commissioners said, and no application has been filed
- Planning board would decide any application, with notice to owners within 200 feet and public hearings
- New state laws create a data center rate class and six-month reporting, but noise is not covered
- Moratorium bill A5663 has not been heard in committee; one assemblymember said he is open to a short-term pause
A Room United Against Kingsland
Why it matters: Opposition to a possible data center at Kingsland spanned new residents, longtime homeowners, high school students and a neighbor from across the Belleville line. The board moved public comment earlier in the meeting at the audience's request.
Where things stand: Residents raised noise, water use, grid strain, children's health and property values. Public commenter Shane Sullivan asked for a show of hands from anyone who supported a data center and reported that none went up. He told the board that the response raised a basic question: "what is the whole point of a republic, a democracy, anything."
Public commenter John Greer, a new resident who lives about half a mile from the site, said he may move if a data center is built. Public commenter Agnieszka Golashik asked how a data center ended up in the settlement and what a child's health is worth, and she played audio of data center noise. Public commenter Kevin Freer cited litigation in Vineland over generator permits. Public commenter Natalia Stevens asked what makes a data center appealing, given the unknown long-term effects on families and wildlife.
Dominic Soron, a Nutley High School senior, said classmates view the project as a negative and that many would not live in Nutley as adults if it is built. Mayor John V. Kelly III later invited him to meet.
Rob Garber said a sign on Kingsland promotes 65 megawatts, compared with 9 megawatts in use at the existing River Road data center. He said the Kingsland site sits near houses, a preschool, a senior center and a park.
Chris Jacobson asked why the issue isn't put to a vote and what protections exist before an application arrives. He later read a statement from a Belleville neighbor who noted that Belleville has banned data centers and urged Nutley to be transparent and take a stand. Patty Little asked whether the town could hold a special election or public question. Officials said a mechanism for a ballot question exists but did not have the details.
The other side: Christina Soretsky, who lives across from the River Road facility, said it has had no noticeable impact on her. She asked whether anything prevents it from upgrading. Commissioner Thomas J. Evans said the facility dates to 2005: "It's an 18-megawatt capable center, which is currently using 9 megawatts of power." He said it is evaporation-cooled and supplied by Jersey City water, and that any upgrade would need code enforcement review and planning board site plan approval with sworn expert testimony. Commissioner Alphonse Petracco asked River Road neighbors to share their experiences. Commissioner Mauro G. Tucci said the board would look into protections for the existing center.
Settlement Ties Commissioners' Hands, Board Says
The basics: A settlement agreement resolves litigation on agreed terms. Commissioners said violating its terms could expose the township to costly lawsuits.
Where things stand: Mayor Kelly said the settlement was reached in principle around 2023–24 and signed in 2025. Under the deal, he said, the developer agreed that "they would withdraw the application for the truck terminal warehouse, never to be revived again, in exchange if we permitted a data center to be a permitted use on the property." He also said "no one on this board has any financial interest in this."
Commissioner Evans stressed that "we do not have an application before us for a data center." He said the redevelopment plan lists about 10 other permitted uses, and that the planning board can attach enforceable conditions to any approval.
The process: Mayor Kelly said any application would go to the planning board. That board retains its own experts, requires notice to property owners within 200 feet, and takes testimony over several meetings with public questions and comment. The mayor said both he and Commissioner Joseph P. Scarpelli sit on the planning board.
The other side: Residents pressed for a stronger stance, and commissioners explained why they would not take one. "We are, in fact, handicapped by the settlement agreement," said Commissioner Tucci. He warned that violating the settlement could put the trucking terminal back in play. He also told residents, "We hear you. We just can't express whether or not we agree or disagree with you." Commissioner Petracco echoed that the settlement constrains what the board can say publicly.
Commissioner Scarpelli made the issue personal, telling the crowd "any of your concerns are my concerns." He noted that his grandson attends the nearby preschool.
