

Montclair Council Shelves Municipal Complex Plan Amid Substation Backlash
Township Council • MontclairNovember 10, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Montclair's Township Council on Nov. 10, 2026, pulled the plug, for now, on a redevelopment plan for the municipal complex that residents feared would clear the way for a PSE&G substation at 205 Claremont Avenue. After a rezoning amendment failed 2-5, the council tabled the ordinance indefinitely, 5-2. In the same session, members advanced a tougher tree code and bike-lane parking changes while residents pressed them on transparency and on who gets a say before decisions are made.
- Municipal complex plan tabled indefinitely, 5-2, after an OR-3 rezoning bid failed 2-5
- 11 residents spoke against the plan, and one cited 620 petition signatures demanding transparency
- New tree ordinance introduced over contractor objections; review shortened to 10 business days
- Harrison Avenue bike-lane parking ban advances to a Dec. 8 hearing despite outreach complaints
- Organized speakers press for an ACLU-model surveillance ordinance; the council did not respond
Substation Fears Sink Municipal Complex Plan
Why it matters: The municipal complex is zoned public (P), and a prior council designated it an area in need of redevelopment. Ordinance O-26-39 would have adopted a plan allowing residential, office and possibly public utility uses. Residents saw that utility use as a path to a PSE&G substation near homes. Shelving the plan defers decisions on both the building's future and the substation's location.
Where things stand: Councilmember William Harrison (At-Large, Interim) framed the plan as a way to decide what happens to the municipal building, not to choose a substation site. "I have no views as to where the substation should go," said Harrison.
Harrison first moved to strike public utilities from the plan. The motion died after 1st Ward Councilmember Erik D'Amato withdrew his second to preserve a public hearing. Harrison later moved to rezone the two municipal lots to OR-3 instead, arguing that an appraiser would not value hypothetical uses. "PSE&G is secondary, and that should come after we make our decisions as to what we're doing," said Harrison.
The other side: Most of the council wanted the building assessment before any plan. "I do not believe that we actually need to have a redevelopment plan right now," said D'Amato. He also defended the downtown business improvement district's earlier opposition to a Bloomfield Avenue site: "I believe that the BID was being very normal and proper in just saying you don't put an industrial facility right on your downtown."
Deputy Mayor Susan Shin Andersen said she would not support a plan that included public utility use and wanted the assessment first. 3rd Ward Councilmember Rahum Williams acknowledged the tradeoff: "I get it. I don't want a substation next to my house either. However, I want electricity." 4th Ward Councilmember Aminah Toler said she would vote yes to have a starting point. "As a councilor for the 4th Ward, I am acutely aware of what happens when residents' voices and interests are ignored," said Toler.
A crowded public hearing: Eleven residents spoke on the item, and their focus was process as much as location.
- Glenn Pasquale, who owns property next to the complex, said residents oppose a private decision rather than a substation itself. He asked the council to publish committee recaps and both appraisals.
- Kathleen Bennett, chair of the Montclair Historic Preservation Commission, spoke for herself and colleagues. She said a substation does not fit the Montclair Center Village historic setting.
- Regan Caton reported 620 petition signatures, 137 on paper and 483 online.
- Elizabeth Cahill rejected the "NIMBY" label for the opposition.
- Marianne Riley Appel called any inclusion of the Cornerstone shelter property unethical.
- Other speakers asked about PSE&G's environmental review, possible tax revenue from a substation and alternative sites.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The OR-3 rezoning failed. For: 2 (Harrison, Toler). Against: 5 (Shin Andersen, Birmingham, D'Amato, Williams, Mayor Renee Baskerville). Absent: 0.
The council then tabled the ordinance indefinitely. For: 5. Against: 2 (Harrison, Toler). The property stays zoned for public use, and PSE&G's siting path through this parcel is closed for now.
What's next: The ordinance would have to be reintroduced. Separately, the council approved a contract with RSC Architects for an existing-conditions assessment of the municipal building, with six recorded yes votes. Staff said the assessment takes about 90 days.
Tree Ordinance Clears First Reading
The basics: The proposal repeals and replaces Chapter 324, the township's short existing tree code. The new rules include:
- Stricter removal review by the township arborist
- Replacement requirements scaled to tree size, or a fee in lieu
- One-to-one replacement for hazardous or dead trees
- A dedicated tree fund
- A new category for "extraordinary trees"
Why it matters: Supporters point to documented canopy loss. Anna Grossman cited public records showing at least 4,786 trees removed from 2020 to 2025. Bill Martens, chair of the Montclair Environmental Commission, urged passage and said the ordinance can evolve with data.
The other side: Tree contractors pushed back. CJ Miller, founder of Montclair Tree Experts, objected to exemptions for PSE&G, schools and the township. He said no company like his was consulted. Brian Rombo, a licensed tree expert with a 92-year-old family firm, said permit fees rising from $15 to $100 to $300 would reduce compliance. He also said four replacement trees do not fit small yards and argued that youth planting programs would do more for the canopy.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: 2nd Ward Councilmember Eileen Birmingham consulted the arborist and moved to cut review of average and significant trees from 20 days to 10 business days. The amendment passed 7-0. Introduction passed with six recorded yes votes. Toler's vote was not captured.
