

Zoning Board Approves Little Club Variance 6-1, Conditions Attached
Zoning Board of Adjustment • MillburnNovember 2, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Millburn's Zoning Board of Adjustment on Nov. 2, 2026, approved a D-2 variance for the century-old Little Club Tennis Center at 60 Linden Street by a 6-1 vote. The approval came after the board rejected the club's claim that its permit had been automatically approved. It rests on event caps, curfews and operating limits the club agreed to, though one member acknowledged the township has no bureau to enforce them.
- Little Club D-2 variance approved 6-1, with a 20-event yearly cap and a 40-person limit
- Automatic-approval claim rejected after the board found the club's permit application incomplete
- Three home additions approved on Hobart Avenue, Stewart Road and Lupine Way
- Stewart Road remake adds a front-yard pool beside a 1914 cottage after Historic Preservation sign-off
Little Club Gets Its Variance, and a Rulebook
The basics: A D-2 variance allows a board to approve the expansion of a preexisting nonconforming use, meaning a use that predates current zoning rules. Approval requires five affirmative votes.
Why it matters: The vote preserves a century-old neighborhood club after months of hearings. It also tests how far a volunteer board can rely on conditions it cannot police itself.
Where things stand: The club's representative argued the clubhouse is a century-old accessory structure and that the proposal continues an existing use. The clubhouse would shrink from about 1,900 to about 1,500 square feet. The representative also argued that adding members alone is not an expansion.
Board Attorney Robert Simon walked members through the Belleville standard, under which doubt is resolved against enlargement. He also noted that the applicant bears the burden of proving the baseline use. Members said the record lacked club bylaws and baseline event counts, and they voted to proceed as a D-2 hearing.
A board member asked a pointed question: "If we determine that it does not require a D2, can we still have the opportunity to impose stipulations?"
"No, because then you're not mitigating against the detrimental impacts," Simon answered.
Simon advised that no formal site plan application was needed because the building is getting smaller. He then read back the club's stipulations:
- A reservation system
- No commercial rentals or public advertising
- No amplified outdoor sound
- A cap of 20 member-sponsored events a year, including yoga, painting and birthday parties
- "At no time will the attendance exceed 40 individuals, and that's day or night"
- Events end by 9 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday
- A caretaker on hand at events and a neighbor liaison
- No court lights, camps or pickleball
- Members encouraged to park farther down Linden Street
The club drew lines of its own. Asked about a membership cap, its representative said, "I can't agree to that." The club also would not commit to barring weekday clinics from 9 a.m. to noon or events on Sunday mornings. "If we create this laundry list that is 4 miles long, who's going to enforce all this?" the representative asked.
The other side: "My personal belief is that this neighborhood cannot absorb this, even with the conditions that were identified by the applicant tonight," said Board Member Regina Truitt, the lone no vote.
A member who lives in the neighborhood credited the club's concessions but added: "the negative criteria of it not causing substantial detriment to the public good and to the neighborhood is really — is a challenge."
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The variance passed. For: 6 (Board Member David Bradford, Board Member Roy You, Board Member Beth Zall, Alternate Nilmino Roberts, Vice Chair Gary Rosen and one other member). Against: 1 (Truitt). Board Member Pricilla Saraf, sworn in that night, did not take part.
Supporters cited cosmetic and safety improvements, the smaller clubhouse and the club's concessions. The member who moved approval said bluntly, "There is no enforcement bureau," but concluded the club "is a beneficial use for the neighborhood."
What's next: Neighbors gain caps on events, hours and noise. Because the board has no enforcement staff, compliance will largely depend on complaints.
No Automatic Approval for the Club
Why it matters: An automatic approval would have carried no conditions at all, Simon warned. Rejecting the claim preserved the board's power to attach the limits described above.
Where things stand: The club argued its permit was deemed approved because the zoning officer denied it after the 10-business-day limit, and that the denial gave no stated basis. Simon agreed the denial came after the statutory period. However, he said the board could find the application incomplete or potentially misleading, because it listed a tennis clubhouse use without mentioning club events.
One member framed the logic: "I think it would be faulty to say it's technically out of time when it wasn't complete."
On the second claim, Simon was direct: "Nowhere in our ordinance does it say that the zoning officer needs to give reasons why a particular application is denied."
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The board voted that the application was incomplete, so the denial was not out of time (For: 7, Against: 0). It then rejected the specificity challenge (For: 7, Against: 0). The rulings reinforce the zoning officer's footing on future permit timing disputes.
Three Home Additions Clear the Board
Why it matters: Each project needed relief from zoning standards. None drew objections from residents.
6 Stewart Road (CAL#4102-26): Owner Anthony Sicoli said the 1980s contemporary house is failing and out of character with its historic setting beside a 1914 cottage. The plan reworks the exterior and adds porches and a front-yard pool. It already has Historic Preservation Commission approval. Variances cover:
- A 67.8-foot front setback, against a 116.4-foot neighborhood average
- Rear-yard requirements
- 14.2% building coverage
- The front-yard pool, with roughly 4-foot fencing to meet pool code
"We think it's less traumatic to the site to do this kind of minor renovation," said the applicant's architect, comparing the plan with a 2021 approval. A member of the environmental commission asked about tree cover. Three trees will be removed and six replaced. "I think the relief sought is reasonable," a board member said. The board approved the plan with no dissent heard.
165 Hobart Avenue (CAL#4101-26): The roof rises about 3 feet 6 inches to add a primary bedroom and attic space. Height goes from 21 feet 11 inches to 25 feet 5 inches, under the 35-foot limit. Floor area grows from about 2,421 to 3,105 square feet because the split-level basement counts toward the floor-area limit. The lot is 9,453 square feet in an R-4 zone that requires 20,000 square feet.
"I like the fact that you didn't increase your coverage," one member said. The addition was approved with seven yes votes.
315 Lupine Way (CAL#4103-26): A second floor will go over the existing garage, which sits 7.5 feet from the property line where 8 feet is required. "The 7.5-foot variance is really an extension of an existing condition," the applicant's architect said. The project was approved with no dissent heard.
Minor Items
- Bodwell Terrace extension: Sowmya Jairam received a one-year extension of variance relief for 17 Bodwell Terrace, with no changes to the plan.
- Talbot Court withdrawn: The 31 Talbot Court applicant dropped a bid to keep a raised patio and walls and will comply with the ordinance.
- New member: Pricilla Saraf took the oath for a term expiring Dec. 31, 2026.
- Routine business: The board approved the Sept. 28, 2026, minutes by voice vote and memorialized the 32 Merrywood Drive resolution 6-0. No result was declared on the 14 Canterbury Lane memorialization.
Looking Ahead
New Jersey American Water's request to expand a pole barn at 185 JFK Parkway was delayed after a notice problem. It will be heard on a new date once the application is re-noticed.