Locunity — where decisions happen.
Nutley Board Says No Data Center Application Exists, Sets Nov. 5 Briefing

Nutley Board Says No Data Center Application Exists, Sets Nov. 5 Briefing

Board of Commissioners • NutleyOctober 21, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Nutley residents packed public comment with pointed questions about a possible data center at the Washington Avenue warehouse site. Officials said no application exists, cited legal limits on what they can say about an existing settlement, and promised a public information session on Nov. 5 with a state lawmaker expected to attend. The board also approved 2027 contracts, including an $87,000 government relations deal tied to the Hoffman-La Roche redevelopment.


  • No data center application on file, Mayor Kelly says. Any hearing is unlikely before late Q1 or early Q2 2027.
  • Nov. 5 information session promised. Assemblymember Venezia is expected to attend.
  • Residents press on pollution, notice and settlement secrecy. A petition has drawn 2,200 signatures.
  • $87,000 Thomas Greco Publishing contract approved for Hoffman-La Roche redevelopment government relations.
  • Purchasing agent role outsourced for up to $18,000, with more than $100,000 in claimed yearly savings.
  • Stormwater Ordinance 3626 heard on second reading. A resident is still waiting to learn whether it covers the Kingsland site.

Data Center Fears Meet Legal Limits

Why it matters: A possible data center at the Washington Avenue warehouse site has become Nutley's most contested land-use question. The petition's 2,200 signatures show organized resident opposition. The board is constrained by a settlement agreement it says it cannot discuss, and it has no application in hand to act on.

Where things stand: During announcements, Mayor Kelly set the frame early. "We have promised an information session regarding data centers to the public," he said.

He said Assemblymember Venezia is "99%" confirmed for the Nov. 5 meeting. The board has approached State Senators Timberlake and Ruiz, but neither has committed.

When public comment turned to the warehouse site, Kelly returned to a single fact. "We don't have an application for a data center," he said, adding that any answers to residents' hypotheticals would be speculation.

Kelly also explained several limits on the board's role:

  • Zoning: A data center is one of about a dozen permitted uses on the site.
  • Notice: If an application is filed, "anyone who's in that 200-foot radius of the property will get a notice," Kelly said.
  • Timing: A planning board hearing would not happen "probably until at least late Q1, early Q2 '27."

The other side: Five public commenters spoke on the issue.

  • Chris Jacobson, public commenter, cited air, noise and light pollution, strain on the power grid and higher electricity costs. He asked why residents get no vote, and why a data center gets less neighbor notice than a pool or shed application. He called the arrangement a double standard compared with residential zoning limits.
  • Christina Saretsky, public commenter, asked what enforceable remedies the township could build into any agreement if a builder's promises on water, pollution and noise prove false.
  • Darryl Taunt, a Hawthorne resident, asked each commissioner whether they had read Dr. Seuss's The Lorax.
  • Rob Garber, public commenter, thanked the board for scheduling the session. He then pressed on how it will be advertised, whether commissioners will address the settlement, and whether the meeting will return to the town hall chambers. He cited the 2,200 petition signatures and urged the board to go beyond standard Sunshine Act notice.

Privilege and prejudice: Kelly said attorney advice on the settlement is privileged and that the township cannot waive that privilege. He promised to advertise the session to the fullest extent the law allows.

Garber asked whether going beyond normal notice steps could prejudice the settlement. "Possibly," Kelly answered.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No action was taken.

On enforcement, a commissioner said planning board resolutions, together with July state law changes on reporting, mean that "that gives the construction office the ability to monitor and enforce compliance." For residents, that points to the planning board's conditions of approval as the main tool for holding a future builder accountable.

On flyers and signs, a commissioner cautioned residents: "You can't put it on public property, public right-of-ways, things like that."

What's next: The information session is set for the next board meeting, Thursday, Nov. 5, 2026, at 7 p.m. The meeting moves to Thursday because of Election Day.

A commissioner said chambers reconstruction may be finished by then. "We should be done and we should be back in, but I can't guarantee that until we get closer," the commissioner said.