Questions about rezoning risk, a ballot question and the independence of experts were answered only partially or deferred to counsel.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The board took no action. Nearby residents, families tied to the preschool and senior center, and Belleville neighbors now know that the planning board is the venue that counts. The developer retains its permitted use under the settlement. The board also faces a squeeze: residents are demanding a public position, while the settlement discourages commissioners from taking one.
What's next: No date was set. Watch for any application to the planning board, which would trigger notice and public hearings.
State Lawmakers Concede a Noise Gap
Why it matters: State rules set the floor for what Nutley can demand of any Kingsland proposal. Residents pressed hard on what those rules leave out.
Where things stand: Assemblymember Michael Venezia said the governor signed two data center bills. One creates a separate ratepayer class. The other requires data centers to report water and energy use to the Board of Public Utilities every six months. Commissioner Evans confirmed the first law was meant to "establish a rate class specifically for data centers." He said a center that reserves 30 megawatts but uses 5 would pay for 85% of its reserved capacity, and he linked this to effects on the PJM regional grid.
Community benefit agreements come from a Local Finance Board notice, not from statute. Public commenter Emma Cortese asked how the state could help towns hire experts. Legislators said the Economic Development Authority would guide towns on which experts they need but would not supply them.
Assemblymember Carmen Morales said about 25 data center bills are pending. One is A5663, which would require a Department of Environmental Protection study and bar new construction until the study is complete. "Currently, it hasn't even been introduced into a committee yet," she said, adding that the next committee meeting is in December.
Commissioner Petracco asked "how could you assure us that today's guardrails are not going to be tomorrow's failures." Assemblymember Morales answered directly: "Can we guarantee that the guardrails that we're setting today aren't going to impact tomorrow? No, we can't guarantee that because we just don't know."
The other side: Assemblymember Venezia cited a Vineland case as evidence of enforcement, saying after resident complaints "the DEP went in and fined them $1 million." Rob Garber asked, "Would the 2 of you be willing to co-sponsor that bill?" Assemblymember Venezia replied, "I will take a look at it absolutely," and later said, "I would be okay with a short-term moratorium." Assemblymember Morales was more cautious: "I want to understand it to its full capacity before I can say yes."
Both legislators acknowledged that noise is not part of the signed laws. Public commenter Agnieszka Golashik asked why, citing 24/7 low-frequency effects. Assemblymember Morales said she would raise the issue at the next committee meeting.
What's next: A5663 awaits committee action. Residents seeking a moratorium or noise rules have a state-level target in December.
Minor Items
- Bill list: The board approved $11,036,304.58 in bills and payroll, including $8.2M for Revenue and Finance (For: 5, Against: 0, Absent: 0).
- 2027 contracts: Voice votes advanced the professional services slate, including $182,070 for the municipal accountant and $75,000 for general legal work. Other items included an $88,059.20 Badger Meter contract and an $82,746.61 Murray Paving and Concrete settlement. Resolutions 305-26, 307-26, 310-26 and 341-26 were tabled or pulled.
- Handicap parking: Ordinance 3627, introduced 5-0, removes handicap spaces at 15 locations where a police review found residents had moved. A Grand Avenue no-parking amendment was also introduced, though the outcome of its voice vote was unclear.
- Renovated chambers: Commissioners unveiled the redesigned meeting room, funded with American Rescue Funds. Commissioner Evans called the project on time and in budget.
- Proclamation: The board honored Father Alex Barbieto for 40 years of priesthood and designated November as National Diabetes Awareness Month.
Looking Ahead
The water and sewer ordinance, which sets a flat fee plus rate, returns at the next meeting on Tuesday, Dec. 1, 2026, at 7 p.m. Estimated billing will continue in the meantime. Commissioner Evans warned that Passaic Valley Sewer's budget, set for introduction Dec. 10, could push costs higher because of PFAS treatment rules. Sewer charges totaled $5.4M last year.