

Montclair Zoning Board Tables Orange Road ADU After Split Signals
Zoning Board of Adjustment • MontclairNovember 19, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Montclair's Zoning Board of Adjustment spent most of its Nov. 18, 2026, meeting on a 304-square-foot backyard cottage at 28 Orange Road and could not find a majority for it. The applicants tabled their accessory dwelling unit (ADU) to Jan. 20, 2027, after a nearly 100-minute hearing. The same night, the board approved a garage on a landlocked lot 7-0 and a front porch 5-1, which shows how much harder ADU cases are than conventional variances.
- Orange Road ADU tabled to Jan. 20, 2027, after members split over setbacks, coverage and a barrier-free bathroom.
- Accessibility rule becomes a flashpoint: One member called a code-compliant bathroom a condition of his support.
- 7-0 approval for a 22-by-24-foot garage on a 1,966-square-foot lot reachable only by easement.
- 94 Warren Place porch approved 5-1. Vice Chair Jerry Simon warned of a "slow creep" of exceptions.
Orange Road ADU Hits a Wall, Gets a Redo
Why it matters: This is an early test of Montclair's ADU ordinance on a very small lot. The board's message was clear: redesign the project rather than ask for a vote.
Where things stand: Richard and Susan Stillman want to build a two-story, 16-by-19-foot ADU in the rear yard of their R-2 zone home (Application 2987) for their two adult daughters.
"The reason we need an ADU is that we have 2 adult children who live with us and probably will continue to," said Mrs. Stillman, co-applicant.
The project needs a long list of variances:
- Setbacks: 3.5 feet at the rear, and 3.5 and 3.75 feet at the sides, where 6 feet is required.
- Rear-yard footprint: 28% of the rear yard, where 25% is the maximum.
- Impervious coverage: 60.5% (1,701 square feet), where 55% (1,543.85 square feet) is allowed.
- Accessibility: a bathroom that does not meet the New Jersey Barrier-Free Subcode.
- Parking: no off-street parking space.
The Stillmans pointed to a public parking garage across the street. They offered to remove asphalt, drop vinyl siding, add a path and manage stormwater.
The bathroom fight: The applicants said a compliant bathroom would not fit in a 304-square-foot unit. Board Member Charles Griffith tied the requirement to the ordinance's aging-in-place intent.
"I'll only approve it with a code-compliant bathroom," said Griffith.
Board Member Jamena Grant also said skipping the requirement would not work. Board Member Angela Harris questioned the rule itself, given the ordinance's 300-square-foot minimum unit size.
"I honestly, I have an issue with the barrier-free requirement in our zoning ordinance," said Harris.
The other side: Vice Chair Jerry Simon argued that the property's constraints mean a person with mobility limits would not choose the unit anyway. He backed the project.
"I'm fully in favor of this, and I think that we could put some moderate restrictions in order to accommodate some of the flooding and stormwater and other concerns," said Simon.
A neighbor at 30 Orange Road supported the plan and agreed to a recorded access easement across her property. The ADU would be reached by a side passage only about 1.7 to 2.8 feet wide. "And so we're here fully supportive of them," she said. No one spoke in opposition.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Members' positions broke down this way:
- Opposed: Board Member Jay Church and Griffith. "I don't think you can put an ADU on a property of this size," said Church.
- Conflicted: Harris and Board Member Jonathan Moore, who urged "a more creative design to minimize the impact on this lot because it is a smaller lot."
- In favor: Simon.
- Calling for redesign: Grant, who said "the design of this unit doesn't work for this space."
Board Chair John McCullough suggested the applicants could table the case. "I think this is a proposal that really could benefit from some additional work," he said. The Stillmans agreed, and the board took a voice vote to carry the case.
The outcome matters beyond one family. It shows that setbacks, drainage and accessibility rules can collide on small lots, which could limit where ADUs are practical.
