Locunity — where decisions happen.
Trustees Reject Lindsey, Name Middle School for Lisjan Nation

Trustees Reject Lindsey, Name Middle School for Lisjan Nation

Board of Education • New Haven Unified School DistrictNovember 11, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

New Haven Unified's Board of Education voted Nov. 10, 2026, to rename Cesar Chavez Middle School for the Lisjan Nation, after roughly 30 speakers lined up and a motion to honor Dr. Tommy Lindsey Jr. failed 2-3. The night also showed a fractured board: the teachers union's political action committee declared no confidence in a sitting trustee, and trustees clashed openly over debate rules.


  • Lisjan Nation Middle School approved after Lindsey motion fails 2-3
  • Committee members and students push a geographic name; Lindsey and Valle backers push back
  • Teachers union PAC declares no confidence in Vice President Melanie Freeberg
  • Trustees clash over Robert's Rules; superintendent to seek facilitator for January session
  • Logan pool lease-leaseback awarded; design heads to state architect this month

A Name, Then a Promise: Lisjan Nation Wins Out

Why it matters: The board passed over all three individual finalists. It sided with its naming committee, which had voted 7-0 and 11-2 against an individual name, and with a staff survey in which 99% opposed individual names. Trustees now owe the community the curriculum and recognition they promised.

Where things stand: Under Board Policy 7310, the Facilities Naming Committee reviewed 442 community suggestions. At the board's direction, it forwarded three people and three geographic names: Dolores Huerta, Dr. Tommy Lindsey Jr., Richard E. Valle, Lisjan Nation, Union Creek and Union. Deputy Superintendent Wee Stevens and Principal Ramon Camacho presented the list.

"It is important to acknowledge that several committee members continue to express a preference for a non-individual name," said Camacho.

When Board Vice President Melanie Freeberg asked, "Did the elders by chance share what that would look like to them?" Camacho replied that "our communication with them has been limited."

The other side: Trustee Shruti Kumar moved to name the school for Lindsey. "To me, Dr. Lindsey's name represents something larger," she said, pointing to courage and student voice.

Freeberg seconded the motion and warned against rejecting every finalist. "Asking for names and then rejecting names seemed like we were rejecting all the names that the community put forward," she said.

Trustee Michael Gonzales said the community forum "kind of sealed it for me that we should not name it after a person." Trustee Patricio R. Urbi Jr., the board clerk, argued that Lindsey himself would prefer deference to the students at Home of the Hawks.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The Lindsey motion failed. For: 2 (Kumar, Freeberg). Against: 3 (Urbi, Gonzales, Board President Shamsa Rafay). Absent: 0. Freeberg's and Rafay's votes were recorded by the order of the roll call, and the official minutes should confirm them.

Urbi then moved to name the school for the Lisjan Nation. Freeberg asked, "What would us honoring them by naming the school after mean, also, beyond naming the school?" Urbi answered: "We will be transforming our instructional practice to support the name of the school." He also promised a plaque.

Gonzales moved to close debate. Kumar raised a point of order that a motion was already on the table, and the chair moved to a vote without ruling on it. The Lisjan motion passed by roll call, and the chair declared it unanimous. Student representative Carey Dang abstained.

Committee members, staff and students who favored a place-based name got their outcome. Lindsey supporters, many tied to the James Logan High School forensics program, did not. The Lisjan Nation receives the honor, but staff described limited outreach to the tribe so far.

What's next: Trustees committed to curriculum changes and a plaque. They also pushed further discussion of naming honors to the January governance session.


Packed Room Splits on Person or Place

Why it matters: About 30 people filled out speaker cards, most of them on the school name. Rafay cut speaking time to 1 minute per speaker. The arguments raised during public comment largely previewed the trustees' later split.

Where things stand: Supporters of individual names framed their choices around personal impact. Public commenter Raymond Yu said that if the board chose a person, it should be Lindsey. Ashari Johnson, a former Logan forensics student who is now an educator, also backed Lindsey. Public commenter Vanessa Sad Sad supported Lindsey and called proposals to blend his name with others anti-Black.

Jason Toro, CEO of Tri-Ced, spoke for Richard Valle's legacy and cited his organization's record of employing formerly incarcerated people. Harinder Pal Singh urged honoring human-rights figure Jaswant Singh Khalra, either with the school name or a Logan facility. Dr. Jatpreet Sahi asked the board to vote on a name backed by 1,600 community members and on a petition to remove her from the committee. The board did not respond to either request.

