Locunity — where decisions happen.
Zoning Board Approves Forest Street Children's Bookstore With Zero Parking

Zoning Board Approves Forest Street Children's Bookstore With Zero Parking

Zoning Board of Adjustment • MontclairNovember 5, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Two Forest Street storefronts, vacant since 2025, will become a children's bookstore and craft learning hub. On Nov. 4, 2026, Montclair's Zoning Board of Adjustment approved Contexto LLC's use and parking variances by voice vote, with five conditions attached. The board approved the project without any on-site parking, and it chose a flexible "good faith" parking condition over binding commitments.


  • Use variance granted for a bookstore and learning hub at 150-152 Forest Street in the R-2 zone
  • Zero-parking variance approved after a traffic study found 19 weekday and 44 Saturday open spaces nearby
  • One resident opposed, citing blocked driveways and school traffic. The landlord's leasing agent backed the project.
  • Five conditions attached, including a good-faith effort to secure off-site parking rather than written leases

Forest Street Storefronts Get a New Tenant

The basics: A D-1 use variance lets a property host a use that the zoning doesn't permit. The site, Block 3302, Lot 10, sits in the R-2 residential zone next to the Montclair Cooperative School. Approval needed 5 of 7 eligible votes. Two alternates on the dais could not vote.

Why it matters: The storefronts were designed for commercial use and are unsuitable for housing. Approval puts a low-intensity, arts-oriented business into a long-vacant space in a residential neighborhood.

Where things stand: Contexto LLC is a family business. Co-owner Yanell Rodriguez described two side-by-side operations:

  • Bookstore: open 10 a.m.-5 p.m. seven days a week, with one employee
  • Learning hub: open noon-7 p.m. about five days a week, running three to four classes of up to 10 children with one instructor

E-commerce will be the main revenue source. All changes are interior.

Thomas Ricci, a senior planner with Stonefield Engineering and Design, argued the site is particularly suited to the use. He pointed to decades of prior variances on the property, including a pizza parlor, a beauty salon, a tutoring business and a co-op school music classroom. He cited Municipal Land Use Law purposes A, G and I, along with the master plan's arts goals.

"It's been a non-residential unit for 30-plus years," said Thomas Ricci, senior planner, Stonefield Engineering and Design.

Board members asked about the history of failed tenants, signage, lighting, deliveries, strollers, noise and bathrooms. Most members came down in favor.

"I think for me, I need to see a business there," said John Caulfield, Board Member.

Board Member Angela Harris supported both variances. She noted that no residential conversion would lower parking needs. "It's unreasonable to expect an owner to knock down income-producing space for parking," said Harris.

Pierce Conway is a Montclair native who leased the space as the landlord's agent. He said he turned away coffee shops, nail salons and other high-traffic prospects in favor of this tenant. He also noted that one prior tenant stayed 14 years.


Parking Became the Real Fight

Why it matters: The ordinance requires parking spaces, and the project has zero. The site is in a congested area near a school and a high school. Because the applicant's arrangements with neighbors are informal, the surrounding streets would absorb any overflow.

Where things stand: Traffic engineer Andrew Viscio of Stonefield Engineering and Design based his analysis on the ITE Trip Generation Manual and compared the use to a library. He estimated trips well below the 50-trip threshold. He counted about 128 spaces within a two-block radius.

"At a minimum, in that 2-block radius, there were 19 available parking spaces during the weekday," said Viscio. His study found at least 44 open spaces on Saturdays.

Rodriguez described a patchwork of informal arrangements:

  • One weekday employee space at 157 Forest Street
  • Two customer spaces on weekends and evenings at 151 Forest Street
  • Roughly eight spots at the co-op school on weekends
  • A few spaces at Fit Loft

"We have a commitment for one employee parking during weekdays," said Rodriguez.

The other side: Karen Janifer, a Forest Street resident of more than five years, said she likes the concept but opposes the location. She described daily competition for parking and blocked driveways. She added that pressure comes from multi-family conversions, the school, commuters and the farmers market. She questioned whether hearing notices reach tenants. She also asked for off-street commitments beyond two or three spots, and she disagreed that the business would benefit current residents.

Viscio responded directly to her concerns. "I can't think of a use that would generate less traffic and parking," said Viscio.

Conway said he can usually park in front of the building. He argued that school pickup is crowded no matter who occupies the storefronts.

Several board members pushed for firmer parking promises, even while supporting the project.

"I think the parking needs to be guaranteed for the two employees," said Jerry Simon, Board Vice Chair.

Jamena Grant, Board Second Alternate, urged the applicants to "merge your programming with the traffic study and then come up with something more comprehensive."

Board Member Jay Church took a more relaxed view. "Finding parking is just going to be part of the adventure, like it is in most places in Montclair," said Church.


Five Conditions, Loose Parking Strings

Where things stand: The applicant's attorney offered a condition requiring a signage plan for Planning Department review. Board Member Jonathan Moore proposed conditions on signage, exterior lighting and a good-faith parking effort.

"I would put as a condition that the store signage be compliant where it meets the code," said Moore.

Board Alternate Cruz, who could not vote, argued for guaranteed employee parking. "I personally do believe that as employers, you have a responsibility to your employees to have them have parking," said Cruz.

Church briefly asked for written parking agreements. He withdrew the request after Board Chair John McCullough warned that requiring leases could undercut the good-faith approach.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: McCullough read five conditions into the record:

  1. Non-illuminated signs that conform to the ordinance
  2. Exterior lighting at the Planning Department's direction, if deemed necessary for safety
  3. A good-faith effort to secure off-site parking consistent with hearing testimony
  4. Adherence to all representations made at the hearing
  5. Payment of inspection and escrow fees

"The applicant shall make a good faith effort to obtain offsite parking consistent with the testimony at the hearing," said McCullough. He also encouraged a committed employee space and clear communication to customers about where to park.

An unidentified board member moved approval. The board approved Application 2977 by voice vote:

  • Result: McCullough declared "the application is approved"
  • Tally: not stated; ayes were heard
  • Abstentions: one heard, member not identified

Third Alternate Charles Griffith backed the project but could not vote. "I would be in favor, but I am not voting," said Griffith.

Who gains and who bears the risk:

  • Contexto LLC and the property owner gain a tenant for space that has sat empty since 2025.
  • Families gain a children's arts and literacy option.
  • Forest Street neighbors carry the parking risk. Their protection rests on informal arrangements and a good-faith standard, not enforceable leases.

What's next: The applicant must coordinate any exterior lighting with the Planning Department. Residents worried about parking should watch whether the informal arrangements described at the hearing hold up. That includes the space at 157 Forest Street, the spaces at 151 Forest Street, and the co-op school and Fit Loft lots.


Minor Items

  • Oct. 21, 2026, minutes: The board took a voice vote; one abstention was heard, and the result was not stated.
  • Application 2980, 18 Miller Street: Eligible members took a voice vote on the resolution for Homes of Montclair Ecumenical Corporation; one abstention was heard, and the result was not stated.