What's next: The case returns Jan. 20, 2027, at 7 p.m. No new notice is required unless the revised plan creates new variances. Board counsel listed what the revised plan should address:
- impervious coverage
- a walkway
- condenser unit placement
- barrier-free issues
- lighting
- a 3-foot pedestrian access easement
Counsel also discussed a fully conforming layout and a standard stormwater condition.
Landlocked Lot Gets Its Garage Back
Why it matters: The board granted a use variance (a D variance, which permits a use the zone does not otherwise allow) because the lot was extremely undersized and reachable only by easement.
Where things stand: Rashmi Sharma sought approval for a 22-by-24-foot detached garage on Lot 30 behind 95 South Mountain Avenue (Application 2977). The lot was created by a three-lot subdivision more than 80 years ago.
Builder Sokol Sulo of Step Right Construction and planner Tanya Marione testified for the applicant:
- The lot is about 1,966 square feet, roughly 15% of the 13,000-square-foot minimum.
- It can be reached only through a shared easement dating to 1948.
- A previous garage, attached to the neighbor's at 91 South Mountain, was removed because it was dilapidated. The application had wrongly said it burned.
"In this case, that lot is inaccessible to the street," said Marione, professional planner for the applicant.
The bulk relief requested was substantial:
- Front yard: 27.3 feet, where 50 feet is required.
- Side yards: 2.2 and 3.9 feet, where 12 and 18 feet are required.
- Rear yard: 8.7 feet, where 30 feet is required.
- Building coverage: 26.9%, where 20% is allowed.
- Impervious coverage: 71.6%, where 40% is allowed.
The ADU question: Members asked about drainage, clearance, the 15-foot height limit, turning radius, snow removal and lighting. The chair also raised whether the garage could later become an ADU. "The town has authorized ADUs to be built," said McCullough.
"Mr. Chairman, there is no present plan to convert it to an ADU," replied attorney Gregory Massara. He added that any future ADU would face the same lot problems.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The garage passed on a 7-0 roll call (For: 7, Against: 0). "The lot is landlocked. There's really nothing else you can do with it," said Simon. Church cited "the uniqueness of this property."
The approval carries these conditions:
- stormwater management
- binding representations by the applicant
- payment of fees
- a corrected plot plan
- a minimum 3-foot setback from the 91 South Mountain side
- lighting that conforms to code
Those conditions protect the attached neighbor. After the vote, Massara said he thought one member had voted no. That question was not resolved on the record.
Small Porch, Big Warning
Why it matters: The board approved a front-yard variance of less than 2 feet. The lone dissent flagged a longer-term concern about small exceptions adding up.
Where things stand: Kieran Callaghan sought a 53.25-foot front setback at 94 Warren Place (Application 2985). The neighborhood average requires 55.2 feet. The project is an aesthetic upgrade of a 1957 house with Hardie siding, new doors and windows, and an open covered porch, not the enclosed porch listed on the agenda.
The owner said he consulted neighbors, including at 88 Warren. The project also went before the Historic Preservation Commission. Members asked:
- why the porch is 8 feet deep, when 6 feet would comply
- how the condenser would be screened
- whether trees would be removed
The other side: "It's a slow creep, you know, and not so much for this one, but the next one might be, you know, a little more than 2 feet," said Simon.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The variance passed 5-1 (For: Harris, Church, Moore, Griffith, McCullough; Against: Simon). Conditions include binding representations, inspection and escrow fees, and replacement of the evergreen tree to be removed.
Minor Items
- Minutes: The board took a voice vote on the Nov. 4 minutes; no corrections were noted.
- Forest Street resolution: The board voted by voice on a resolution memorializing a use variance for a children's bookstore and learning center at 150-152 Forest Street (Contexto LLC). One wording correction was made.
- Hollywood Street extension: William Baggett received a one-year extension for a detached two-car garage at 5 Hollywood Street (Application 2619). Members said it runs to Nov. 18, 2027.
Looking ahead: The Orange Road ADU returns Jan. 20, 2027, at 7 p.m. It is the clearest test yet of whether Montclair's ADU rules can work on its smallest lots.