A companion amendment to Salary Ordinance O-26-21, which creates positions tied to the tree program, was introduced 7-0. Harrison flagged a discrepancy: "So the ordinance says the community forestry manager is a part-time position, but then I asked what the position is, and what I got from Alicia is it's a full-time position." The council confirmed the role as part time.
What's next: The tree ordinance heads to a second reading, which will affect homeowners and tree contractors.
Bike-Lane Parking Changes Advance, Outreach Questioned
Why it matters: Crews striped the streets before the ordinances arrived, so some residents see the public hearings as after-the-fact ratification.
Where things stand: For Upper Mountain Avenue (O-26-50), the township's Complete Streets director said the change is housekeeping. "It ensures that the township code aligns with where the paint actually is," said Complete Streets Director Neiman. Williams agreed, describing the ordinance as putting in place what already occurred with the chicane restriping.
Toler pressed for more engagement. "There has to be more outreach to the residents in the area where you're recommending these changes," said Toler.
Harrison's amendment added a seventh street segment and clarifying wording. It passed 6-1, with Toler opposed. Because the changes were substantive, the council voted 5-2 to reintroduce the ordinance, with Harrison and Toler opposed.
The other side: On the east side of Harrison Avenue, Toler moved to table the parking ban to Dec. 8, citing 4th Ward residents who did not know about the changes. "I just can't take any more emails, phone calls regarding things that are happening and they're totally unaware," said Toler.
The director said the work is about 90% complete and that delay could add costs. Harrison backed moving forward but criticized the order of operations. "I am supportive of the project. My problem is doing it backwards," said Harrison.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The motion to table failed. For: 3 (Harrison, Toler, Baskerville). Against: 2 (Shin Andersen, D'Amato). Abstain: 2 (Birmingham, Williams).
Introduction then passed. For: 4 (Shin Andersen, Birmingham, D'Amato, Williams). Against: 2 (Toler, Baskerville). Abstain: 1 (Harrison). Cross-talk interrupted the roll call; the result is reflected in the mayor scheduling a hearing.
At least 10 east-side parking spaces are expected to be lost to the bike lane. Cyclists stand to gain: Gigi Drucker, a young resident, urged the council to make bike lanes permanent for safety and the environment. The director committed to improved outreach.
What's next: "Okay, so I'll schedule this hearing for the 8th of December," said Baskerville.
Organized Push for Surveillance Oversight
Why it matters: Speakers warned that technology such as automated license plate readers (ALPRs) can arrive in Montclair without public debate.
Where things stand: A coordinated group of speakers asked the council to schedule an ACLU-model surveillance-technology ordinance:
- William DeBeer, speaking for Montclair Indivisible
- An ACLU-ordinance advocate
- Victoria Luna, a Montclair High School junior
- Nola Kim
- Cassia Lang Robertson
Commenters said the ordinance would require reports, a three-week review period and hearings, not a ban on technology. Luna said the council acted early on immigration but has since ignored surveillance concerns. Robertson cited risks from camera networks, artificial intelligence and ICE targeting. Kim said she has repeated the request without action.
The ACLU advocate also asked the council to revive a tabled agenda-procedures resolution. It would set an eight-day deadline, publicly name sponsors and allow two-minute council responses to public comment.
The other side: No council response was recorded. Separately, resident Tony Martin objected to the mayor's practice of deferring comments on pending ordinances to their hearings.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The council approved a Millennium Communications Group security contract for the Department of Public Works (DPW) on a 7-0 vote. Officials said the cameras cover doors and time clocks and address overnight trespassing at a building. D'Amato asked whether the goal is to link every township facility.
Minor Items
- Affordable housing amendments tabled: Two Chapter 65 amendments were tabled 7-0 to Nov. 24 after the planning director left ill. One covers assisted living and group home definitions; the other sets enforcement provisions, with fines up to $2,000.
- Public pianos delayed: The Downtown Montclair piano agreement was tabled 7-0 to Dec. 8. Williams withdrew a proposal to limit the Church Street piano to Thursday through Sunday, 10 a.m. to 8 p.m.
- Safe Routes to School grant backed, 7-0: Construction of about $1.4M is grant-funded. Roughly $280,000 in soft costs falls to the township.
- Two pulled finance items approved, 7-0: Year-end transfers were driven by a roughly $290,000 unbudgeted fire department retirement payout. A roughly $42,000 emergency replacement of 11 stairs at the North Fullerton Deck prompted debate over prevailing wage costs.
- Consent items approved en bloc, 7-0: These include a donated Clary Anderson Arena locker room, built with $211,000 raised and slated to open by Dec. 15, and a privately funded seating area at Walnut and Grove streets.
Looking Ahead
The affordable housing amendments return Nov. 24. The Harrison Avenue hearing and the piano agreement come back Dec. 8.
The municipal building assessment is expected to take about 90 days. The township manager also reported a state fiscal best-practices score of around 46, slightly above the prior 43 to 44.
Downtown business owner Jeremy Folatana announced an independent nine-candidate slate for the 2027 Montclair Center BID board, citing a lack of transparency.