

Rooftop Decks Spark Fight Over $1M JFK Parkway Housing Deal
Township Committee • MillburnOctober 20, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Millburn's Township Committee spent the heart of its Oct. 20, 2026, meeting on a deal for a court-mandated affordable housing building at 111 JFK Parkway. The deal adds a story and two rooftop decks in exchange for $1M in developer contributions. Members amended the resolution to put the decks in writing, then held roll calls. The results were not announced, which leaves residents tracking a deal whose final shape still needs confirmation.
- JFK Parkway agreement: One added story and two rooftop decks traded for $900,000 in pump station money and a voluntary $100,000 for the Bauer Community Center.
- Downtown business district overhaul: Tiered fees, wider boundaries and a town-employed economic director advance toward a Nov. 10 hearing.
- Data center ban reintroduced after the planning board found the earlier version inconsistent with the master plan.
- Residents press on downtown poles, senior bus rules and NJ Transit delays.
JFK Parkway Deal: Decks on the Record
The basics: The 111 JFK Parkway project, developed by Kennedy at Millburn LLC, is part of Millburn's Round 3 affordable housing settlement. Round 3 is the township's court-supervised obligation to plan for affordable homes. Resolution 26-241 approves a memorandum of understanding (MOU), a negotiated agreement that modifies the approved project.
Why it matters: The agreement turns a court-mandated building into a negotiated package that includes infrastructure money. It also drew objections over how fully the terms were disclosed, along with worries that it could set a precedent.
Where things stand: Under the MOU, the building gains one story with no increase in maximum height and no added units. The 20% affordable requirement is unchanged. The footprint shrinks and impervious coverage drops. The developer pays $900,000 toward the Hilton Pump Station and a voluntary $100,000 for the Bauer Community Center. The deal also allows two rooftop decks.
The decks became the flashpoint. A committee member who supports the MOU objected that the draft resolution left the decks out and that a requested whereas clause had been refused. The presiding officer said counsel had advised the wording. After discussion, the committee moved an amendment adding a whereas clause for two rooftop decks on the back of the building, with agreed restrictions. It then moved the resolution as amended.
Township Attorney Cantor said the MOU is consistent with the township's affordable housing agreement and that the Fair Share Housing Center is aware of it.
The other side: Early in the meeting, a public commenter asked what "allowable amenities" in the resolution actually means. Jeffrey Feld, a public commenter, questioned how the project affects sewer capacity and the township's third-round compliance credits. "Very important that you look at the bill list because it shows that we have a sanitary sewer infrastructure problem," said Feld.
Some members said they dislike rooftop decks. They backed the deal anyway, citing lower impervious coverage and improved egress.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Roll calls were held on the amendment and on the amended resolution. "Yes" responses were heard on the amendment, but neither result was announced. Individual votes could not be confirmed (For: not announced, Against: not announced, Absent: not announced).
If adopted, the deal gives the township $1M toward sewer infrastructure and a community center. The developer gains added space and amenities. The affordable share stays fixed. Residents worried about sewer capacity and precedent got answers on paper but not a guarantee.
In closing comment, Phil Kirsch, a public commenter, thanked the committee for clarifying the rooftop decks in the resolution. Al Carlin, a public commenter, thanked members for the explicit agreement language and criticized the developer.
What's next: Residents should confirm the final vote outcome with the township clerk.
SID Overhaul Heads to Nov. 10 Hearing
Why it matters: Ordinances 2781-26 and 2784-26 change what downtown and outer-district businesses pay. They also shift the economic development director's salary and benefits toward the township budget.
Where things stand: Presenters said the changes follow nearly two years of subcommittee work. The Special Improvement District (SID) is a self-assessing business district. Its former director left over a lack of benefits.
The reconstituted SID would use tiered pricing, with downtown businesses paying more. Its boundaries would expand down Main Street and east on Millburn Avenue. A new economic development director would be a township employee working in Town Hall. Pricing numbers are not yet set.
Members raised concern about the order of the two measures, saying the director ordinance should not trail the SID ordinance. They agreed that the split of costs between the township and the SID must be known before the final hearing.