Contracts Slate Locks in 2027 Services

Why it matters: The board committed money for 2027 before adopting a 2027 budget. Every 2027 dollar is subject to that budget.

Where things stand: The largest new award is a contract with Thomas Greco Publishing LLC. It pays $7,250 a month, or $87,000, from Nov. 1, 2026, to Oct. 31, 2027, for government relations work tied to the Hoffman-La Roche site redevelopment.

The contract was awarded as a non-fair-and-open professional service, with a pay-to-play disclosure attached. Mayor Kelly explained why the cost is split across multiple budget accounts. "This is simply that the services are utilized by all departments," he said.

The board also outsourced its purchasing agent role to Denise Caffone of Dynamic Municipal Consulting for up to $18,000, replacing a full-time employee who retired. "The difference in cost to the municipalities is over $100,000 a year in savings," said a commissioner.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts:

  • Greco contract: Passed, with four ayes audible.
  • Purchasing agent: Passed (For: 5, Against: 0, Absent: 0).
  • Forester contract: Shade Tree Department LLC will serve as township forester for up to $32,500, from Oct. 23, 2026, to Oct. 22, 2027 (For: 5, Against: 0, Absent: 0).
  • Litigation counsel: Bruno and Ferraro was retained for Oriema v. Township at $215 an hour, capped at $15,000 (For: 5, Against: 0, Absent: 0).

The outsourcing trend favors consultants over township payroll. It may save money, but it also moves institutional knowledge outside Town Hall.

What's next: Proposals for two requests for qualifications are due Nov. 2, 2026, at 11 a.m. One is for an insurance risk manager. The other is for an accident and safety consultant tied to the township's Joint Insurance Fund. Both RFQs passed 5-0.


Stormwater Rules Advance, Kingsland Question Lingers

Why it matters: New state stormwater rules could affect a contested redevelopment parcel on Kingsland Street. A resident has asked more than once whether they apply.

Where things stand: Trish Molesky, public commenter, again asked whether the new stormwater laws apply to the Kingsland property, and when she would get an answer.

Mayor Kelly said an answer would come, most likely from redevelopment counsel rather than Attorney Bruno. He said it would probably arrive as a board announcement rather than by email.

At the second-reading public hearing on Ordinance 3626, which amends Chapter 622 on stormwater control, no one spoke. Kelly said the change brings township code into compliance with New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection standards.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The ordinance was seconded and a roll call was called, but members' responses were not captured. Adoption is not confirmed.

What's next: Residents tracking the Kingsland site should watch for the promised board announcement from redevelopment counsel.


Minor Items

  • Generator contract extended: Montillo Electric's public safety building generator contract now runs through Dec. 31, 2026, with the $1,124,000 cap unchanged and grant-funded (For: 5, Against: 0, Absent: 0). A commissioner blamed the delay on a past fire department diesel spill, and Kelly stressed "this is not another $1,124,000."
  • Towing contracts: Nicoletti Auto Body and Twin Towing contracts were extended to Dec. 31, 2026. A three-year, two-vendor towing rotation running through 2029 was then approved 5-0.
  • Street tree complaint: David Fisher, a Lynn Road resident, said a healthy town tree caused $2,000 in drain cleaning and damaged his sidewalk. A commissioner said "we don't typically take down live healthy trees" but pledged a personal site visit.
  • Bill lists: The board approved bill lists totaling $14,771,063.90, with four ayes audible.
  • Recognitions: The board recognized Oct. 26 as National Day of the Deployed and November as Native American Heritage Month, citing Lenape homelands. Members also held a moment of silence for former Nutley High School principal Mario Cacciola.

Looking Ahead

Prospect Street will close from Chestnut to High streets from 3 to 7:30 p.m. for Halloween. DMV inspections, which checked 62 cars this round, return Nov. 5 and Dec. 15. A ruck march is set for Nov. 11 at American Legion Post 299. The next board meeting, with the data center briefing, is Thursday, Nov. 5, 2026, at 7 p.m.