The other side: Committee members pressed the board to follow its advisers. Carmen Castellanos, a Cesar Chavez Middle School staff member, said the committee voted against an individual name and that 99% of staff agreed. Paul Espejo, a teacher on the committee, cited the 7-0 and 11-2 votes.

Seventh-grade leadership student Alexandra Sahagan said 46 of 50 classmates she surveyed preferred Union Creek Middle School. Hector Romero urged a geographic name that welcomes every student.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The geographic-name coalition of committee members, staff and students prevailed, though not with its students' top pick of Union Creek. Public commenter Lily Turner criticized adult behavior during the naming process and asked the board to adopt a code of conduct for speakers.


Union Rebukes Board as Trustees Trade Barbs

Why it matters: The district's teachers union publicly broke with a trustee after a divisive election. Trustees' own clashes later in the night reinforced the union's complaint.

Where things stand: "In my short time as president of NHTA, I have too often seen a breakdown of decorum and shouting matches erupt from board members," said Shane Henderson, President, New Haven Teachers Association. Henderson also recalled the 2019 strike.

Abby Andrade, Political Action Committee chair, New Haven Teachers Association, said "we have officially lost confidence in Trustee Freeberg's leadership in Area 2."

The other side: After the naming vote, Gonzales apologized for the debate cutoff. "I think we should always adhere to our Robert's Rule, and this meeting will be so much smoother," he said. Kumar countered that "it is okay for trustees to engage in conversation" and called the cutoff bullying.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Superintendent John Thompson asked for direction on bringing in an outside facilitator for the January governance session. "Right now our board is fragmented," Kumar said, adding that outside facilitators had not helped in the past. Urbi disagreed: "I believe we do need a facilitator to have the conversation." Urbi suggested a new facilitator from the California School Boards Association, and Gonzales also favored outside help.

What's next: Thompson declared consensus to explore options, possibly Lee or a new CSBA facilitator. He needs direction soon to place a contract on the December agenda.


Logan Pool Clears a Hurdle; Vape Sensors Coming

Why it matters: The board awarded the lease-leaseback contract for the Dan Oden Swimming Complex pool addition by voice vote, without discussion. Lease-leaseback lets the district select a builder before the design is approved, so state review and contracting can run in parallel.

Where things stand: "We are targeting to submit the design to Division of State Architect by the end of the month," said Eric Qiu, Facility Director. Staff assume approval in April, with a 50-meter pool, construction from April to December and completion around December 2027 to February 2028.

Asked whether that was a best- or worst-case date, Qiu would not commit, because the guaranteed maximum price is not set. "I don't want to give you wrong information or expectations," he said. Thompson credited voter-approved Measures M and N for the facilities work.

Other projects include a Logan gymnasium pavilion and modernization, a finished track and field at Cesar Chavez Middle School, and an IVC track now under construction. Office upgrades are planned at Alvarado and Barnard White, along with an accessibility upgrade at Hillview Crest.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Earlier, Liam Wu, president of Logan's Unity Collective Club, cited a survey of 83 students. In it, 77% reported moderate to severe impacts from vaping and 80% from limited restroom access, and a petition gathered 345 signatures.

Jason Rogers, Director of Maintenance and Operations, said sensors will go into restrooms at James Logan, Conley Carabello and two middle schools by spring. They are part of a broader safety plan that includes access control and geofenced cameras. "Those are vape sensors," Thompson said.


Minor Items

  • Rafay farewell: Resolution 252627 honoring the outgoing president passed by voice vote; she cited bigotry her children faced.
  • Celebrations of Light: Resolution 232627 proclaims December 2026 Celebrations of Light Month.
  • Labor deals: Voice votes approved the CSEA agreement and two NHTA memorandums of understanding, on interim evaluations and the adult school salary schedule.
  • Vendor agreements: MOUs with Challenge Island, Concord LLC and Pivotal Pathways, plus a NextGen Science Innovations contract, passed; Challenge Island required a re-vote.
  • Consent calendar: Items 13A through 13AJ passed. For: 5, Against: 0, Absent: 0.

Looking Ahead

The board's January governance session will test whether a facilitator can repair working relationships, with a contract possibly coming in December. Trustees also agreed by consensus to renew the district's CSBA membership and support attendance at the Coast to Coast and CAAPLE conferences.