

PSEG Eyes Township-Owned Claremont Site for Substation, Residents Push Back
Township Council • MontclairOctober 20, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
PSEG told the Montclair Township Council on Oct. 20, 2026, that the town's 100-year-old substation must be replaced. Its preferred new site is 205 Claremont, the township's own municipal complex property. No vote was taken, but more than two dozen public speakers opposed the site or demanded transparency, and council members questioned why PSEG's choice had shifted.
- PSEG names 205 Claremont as its preferred substation site for about 19,000 customers. No council action was taken.
- Residents press the council to separate utility zoning from the municipal complex redevelopment plan.
- Surveillance advocates return, again without a vote. The council approved 6-1 bidding for automated parking enforcement.
- The tree ordinance rewrite was pulled 7-0 to settle disputes over dead trees and hardship waivers.
- Upper Mountain Avenue parking rules advanced 5-2. Two members objected that public input comes after striping.
A Century-Old Substation Needs a New Home
Why it matters: The substation serves about 19,000 Montclair customers, including schools, emergency facilities and places of worship. PSEG's preferred site is township-owned land next to homes and downtown.
Where things stand: PSEG representatives said the 1925 facility needs a full replacement. "The existing substation is 100 years old and has reached the end of its useful life cycle," said Gary Williams, PSEG regional public affairs manager for Essex County.
PSEG walked through its search. The utility abandoned 651 and 665-679 Bloomfield Ave. after the Montclair Center Business Improvement District and the prior administration opposed them. "Without that municipal and stakeholder support, the properties were no longer viable, and PSE&G subsequently terminated the contracts," said Alan Young, PSE&G project manager.
Historic designation ruled out 33 Cottage Place. PSEG is taking another look at 101 Greenwood Ave., the DeCamp site, because its owner may be open to selling. PSEG now prefers 205 Claremont because it has less underground congestion and sits close to existing circuits. The utility said it needs about 2 acres at minimum. The station would be unmanned, with sound walls if needed and a facade and landscaping designed with the township.
The other side: Council members were skeptical. Councilmember D'Amato noted that PSEG had called Portland Place its preferred site in August 2025. "You very firmly said that the Portland Place location was your preferred location," he said. PSEG answered that later survey work found more underground congestion at Portland Place, which remains viable but is no longer preferred.
Councilmember Harrison pressed for details on the size of the structure and its setbacks. After one response, he said: "That's not a particularly good answer." Another councilmember noted on the record that building at Portland Place would have cost two families their homes. A member urged PSEG to keep searching widely.
What's next: The presentation was informational only. Before the public session, the council met in a closed executive session on an employment matter and a redevelopment and real estate matter.
Neighbors Organize Against Claremont Rezoning
Why it matters: Many speakers argued that a zoning change, not PSEG's preference, would lock in the site. They also warned it would set a precedent for utilities on other public land.
Where things stand: Opponents filled the public comment period, each limited to three minutes. Susan Severin, a board member at The Chesapeake condominiums on Claremont Avenue, said residents never chose to live beside a substation. "Is it fair to us to be the guinea pigs when it really comes down to it," she asked.
Other speakers focused on the process:
- Glenn Pasquarell, owner of 201 Claremont Ave., said public records requests turned up no documents explaining the switch. He also said an owner next to Portland Place is willing to sell. "You cannot vote on Ordinance 2639 unless these questions are answered," he said.
- Michelle Robinette Hoth said PSEG's reasons for dropping Portland Place do not line up and asked for one documented answer.
- Brian Bambrick, a resident of 234 Claremont Ave., asked what testing showed congestion underground. He suggested a mobile substation or shifting load to other substations.
- Regan Caton cited township records, including an appraiser engagement letter, committee agendas and a street access agreement. She argued the sale had moved past its early stages and asked about a linked purchase of the Mills Building.
The zoning fight: Peg Sipe called the municipal complex redevelopment plan close to spot zoning, meaning a zoning change that benefits one parcel or deal. She warned that allowing utilities in the P zone could open the door to data centers. Matt Horrigan, owner of 63 Park St., warned that PSE&G would stop looking elsewhere once the site was zoned. Roddy Moore asked the council to limit the plan to the utility use alone. He cited a 2005 engineering assessment to argue the township had not shown 205 Claremont is beyond saving.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Concerns ranged from the character of the neighborhood to health, property values and street life. Tony Schumann, a professor emeritus of architecture, said a substation without a front door would kill street life along Claremont's long frontage. Not everyone rejected the project outright. Toni Martin acknowledged a new station is needed but asked for public give-and-take. Maggie Gerolimon, a Portland Place resident, said she did not want it in her neighborhood either. The council did not act on the redevelopment plan.
Surveillance Advocates Keep Waiting
Why it matters: Speakers warned that data from automated license plate readers (ALPRs) could reach federal immigration enforcement regardless of state law. They also noted there is no formal way to force an item onto the council's agenda.
