

Napa Faces Roughly $9M Yearly Budget Gap as El Niño Winter Looms
Board of Supervisors • Napa CountyNovember 17, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Napa County's General Fund is spending faster than its discretionary revenue grows, and budget staff told supervisors Nov. 17, 2026, that the county would need to draw about $9 million a year from fund balance to keep pace. The study session came on a day when the National Weather Service warned of a very strong El Niño winter and the Board unanimously adopted a land-use resolution against new detention facilities. Together, they point to a year in which money, staff time and emergency capacity will all be stretched.
- Roughly $9M annual General Fund gap projected in five-year forecast; no action taken
- "Coastal flooding is going to occur": NWS flags January as peak storm risk
- Detention-facility resolution adopted unanimously, framed as land-use policy rather than jail policy
- Draft 2027 legislative platform draws edits on housing, PG&E outages and FEMA; returns Dec. 15
The Math Doesn't Close: Budget Forecast Shows Structural Gap
Why it matters: The forecast shows costs persistently outpacing discretionary revenue. That will constrain staffing, capital projects and programs when the next budget is built.
Where things stand: Michael Kleiman, Chief Budget Officer, and Tracy Schulze, Auditor-Controller, walked the Board through budget rules, fund types and the line between mandatory and discretionary services.
The FY 2026-27 General Fund expenditure budget is about $338.4M, and 55% goes to salaries and benefits. Discretionary revenue has grown about 6.1% a year, while labor costs have grown about 6.7%.
FY 2025-26 ended better than planned. The county used only about $8M of fund balance instead of the budgeted $45.9M, helped by more than $21M in unspent services and supplies. The five-year forecast shows a recurring need to draw about $9M a year from fund balance, or about $5M with additional savings. The general reserve is about $70M.
Ryan J. Alsop, Chief Executive Officer, described restricted position control, deferred capital purchases and efficiency reviews. "We are not adding any additional positions here in the county," said Alsop. He also pointed to Measure B, the county's voter-approved wildfire funding: "that's $11 million a year for wildfire mitigation," said Alsop.
The other side: Belia Ramos, Supervisor, District 5, did not treat the better-than-budgeted close as reassurance. "This is absolutely unsustainable for us," said Ramos.
Ramos raised three further pressures:
- liabilities for employee leave payouts
- deferred maintenance
- the volatility of excess ERAF and Vehicle License Fee (VLF) revenue
Schulze explained the VLF risk. ERAF is the state fund that shifts local property taxes to schools; "excess" ERAF returns to counties when school needs are already met.
Anne Cottrell, Supervisor, District 3, pressed staff for more options. "What else can we do?" asked Cottrell. Staff responded by citing the roughly $70M general reserve.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No action was taken. County employees and bargaining units face a hiring posture that adds no new positions. Departments waiting on capital purchases face continued deferrals. Programs funded through VLF and excess ERAF carry the most revenue risk.
What's next: Budget guidelines return to the Board early next year. Budget adoption is set for June 29, 2027.
Storm Season: NWS Warns of a "Slam Dunk" Flood Year
Why it matters: Flooding, landslides and power outages are likely to test county response this winter. The briefing showed how agencies plan to coordinate before storms arrive.
Where things stand: Brian Garcia, Warning Coordination Meteorologist, National Weather Service SF Bay Area, described a very strong El Niño. He cautioned that no two El Niños are alike and that impacts depend on how fast storms drop rain. "January looks kind of like our worst timeframe right now," said Garcia.
Garcia flagged several hazards:
- shallow landslides on saturated soils
- downed trees
- king tides, beginning shortly after the meeting
- Kelvin waves, which stack on top of sea level
"Coastal flooding is going to occur; that's a slam dunk," said Garcia.
Steve Lederer, Public Works Director, described flood-gate checks and drainage work on mountain roads. "If we have done enough to prevent even one slide, we're $1.5 million ahead," said Lederer. He also explained that Milton Road sits at a natural drainage low point and can flood at high tide.
Other agencies outlined their readiness:
- JC Greenberg, Deputy Chief, CAL FIRE/Napa County Fire Department, cited swift-water teams and CAL FIRE hand crews.
- Oscar Ortiz, Sheriff, described river monitoring and deputies supplementing road crews.
- Mark Van Gorder of PG&E's local government affairs team said road access will be the main constraint on restoring power.
Cottrell asked about outreach from the Office of Emergency Services (OES) and suggested a dedicated OES social media account. "We're going to start a separate page for Ready. It'll be a Ready Napa County social media account," said Ortiz.
The other side: Earlier in the meeting, an Edgerly Island resident disputed a Napa River Reclamation District memo directing property owners to maintain levees. He offered $5,000 for any legal document proving that responsibility and asked for more sandbags.