The other side: In final public comment, Feld said he was not consulted. He asked for a blacklined copy of the roughly 40-page document, which would show exactly what changed. He also drew a distinction between property owners and business owners, two groups whose interests in an assessment district can diverge. Another resident welcomed the SID.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Both ordinances were moved on first reading by roll call. Results were not announced. Downtown merchants face higher tiers than businesses farther out. Newly included businesses along Main Street and Millburn Avenue would join the district. Taxpayers will want to see the funding split before Nov. 10.
What's next: The public hearing is set for Nov. 10, 2026.
Data Center Ban Gets a Procedural Fix
Why it matters: Ordinance 2783-26 repairs the defect that stalled Millburn's earlier ban. It also responds to regional worry over a proposed data center in Kenilworth.
Where things stand: The ordinance defines data centers and excludes limited-scale and residential computing. It prohibits data centers in all zoning districts, with future review. The presiding officer said the planning board found the earlier ban inconsistent with the master plan. A planning board subcommittee fixed those issues, and the full board was set to consider the ordinance the next day, Oct. 21.
The other side: Alex, a Union resident, thanked the committee. He cited diesel generators, infrasound and the proposed Kenilworth site. "Please consider a dBC scale ordinance," said Alex. The dBC scale is a C-weighted decibel measure that better captures low-frequency sound. Officials responded that Millburn was banning data centers and would look at the dBC idea.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The ordinance was moved on first reading by roll call. The result was not announced. The ban closes the door on data center development across all of Millburn's zoning districts. Neighboring residents' push for noise standards remains under review.
What's next: Planning board review comes first, followed by a public hearing on Nov. 10, 2026.
Residents Push on Poles, Buses and Trains
Why it matters: Public comment showed how daily life in Millburn is shaped by a downtown traffic pilot, senior transportation rules and regional rail.
Where things stand: Bonnie Wapsie, a public commenter, said Millburn Avenue looks like a construction zone and asked for stationary metal signs. "Your yellow little poles fall over all the time and people can break their necks," said Wapsie.
Officials explained the barriers are part of a three-to-two-lane prototype. The township plans widened sidewalks and permanent bump-outs. Safety sticks reviewed by police will replace some of the bollards.
Reports also said a meeting with Essex County on Wyoming Avenue traffic is planned, and a non-binding resolution may come by Nov. 10. PSE&G road restoration will extend to spring 2027.
On senior transportation, Carlin asked for more options. Trina Franco, chair of the Senior Citizens Committee, read the rules. "The senior bus provides free service for township residents 62 years and older, 4 days a week," said Franco. Rides must be reserved by phone a day ahead, and there is no voicemail. One member called the rules troubling. Another official said he is researching Montclair's ride-subsidy model. Township Administrator McDonald said he would speak with the senior citizen coordinator.
On transit, one member said commutes to Manhattan average about 2.5 hours each way. The member urged accountability from Amtrak, NJ Transit and the state.
What's next: The presiding officer suggested bringing a resolution to the governor's office at the next meeting.
Minor Items
- Town Hall: Final passage was moved on a $2.5M bond ordinance (up to $2,380,952 in bonds or notes), followed by the construction contract, Resolution 26-242. Reports noted Moody's reaffirmed the township's AAA rating.
- Tree appeal: Members moved to overturn the forester's denial at 37 Byron Road, citing a documented allergy concern. Replacement rules still apply.
- Block 702, Lots 8 and 9: Ordinance 2782-26 starts an acquisition for flood mitigation, with the flooding building prioritized.
- First readings: Stormwater Ordinance 2779-26 and Historic Preservation Checklist Ordinance 2780-26 head to Nov. 10. Kirsch said, "I was pretty much blown away by the application checklist."
- Final passage moved: Pet grooming in the B-3 zone (2769-26) and a Community Service Award (2777-26). The Fire Department's 150th anniversary was also proclaimed.
Looking Ahead
The Nov. 10, 2026, meeting brings hearings on the SID, the economic director, the data center ban, stormwater, the historic checklist and the Block 702 acquisition. A possible NJ Transit resolution and a Wyoming Avenue resolution may also be on the agenda.