

Planning Board Urges Council to Revive Original UDO, Rejects Industrial Rezoning
Planning Board • Mills RiverNovember 17, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Mills River's Planning Board told Town Council to take up the original Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) the board recommended. It offered Council's amended version only as a fallback, part of a push to end a stalled, multi-year rewrite of the town's development rules. Separately, the board voted to recommend that Council deny a light-industrial rezoning on Schoolhouse Road, after members weighed farmland, truck traffic near a school and possible 80-foot buildings against a land use map that favored the request.
- Original UDO first, amended UDO second: board's consensus message to Council
- Council's UDO hearing resumes Dec. 10; revised board memo is due Dec. 1
- Recommend denial of 32 Schoolhouse Road rezoning, passed by voice vote; tally not announced
- Staff found the rezoning consistent with the future land use map; majority advised otherwise
Board to Council: Pass the UDO We Sent You
The basics: The UDO is the town's consolidated zoning and development code. Council reconvened its UDO public hearing Oct. 22 and asked the Planning Board to respond to specific revisions in a memo by early December.
Why it matters: The memo shapes whether Mills River adopts a UDO after a stalled multi-year effort. Council will receive it before a new Council takes office.
Where things stand: Planning Director Michael Malecek walked members through Council's revisions:
- A 35-foot cap on residential building heights in all districts
- Reclassifying mixed use as residential, with lower non-residential heights
- New architectural standards for industrial buildings over 35 feet, with Ferncliff Park exempt
- Corrections on manufactured home parks (4 units per acre) and retail plant nurseries
Malecek said heights would be measured from the average finished grade elevation at a building's major corners.
Mixed use sparks pushback: Board Member Jennie Sealey objected to reclassifying mixed-use property as residential, noting that small businesses, including her own, operate there. "I don't think we need to move it to a residential at all," she said.
Malecek said a residential classification can create nonconformities, meaning properties that no longer meet the rules. He said the UDO's amnesty provision makes all existing properties conforming and that the change better reflects how those parcels are actually used.
Board member Amber asked why an existing 80-foot height cap was not being lowered. Malecek said that would be downzoning, which creates nonconformities.
Design standards with a price tag: Board Member Brad Burton said stepped facades on three-story industrial buildings are costly but achievable. "It's easily done, and it's actually pretty classy," he said. Malecek said staff would review architectural compliance and cited the Banner Farm warehouse as an example.
The other side: Members split on how hard to push back. Vice Chair Jim Foster urged sending the UDO back so Council could move ahead. Board Member Mike Cole and Sealey said the original document, which the board recommended unanimously, was ideal and argued against reopening the process. Earlier in the meeting, Cole tied the UDO to the town's long-standing preference for rural character, noting "the council voted 4 to 1 to approve the original UDO."
Burton and Board Chair Lisa Marino favored answering Council's specific requests directly.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The board took no formal vote but reached consensus. Cole framed the first recommendation: "Send back what we recommended the first time, see if there's a way to enact it or pass it." As a second option, the board will concur with Council's changes. Marino said the fallback should read as "something the Board is in favor of and recommends." The memo will also say the town needs to move forward.
Owners of mixed-use parcels have the most at stake in the reclassification. Industrial developers face new design costs on taller buildings.
What's next: Malecek will shorten the draft and present it Dec. 1. "I believe they recessed the hearing again until December 10th," he said of Council's hearing. He said that would mean no re-advertisement is required, but deferred that question to the town attorney. Sealey said public notice of comment opportunities could be better. Cole replied that all meetings are public.
Schoolhouse Road Rezoning Gets Thumbs Down
The basics: Request R2604 would rezone 32 Schoolhouse Road from neighborhood commercial to light industrial. A conventional rezoning opens the parcel to every use allowed in the new district. Conditional zoning, by contrast, can limit what gets built.
Why it matters: The item was tabled Oct. 6. Staff said the board had to act, or Council would hold its hearing without a recommendation. Council has the final say and can still approve the rezoning.
Where things stand: The applicant's representative, Mr. Freeman, noted that the parcel is designated industrial on the future land use map. He said it sits near Bold Rock Cider, Flavor First Growers and Packers, and a grafting operation. "I think this is an easy one because it's squarely within the future land use map," he said.
Burton said staff found the request consistent and that the board was "hobbled" by the adopted map. "I don't see a reason to deny this," he said. Board Member Billy Kimzey agreed the site would be a good industrial location.
The other side: Opponents cited the parcel's current farm use, truck traffic in a school zone and the "rural character" goal of the Mills River Comprehensive Plan. "If we were to zone that industrial, there could be an 80-foot building put on it," said Amber. Cole said he opposed the request because the board cannot know which light-industrial uses would follow.
Sealey left the door open to a different path. "Someone trying to hold on to a rural Mills River is a hard no unless it is conditional, and I'm all up for that," she said.
Who decides consistency: Malecek said that under G.S. 160D-604, the board gives an advisory consistency comment and is not bound by staff's analysis. "That is your role as appointed board members to make that judgment call," he said.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Foster moved to "deny R2604 conventional rezoning request for 32 Schoolhouse Road." The motion was amended to include a statement of inconsistency, and Sealey seconded. Freeman tried to speak during the vote and was told he could not. Marino announced that the motion passed on a voice vote. The tally was not announced.
The recommendation strengthens the hand of residents worried about farmland and school traffic. The applicant may still find a path through conditional zoning, which at least one member signaled she would support.
What's next: The recommendation goes to Town Council for a public hearing. No date was announced.
Minor Items
- Routine approvals: The agenda and the Oct. 6 minutes were approved by voice vote.
Looking Ahead
The Planning Board meets Dec. 1 to finalize its UDO memo. Council resumes its UDO public hearing Dec. 10.