Joelle Gallagher, Supervisor, District 1, cited the State Lands Commission as placing responsibility for structures on state-leased land with the owner. "We have actually delivered the equivalent of over 2,000 sandbags," said Gallagher, compared with the usual roughly 500. Lederer said the county provided about four times the usual sand.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No action was taken. Low-lying Milton Road and Edgerly Island residents face tidal flooding that sandbags can only partly address. Hillside and rural residents face slide and outage risks.
What's next: Residents were urged to use sandbag stations and sign up for emergency alerts ahead of storms.
Detention Resolution Passes, but Advocates Want More
Why it matters: The resolution declares detention facilities inconsistent with county land-use policy. It also builds an administrative record the county can use if a detention facility is ever proposed in Napa County.
Where things stand: Andrew Mize, Senior Legislative and Policy Advocate, said the item stemmed from Gallagher's Aug. 25 referral seeking an interim urgency moratorium on new detention facilities. Staff, the Planning, Building and Environmental Services department and County Counsel chose a resolution instead. They cited legal defensibility and the county's permissive zoning code.
Staff "determined that a policy resolution offers the best blend of building an administrative record in the event of future litigation, providing clear and direct guidance to the board's subsidiary bodies, and legal defensibility," said Mize.
The resolution draws on existing county policies on agricultural land, groundwater, housing, airport land use, climate and wildfire resilience.
The other side: Risa Jarvey of Napa Mutual Aid welcomed progress on non-cooperation with ICE. She said the measure does not go far enough and urged limits on jail communication with ICE and releases to ICE.
Wendell Coleman, public commenter, called the policy symbolic. He cited jail and ICE-transfer figures and Hispanic economic disparities, and urged support for farmworker unionization and pathways to naturalization.
Ramos drew a firm line between the resolution and the jail's "604 policy" on ICE detainer requests. "This policy has nothing to do with our own correctional facility," said Ramos.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Cottrell backed the approach. "It's common sense and it's also strategic," said Cottrell. Gallagher and Vice Chair Liz Alessio, Supervisor, District 2, also expressed support.
Ramos moved the resolution and Gallagher seconded. It passed on a voice vote declared unanimous; individual votes were not recorded. (For: unanimous of members present, Against: 0, Absent: 1, Chair Amber Manfree, excused.)
The county gains a defensible position against future detention proposals. Immigrant advocates did not get changes to how the jail handles ICE detainer requests.
Legislative Platform: Defense Year Shapes 2027 Wish List
Why it matters: The platform guides the county's lobbying on federal safety-net cuts, wildfire recovery, VLF protection, housing and utility reliability.
Where things stand: "2026 was a record year for advocacy during my tenure, but we spent most of the time on defense," said Mize. The county sent 30 letters on 22 topics in 2026, up from 12 topics in 2025. Most of that work defended programs threatened by H.R. 1, the federal budget legislation.
Mize cited three wins:
- $250,000 a year for Farmworker Center housing
- an extension of authority to buy Camp Coombs
- legislative intent language for a permanent VLF fix, which has not yet been codified
The 2027 draft takes a wait-and-see approach toward a new Congress and governor. It covers behavioral health funding, the airport, surface transportation, insurance, carrier-of-last-resort rules and PG&E cost recovery.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Supervisors requested several changes. Cottrell asked staff to:
- remove a Measure B paragraph
- add CEQA bullet points
- strengthen language on pest control and disaster resilience
- call out FEMA cost-shifting
- reference PG&E outages
On outages, Cottrell said she wants "a reference to the numerous and prolonged outages that many in Napa County have faced this year in particular."
Ramos sought attention to high-resource-area designations and broader housing wording. "I think we need to say housing and economic stability because it doesn't otherwise signal housing in and of itself," said Ramos.
What's next: A public feedback page is open at connect.napacounty.gov. The Board will consider the revised draft for adoption Dec. 15.
Minor Items
- Management pay plan (4.W, 4.X): Approved unanimously, Manfree absent, after Ramos had an erroneous Deputy Sheriffs' Association (DSA) reference removed. Her comments on pay for master's-level coursework were referred for future policy; 4.X carries a $7,155 Health and Human Services Agency expense.
- Consent calendar: All other items passed by a voice vote declared unanimous on a motion by Gallagher, seconded by Ramos.
- Molly's Angels: Executive Director Devereaux Smith thanked the Board for a District 1 grant supporting a Dec. 4 Elks Lodge luncheon for 240 older adults.
- Regional role: Ramos was elected vice president of CalCOG and reported that the Bay Area Housing Finance Authority (BAFA) will seek legislative changes in 2027.
- Employee awards: Library Services Director Anthony Halstead received the Outstanding Department Head Award, Greenberg received the CEO's Award, and the Elections Department received the Chair's Award.
Looking Ahead
The Board next meets Tuesday, Dec. 8, 2026, at 9 a.m. The revised legislative platform returns Dec. 15.