Where things stand: William DeBear cited a Sept. 30 report that federal authorities claim they are entitled to ALPR data. "I renew my request that the council put the proposed ordinance on the agenda for approval at its next meeting," he said.
Parker Cheehock said a survey found 46 fixed ALPRs at 20 locations in town. "I'm here again to ask that you place the ACLU's community control over police surveillance legislation" on the agenda, he said. He also asked for written rules on how items get onto the agenda, and for township alerts about ICE activity.
Victoria Luna, a Montclair High School junior, described returning repeatedly without action. "We are tired of waiting," she said. Nola Kim spoke about the chilling effect of surveillance. Asher Bergman said at least three ALPRs operate near his home.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The council did not schedule the ordinance. It did authorize competitive bidding for automated parking enforcement under state law (NJSA 40A:11-4.3), replacing a single-vendor approach. Staff said the cameras sit on sidewalks about 2 feet from the curb and are not ALPR cameras. Councilmember Williams asked that bidders disclose how they control and retain data. Township Manager Marks said the parking system is separate from police systems. "It's a closed-loop system," Marks said.
Vote: For: 6, Against: 1 (Harrison), Absent: 0.
Tree Ordinance Goes Back for Repairs
Why it matters: The rewrite of Chapter 324 would replace a 2012 law. It adds replacement requirements and fees and spreads enforcement across several township offices.
Where things stand: Public speakers backed the draft but flagged gaps. Anna Grossman asked the council to:
- close a loophole that lets healthy large trees be removed
- give the Planning Board power to deny permits
- define the tree fund
- set the $450 in-lieu fee at the full cost of planting
- reconsider the exemption for invasive trees
Bergman worried about how much discretion the town arborist would have.
The other side: On the dais, Councilmember Williams said, "I do have an issue with the dead tree requirement." He called it a disincentive and an affordability concern for property owners. Councilmember D'Amato pointed to inconsistencies in the text and to the number of offices administering the law, though he supported tougher penalties. "I don't want us to be the most ambitious township, the most ambitious municipality when it comes to administrative complexity," he said. Councilmember Harrison signaled a bundle of amendments, including a definition of hardship.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The council debated whether to amend and adopt the ordinance or reintroduce it, then pulled it to the next meeting. Vote: For: 7, Against: 0, Absent: 0. Another member urged colleagues to preserve as much of the published draft as possible. That member noted the town has a new part-time arborist and a state grant.
What's next: Amendments will circulate in writing before the next meeting.
Street Changes: Build First, Ask Later?
Where things stand: The Upper Mountain Avenue ordinance updates parking rules to match new striping for a chicane, a set of curves that forces drivers to slow down. The township's Complete Streets director said parking would decrease modestly and that demand there comes mostly from service vehicles. The public will be heard at second reading.
The other side: Councilmember Harrison objected to taking public comment only after the striping is down. "I like giving the public a chance to participate before the lines are there," he said. The director pointed to a forthcoming local safety action plan that will gather community input on streets like Claremont. A member again asked the Complete Streets board to hold evening meetings.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: For: 5 (Mayor Baskerville, Deputy Mayor Anderson, Councilmembers Birmingham, D'Amato and Williams), Against: 2 (Harrison, Toler), Absent: 0.
Safe Routes to School: The council carried the grant resolution to Nov. 10. Vote: For: 7, Against: 0, Absent: 0.
- The application is due Nov. 13.
- One member said they would not vote for it without a binding commitment to safe pickup and drop-off at Montclair High School and Montclair Early Learning Academy.
- The grant program does not fund drop-off zones, so the sponsor agreed to work with the parking utility, the traffic bureau and the schools on a parallel track.
Minor Items
- Firehouse 1 roof: The council approved a $54,700 RSZ Architects contract, 7-0, for design and construction administration of a roof replacement. Councilmember Birmingham said "this is our newest municipal building that needs substantial work."
- Snow protocol: The council amended the protocol 5-1 (D'Amato opposed; Anderson's vote not recorded) to exclude Wildwood Avenue frontage designated for affordable housing. The amended protocol then passed 7-0.
- Ordinances: A business and rental unit liability insurance registry (02647) passed with six recorded yes votes. Loading zones (02648) and accessible parking (02649) changes each passed 7-0. A vehicles and traffic amendment (02646) was deferred to Dec. 8.
- Bill list: Approved 7-0 after members pulled a purchase order for stairs between the North Bulletin deck and the YMCA. The required emergency resolution had not yet been circulated.
- Tax relief deadline: Eligible seniors and renters must file the state's PAS-1 property tax relief form by Nov. 2. Hearings on the 2027 budget begin the same day.
Looking Ahead
The Safe Routes to School resolution returns Nov. 10, three days before its grant deadline. Amendments to the tree ordinance are due at the next meeting, and Ordinance 02646 returns Dec. 8. The council has not scheduled any action on PSEG's site or the municipal complex redevelopment plan.